• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Manga Discussion/News Thread |OT5| We Post on Wednesdays

Status
Not open for further replies.

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Dragonball 112 - 195

Well it was decent overall. Arcs that didnt involve the Tenkaichi Budokai were pretty dull though they had their moments, for example, I will never forget the cruelty incarnate, demon Piccolo, incinerating Shenlong, still the best moment of the series thus far. The Goku Piccolo fight was fun too, enjoy when both characters have fun fighting.

I was glad the last arc was a return to the Tenkaichi Budokai and gave more panel time to Yamcha, who seems to have gotten weaker and irrelevant. I hope in this five year timeskip next chapter, he received some powerboost.

Only real criticism is that there needs to be more characters involved in the actual significant fighting, Goku hogging all the screen time and looks kind of goofy will still be tiring if this continues for 325+ more chps.

lol @ Yamcha getting more powerful

I won't suggest you bail on it, but DB post 195 (i.e. "Dragonball Z") is pretty legendary for it's obsession with power levels.
 

gunbo13

Member
Damn, I was just in a shounen battle asking this girl out at work. Was in the kitchen with enemies pouring in blocking out my chance to ask. Had to adapt and react straight into the talk of the enemy. Then time was running out and I got interrupted by her boss. Fuck! Not a mid-boss but THE boss. I stalled and stalled, luckily she gave me a DBZ episode window. And then...

Next week on generic shounen manga, the conclusion to the above nonsense.

Retcon:
Isn't it too early for the bitter tears
Those bitter tears is the lifeblood of team Chitoge.
Aunt Tits:

Also it's not easy drawing manga of this calibre. You can't rush genius.
The quality IS truly outstanding.
 
Rorouni Kenshin: Restoration 1

Nice quality in the viz shonen jump alpha thing. Anyway, I think the story is compelling at least. More should have been spent on showing Hitokiri Battōsai and all the sword skills by Himura Kenshin looked nice. I do hope Myōjin Yahiko sticks around. He seems like a good side character who needs a chance.

I dont think I will be able to remember any of these names without the assistance of the character list and wikipedia pages.

Will continue to follow monthly.
 

Solune

Member
That would generally be an improvement :x

Regarding best girl Chitoge winning, it's the most likely case just based off the oneshot. Not sure if that really indicates anything for the long run, however.

First you slander Onodera and then you try to squeeze in some hope. nononono nope not gonna take the bait.
 

Zekes!

Member
Damn, I was just in a shounen battle asking this girl out at work. Was in the kitchen with enemies pouring in blocking out my chance to ask. Had to adapt and react straight into the talk of the enemy. Then time was running out and I got interrupted by her boss. Fuck! Not a mid-boss but THE boss. I stalled and stalled, luckily she gave me a DBZ episode window. And then...

Next week on generic shounen manga, the conclusion to the above nonsense.

this is an accurate representation of how I narrate up my life too
 

Stat Flow

He gonna cry in the car
p5dR3.jpg
 

survivor

Banned
Damn, I was just in a shounen battle asking this girl out at work. Was in the kitchen with enemies pouring in blocking out my chance to ask. Had to adapt and react straight into the talk of the enemy. Then time was running out and I got interrupted by her boss. Fuck! Not a mid-boss but THE boss. I stalled and stalled, luckily she gave me a DBZ episode window. And then...

Next week on generic shounen manga, the conclusion to the above nonsense.

Did you trip and fall on her grabbing her boobs?
 

Freshmaker

I am Korean.
Living in a to love ru world is worse than death. Always so close, yet so far.
Especially since the only person you'd want to have sex with is Rito. He bats both ways due to that gender ray.

I'm betting his best friend will end up in the harem by the series end.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Especially since the only person you'd want to have sex with is Rito. He bats both ways due to that gender ray.

I'm betting his best friend will end up in the harem by the series end.

His best friend IS in the harem through the gender ray you speak of. I don't even know why I remember this but there was some chapter where he turned into a girl and then the best friend was all into him and then the principal tried to rape him as usual. Speaking of that, why does the author think that principal is some kind of comic relief, when he very closely resembles a child molester.
 

Parallax

best seen in the classic "Shadow of the Beast"
His best friend IS in the harem through the gender ray you speak of. I don't even know why I remember this but there was some chapter where he turned into a girl and then the best friend was all into him and then the principal tried to rape him as usual. Speaking of that, why does the author think that principal is some kind of comic relief, when he very closely resembles a child molester.

Unless rito swings for dudes, I don't think he's in. I can't wait until you guys report that male rito and female rito become two people. The series will have officially jumped a schoolbus full of sharks at that point.

As for the principal, he's a sick ass skirtchaser who finds a way to strip to his undies when he thirsts after an attractive female. Chris hansen could dedicate a whole damn episode to his sick ass.
 
Ryuu wa Tasogare no Yume o Miru

So this is about a shota dragon boy that gets captured by some organization and partnered with a dude with 1 leg. Seems interesting so far.
 

Freshmaker

I am Korean.
His best friend IS in the harem through the gender ray you speak of. I don't even know why I remember this but there was some chapter where he turned into a girl and then the best friend was all into him and then the principal tried to rape him as usual. Speaking of that, why does the author think that principal is some kind of comic relief, when he very closely resembles a child molester.

In the first encounter Rito ran away.

In the second, he went on a date with the guy since Tailgirl Prime shot him with the girl ray and made him go.
 

Dresden

Member
I had to stop reading when her cousin came by to visit, it was soul crushingly depressing stuff. Started out funny but it's just sad now.
 

Zekes!

Member
I had to stop reading when her cousin came by to visit, it was soul crushingly depressing stuff. Started out funny but it's just sad now.

I literally couldn't finish reading the chapter where she takes her cousin the library and they run in to that guy
 
I had to stop reading when her cousin came by to visit, it was soul crushingly depressing stuff. Started out funny but it's just sad now.

That little arc had an... interesting conclusion. It's both less depressing than you would think and more depressing than you would think.

But yeah, the series is pretty sad, especially if you can relate (even if not to the same extent). What makes it worse is each new development gives you hope, but she keeps messing it up, so you end up getting frustrated, but then you realize you're getting frustrated at your past (or maybe current) self, so you get more depressed.
 

ULTROS!

People seem to like me because I am polite and I am rarely late. I like to eat ice cream and I really enjoy a nice pair of slacks.
Princess Knight Vol. 1

It's definitely early shojo work but good shojo work.
 

dumbyugi

Member
Saki

Saki's finally started doing something. This was the best chapter since before Nodoka played.

HSDK

I'm happy and dissapointed about Hongou being alive/fighting. I'm happy because he's pretty cool and his fight so far has been great, ut I'm dissapointed because I wanted Sakaki to fight.
 

Big One

Banned
Yu Yu Hakusho RTTP

So been introducing my little brother to YYH and watching it in segments. Finished Dark Tournament Saga. One thing I noticed is wtf is up with the Sakyo and Kuwabara's sister relationship? I don't ever recall that ever happening in the manga. I mean did they really have to soften Sakyo up even though we pretty much know he's a fucked up dude all around?

Toguro's story is some manly tears shit, goddamn. So good.

One thing I'm reminded about YYH is that despite being pretty much a standard fighting shonen, in a lot of ways it's a deconstruction of fighting shonen. Keep in mind that Yusuke is a character who despite has spiritual powers already at birth, pretty much worked his way up from a normal kid to becoming Goku. This is what I like about YYH, it makes you feel like that it's logical for the characters to progress into these DBZ-esque super characters, as every moment in the series feels like it has some weight to it to their progress and character development.

I do wish YYH was more of a complete series, though. Both the anime and manga had endings that left a lot to be desired, and experiencing that all over again won't be a happy thing for me. If Togashi ever gets the chance I wouldn't mind him revisiting the series and expanding on the lore even more-so than he did, but I doubt he'll do this considering he's lazy as fuck.

Despite the whole "sympathy for Sakyo" thing in the anime, I do like it a lot better than the manga. The manga does the good moments of the anime better than the anime does, however the manga is rather disjointed in terms of art and suffers from a lot of problems both Bleach and Hunter x Hunter suffer from. While YYH never outright has HxH-esque scribbles, you can tell Togashi is pretty lazy with the art, sometimes even outright not drawing a background similar to Kubo. Guess that's another thing Kubo stole from Togashi.

Also the techno soundtrack they switched to in Chapter Black Saga fucking sucks goddamn.
 

Defuser

Member
AKB49 ch1 to 52
Ok, despite the first page first panel of chapter 1. This manga is full of hot shonen blood which gets you pumped despite being a akb48 manga goddamn ,Yasushi Akimoto is a dickhead in the manga.

I can see why it is publish in weekly shonen magazine
 
Yakitate Japan! Start to End
Been a while since I actually finished a series, but man was this a fun read.
Sure, the bread technical info pretty much went over my head most of the time, but I still loved how over the top it got especially near the end. The ending itself was pretty awesome just for the grand scale at what bread can do.
 
Yakitate Japan! Start to End
Been a while since I actually finished a series, but man was this a fun read.
Sure, the bread technical info pretty much went over my head most of the time, but I still loved how over the top it got especially near the end. The ending itself was pretty awesome just for the grand scale at what bread can do.

It goes way off the deep-end in the last 5 volumes or so, almost like the author wrote himself into a corner. But it's an iconic series. It's a shame Iron Wok Jan isn't still in print, it's similar as one of those crazy shonen/cooking mangas with tons of technical detail that you can nonetheless ignore.
 

gunbo13

Member
This series needs to be put down following Negima. It should have went into the final after the Apachi arc. It's running on fumes worse then KNIM. And that is saying ALOT.

PS: Just wanted to give a shout-out to Mafuyu from Oresama Teacher for being so awesome. That manga also gets me cracking up quite a bit. Easily the funniest shoujo I've read.
/Shoujo-gaf
 

gunbo13

Member
So I'm clearing out my backlog and since I read alphabetically, I'm up to P. Not much longer!

*see next post*

Hope I didn't write too much details. You're next R! *sees Rosario to Vampire chapter* Ah fuck...kill me.

Recton:
Forgot Bleach and Boku wa Tomodachi. And more...fixed.
 

upandaway

Member
So I'm clearing out my backlog and since I read alphabetically, I'm up to P. Not much longer!
Hope I didn't write too much details.
..But you didn't write anything! You're supposed to impress with impressions!

Also you know, we all talk shit about Pajama na Kanojo but in the end just look at us. Seriously what the hell. What the hell.
 

gunbo13

Member
..But you didn't write anything! You're supposed to impress with impressions!
Lazy days man...lazy days. But TBH, so little happened in almost all those chapters except for like fucking Freezing. Just for you upandaway, let me level this up a bit.

These latest reads were good:
Aunt Tits - Sleeping in same bed with your aunt and being uncontrollably drawn to sucking on her tits? But I think drill hair is up to something with that make-out kiss.
Beelzebub - Beel thinking it is a race was funny. That distance between Beel/Oga still doesn't make sense and sounds like BS.
Chronicles of Street Observation Research - Dude popped a boner modeling naked for a female art class. Greatest manga ever? And how does Rika not know what it is?
Freezing - Does Chiffon now get to run on snake way? I want more details on her back-story and I still think she is a clone of Maria. She doesn't think she is human cause she was probably modded to be mostly nova.
Hitsugime no Chaika - Lolicon and mysterious back-story of the little girl's daddy being a bad bad king. Cue death scene and unknown way she escaped. The flashback for Toru was nice but his little girl shenanigans...also nice. Chaika seriously hits every check box on making a character moe to ridiculousness (not in a good way).
Kaichou wa Maid-sama - Daddy's back! His reason for leaving was fucking stupid but his return was so random. Some good jokes and actually something happening in Maid-sama means I like.
Kuragehime - Hanamori steals the show in this manga. So swag and hilarious. Kuranosuke totally wants that fujoshi ass but his virgin bro is on the task.
Let's Lagoon - Time travel mix-ups are fun.
MMY - Cheerful little chapter but the demon chicks have nice racks. Also, the two girls diving into hero's bed was great along with the maid offering her "services." What a great maid.
Oresama Teacher - Mafuyu goes home and Takaomi definitely wants that illegal stuff. He's got the best girl in manga so he has good taste. They seem to be getting a bit closer. But you can't figure out if Mafuyu is supposed to be the romantic dense or not. I think she is just not used to it but still acknowledges it unlike most shitty female protags with that trope.
Oyasumi Punpun - Already did this one!

These were stupid:
Bleach - Please teach me how your manga works Kubo.
Boku wa Tomodachi - Already saw this in the anime. Got to like Rika's orgy joke.
Cage of Eden - Eh, fuck this. They are talking about taking side-trips when a woman is internally bleeding. Oh and no plan. And why can't they just split up like they did before and have people making the boats as well? Are they planning a massive battle?
Dengeki Daisy - Eh, it was the close-to kidnapping I wanted but really stupid. Kurosaki got there way to fast before the sexual harassment kicked in.
Denpa Kyoushi - Lolicon stuff again... Options is like trying to get him to teach again by doing infiltration shit using her super powa. I don't get.
Kimi ni Todoke - Already did it and want to quit it.
Magico - Not feeling this battle. It's just boring except for treasure stealing mummy girl. The cos-play ferris wheel is a new one though.
Nana to Kaoru - The latest breather makes me very uncomfortable.
Nana to Kaoru Arashi - This is boring.
Nise Koi - Are you afraid of the dark? Was Chitoge like 5 feet away when shithead found her? And what if Raku got stick in the onsen pipe and died? Chitoge x Tsugumi?
Omamori Himari - I have no fucking clue what is going on. Except I have puns on the borderline H where Himari is a cat and Yuuto was feeling her...
Onihime VS - Female on female rape once again. Yea, this manga is no longer recommended by me.
Oniichan no Koto - College tutor who is like being seductive and destroying porn. This manga is fucked up.
Pajama na Kanojo - The ring to rule them all. What is with all the rape scenes I'm seeing as of late? It's either gags or rape scenes. This story is stupid with magical girl transformations and totally random events/confessions. Guh, just shit.

Sucks and should die:
Kimi no Iru Machi - Who the fuck cares if Haruto can whip up tea in the forest? Who the fuck cares about some random club he joined so Seo can ass-pull him back into being a chef? Who gives a shit about another ass-pulled girl from HS who is a fucking idiot? Who cares if this manga just doesn't end right now? The answer is...Seo you hack shit idiot.

And...that should do it.
Also you know, we all talk shit about Pajama na Kanojo but in the end just look at us. Seriously what the hell. What the hell.
Damn...I don't want to admit it but...damn...
 

upandaway

Member
Lazy days man...lazy days. But TBH, so little happened in almost all those chapters except for like fucking Freezing. Just for you upandaway, let me level this up a bit.
:eek:

Magico - Not feeling this battle. It's just boring except for treasure stealing mummy girl. The cos-play ferris wheel is a new one though.
My enjoyment with Magico is directly proportionate to how unique the magic powers are (in concept). They're usually cool, but the bunnies have some really boring powers.

If Magico was playing on its strength, each bunny would have a wife/husband and a kid, and the powers would all be crazy shit.
And in the end all the bunnies would join Shion's neighborhood.
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
Cage of Eden is truly a poor man's Let's Lagoon.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom