GoutPatrol
Forgotten in his cell
That would be a fixed Cascade.
And you can probably make the Cascade "as you cast it instead of ETB" effect on Fairies dominance in standard the year before.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Magic: the Gathering |OT4| Izzet Me; Izzet You? A Love Story
- Thread starter The Technomancer
- Start date
- Status
That would be a fixed Cascade.
And you can probably make the Cascade "as you cast it instead of ETB" effect on Fairies dominance in standard the year before.
Except in living end
Keru_Shiri
Member
I was rocking the BBE>Blightning Jund decks when I got back into Magic. Looking back and knowing the era of JtMS and all that bullshit was right around the corner, I have no regrets.
Cascade, as much as I love it, is a bad mechanic, though.
Cascade, as much as I love it, is a bad mechanic, though.
I meant competitive. 14th place doesn't mean anything at all.
I think Cascade was a mistake and they know that. But I wouldn't be shocked to see the odd Shardless Agent-style card pop up in supplemental sets here or there.
I never realized what a good sacrifice outlet Greater Gargadon is until today. Super weird how it just clicked for me.
Takes a lot to get to 14th place. I would say you'd be best to keep an eye on any decks in the top 32 - 64, as placing in those spots is nothing to sneeze at.
I never realized what a good sacrifice outlet Greater Gargadon is until today. Super weird how it just clicked for me.
Takes a lot to get to 14th place. I would say you'd be best to keep an eye on any decks in the top 32 - 64, as placing in those spots is nothing to sneeze at.
If Twin were to get banned tomorrow, Restore Balance becomes interesting, because it's great against the midrange/aggro decks, but is non-competitive with combo.
While 14th place isn't bad for a result it is an outlier for the deck. If we see it perform consistently then we could talk. The same event had a slivers deck at 5th, should we talk about how broken slivers are?
No, but 5th place is even better. I'm making the argument that decks that place highly in an event at least warrant looking into. 14th and 5th are great finishes. I guess I wasn't really commenting on the broken nature of things the way you guys were. Carry on.
divisionbyzorro
Member
This is essentially the crux of the argument for banning Twin - you expand the metagame significantly.
As I've said before, I'm happy to get Twin banned if you give back Seething Song. Storm is much easier to hate out than Twin, so it wouldn't clamp down on the metagame quite so hard, but it would give people like me a deck that they would love to play.
EDIT: Also, I'm glad to see that Ugin is, in fact, really good in Modern RG Tron. I always thought it was silly that people were immediately dismissing it because it cost 8 instead of 7.
I top 4'd one of those premier iqs a few months back with a tier 2 deck and made some pretty big misplays along the way including a series of them that cost me the top 4 match. It's not as impressive as you think lol.
Speaking of tournaments, I'm very undecided what I'm going to play at the invitational next week. Standard I'm leaning towards atarka red since I don't have a whole lot of experience against those morph fuckers. In Modern I'd normally go with Scapeshift but every big tournament I've played it in has been a disaster even though I've been playing it almost weekly for the last 14 months to local and smaller tournament success. Leaning towards Jund since it's been testing well against everything except for Junk... and even that's definitely winnable. Twin is probably the right choice but the thought of twin mirrors makes me ill.
This
"If you dare root around in my head, Beleren, I think you'll find those clouds overhead are suddenly full of lightning bolts that are all, coincidentally, aimed at you," said Ral Zarek in a low voice.
"Then can you just tell me where we're going?" Beleren asked.
"You'll see soon enough."
"You realize, 'You'll see soon enough' is exactly the kind of thing people say right before I immediately dive into their minds."
Ral looked over his shoulder at the mind mage. "Did you know lightning strikes the Tenth more often than any other district? Do you know why that is?"
"You?"
Ral smirked. "Gold star."
"Then can you just tell me where we're going?" Beleren asked.
"You'll see soon enough."
"You realize, 'You'll see soon enough' is exactly the kind of thing people say right before I immediately dive into their minds."
Ral looked over his shoulder at the mind mage. "Did you know lightning strikes the Tenth more often than any other district? Do you know why that is?"
"You?"
Ral smirked. "Gold star."
is embarrassing.
divisionbyzorro
Member
It reads like a screenplay. That dialogue could absolutely work if sold correctly by the right actors, but reads like a ball of cheese.
Sometimes I wish I could play with oversized cards. I never knew what the heck was going on with Underworld Connections, but it looks good when the image is large enough to take in the detail.. Yeong-Hao Han may not be renowned in the mtg art community but I've always liked his work.
On the card this art looks like a mesh of a tunnel hideout, but blown up it looks like a seedy underground Ravnica marketplace.
---
It should be noted I did not read this Uncharted Realms. The only lore I've been interested in has pretty much been limited to Innistrad. Even that wasn't necessarily great, I'm just a sucker for the gothic horror theme.
On the card this art looks like a mesh of a tunnel hideout, but blown up it looks like a seedy underground Ravnica marketplace.
---
It should be noted I did not read this Uncharted Realms. The only lore I've been interested in has pretty much been limited to Innistrad. Even that wasn't necessarily great, I'm just a sucker for the gothic horror theme.
Seems like pretty boilerplate Fantasy writing tbh. Other than the gold star bit I don't think it would have been out of place in something like the old Forgotten Realms books that I read when I was a kid. It's certainly not great but expecting better from a snippet of flavor intended to help sell packs of cardboard is expecting a bit much.
His RtR basics are amazing.
Considering they used to write actual novels and they were then reduced to this, I don't feel bad for expecting more.
This is why I don't read them. The writing is horrendous.
Who says the novels were any better?
People who read them? I mean I haven't read any of them since high school, and I'm sure some were better than others, but I don't remember them being THIS bad.
SigmasonicX
Member
I thought the story was fine other than that part. *shrug*
I had those in mind when I praised his art. Even the basic mountain, being my least favorite of the five, is still distinctive and beautiful.
His art likes to accentuate sharp points and edges (especially in RtR) like Raymond Swanland while somehow maintaining a recognizable and distinctive style.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
I couldn't figure out why there was a heart at the end of this post. (lol)
Dude, cascading into Abrupt Decay is total BS.
I read all that dialogue in my head with Jace being played by that guy that played Peter on Heroes and Ral's dialogue by the guy who played Mark Sloan on Grey's Anatomy. I'm pretty sure both of those dudes could deliver the dialogue exactly as written.
Living End, Restore Balance? Also, Hypergenesis is banned because Cascade exists. Its not even just the brokenness of the mechanic. Its mindless 2 for 1s and the rate of return on a 3/2 haste is too high to also get to Cascade any 3 or less CMC spell that you get. You're basically getting a 3/2 for free on top of whatever the payment is for the spell you get. 3/2 haste isn't a bad return even if you turn over Thoughtseize or Bolt.
The Technomancer
card-carrying scientician
MTG lore is interesting. Like, Uncharted Realms is often pretty awful, and no-one I know reads it, but we all care enough about the story to find out second hand. Everyone in my playgroup has a handle on what's going on, and we all talk about it, but none of us actually want to read it.
From the bit I've read you might want to go back and reevaluate. My limited experience would put them on par with the slightly below average Forgotten Realms books and that writing is probably on the lower end of that range but it's comparable. Uncharted Realms stuff probably ends up averaging pretty low on that scale but it's not like series like the FR, Warhammer, or MtG books were very good on average.
So I had a bit of a shitty day so went by the store to get some Khans packs, just to open them and perhaps find a fetch land. Well my GF helped me with opening and in her very first pack a Wooded Foothills, but then in my second to last pack (bought 10 packs for 34 euros) I found a Foil Windswept Heath! Haven't felt so excited in a long time.
But now the question. Should I hold on to them and wait for them to rise a bit, or just sell them and get my own set of regular windswept heaths?
But now the question. Should I hold on to them and wait for them to rise a bit, or just sell them and get my own set of regular windswept heaths?
Except for cascading into tarmogoyf and sometimes liliana, I'd almost rather have a siege rhino if I'm paying 4 for a creature. You get value but you're still stuck with a 3/2 body after the fact. Assuming you actually cascade into a relevant spell.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Some of the UR series are written by Sam Stoddard. Yes, developer Sam Stoddard.
Cascading into anything in a well-constructed Jund deck is good, e.g. casting BBE is always good.
Siege Rhino can at least just get PTE'd and die. Pathing a BBE works, but its still a 2 for 1 because the Jund player got whatever they cascaded into. If they Cascaded into Lightning Bolt, its the same thing as Siege Rhino. If they Cascaded into Liliana, you're just fucked. The overall return on BBE is way better than Siege Rhino in reality because level of variance on the Cascade is at the low end, very close to or equal to Siege Rhino, to on the high end just offensively above Siege Rhino.
This is bad writing no matter how you cut it. I read a lot of fantasy, and have recently been reading Pathfinder novel (tie-ins with the popular tabletop RPG) and the writing, in general, is much, much better than the quoted passage. No editor worth their chops would let dialogue like that slide.
I wasn't making the argument that it was good but that it was close to being on par with some of the young adult/entry level fantasy of the early era in which the Magic novels were being printed. A good number of those mid to late Nineties fantasy novels spawned from physical goods (Dungeons & Dragons, Magic, Warhammer, etc.) aren't up to the level we would expect nowadays. Heck, a good number probably weren't up to snuff for their day but they were light, easily consumable entry points for young readers.
A lot of the stuff you're cascading into on turn 4 or later just isn't all that great. You're forgetting that BBE is a 3/2 and Rhino is a 4/5 with trample. The life loss is strictly better than BBE's haste and the guaranteed life gain is important when a T1 deck is burn.
Both die to PTE but BBE dies to bolt, snapcaster, half a lingering souls, voice, finks, or any other number of common modern stuff.
BBE just isn't the same now with all the rhinos and tasigurs running around and without the boost that DRS provided.
"God's Beard!"
Member
Shardless into Tibalt value train
It's a weird situation where you unironically wish you were reading a Mark Rosewater-penned piece instead.
Keru_Shiri
Member
I think that's the main reason BBE will remain on ice. Hitting that on-curve seems backbreaking, and now we can add Kolaghan's Command to the mix.
Yes. Don't touch 2015. Origins in a few months is probably the best option to hop into next since it's actually a permanent game going forward.
WanderingWind
Mecklemore Is My Favorite Wrapper
Seconded.
Really? That's interesting. Maybe it'll eventually replace MTGO.
It won't, it's meant to compete w/ HStone, so its functionality is simplified.
I lived the dream for exactly three minutes. Back to Earth I go, I suppose.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
I'm not forgetting anything. Its still a 2 for 1 on its own without anything else at all.
The fact that there's variance in whether its game-breaking or just vaguely OP doesn't actually make it not a bullshit mechanic. Cascade is an exceptionally poor mechanic and shouldn't be around on a card that leaves behind a 3/2 with Haste for 4 CMC.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
I'm not sure what card you'd think they should reprint in Standard...
The thing is, it doesn't mean MTG is getting less powerful, per se, its that they don't reprint cards that were already a problem in Standard.
We've known for a while, but I still think it's bunk that they're not going to reprint the three original Eldrazi in standard. People whining about Annihilator ruining it for everyone.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked