Watched The Tribe (2014) with a few friends last night and hoo, boy. The movie is set on and around a boarding school for mute and deaf people (all the actors are also deaf-mutes), and there's no dialog whatsoever in the movie beyond sign language and muted groans. A new student arrives and is pulled into a gang that extorts and robs other students and prostitutes some of the female students. Nothing new about that, but having to decipher the story through gestures and visual content instead of words makes for an interesting experience.
Still, while the camera and editing works really well, the movie does such a good job of separating you from its characters that I never really built an emotional connection to the main character. That might have been the idea, and the movie largely works without it, but it never elevates the plain story.
I can recommend it to anyone who can handle dark material.
Odd Man Out (1947) takes a bit of time to get started, but once it's up to speed it's gets very good. Johnny's desperate wanderings through the town towards safety reminded me a bit of Raskolnikov's feverish dito through St. Petersburg in Crime and Punishment. Since everyone he meets in the movie recognises him as the killer it's gripping to see how the character's face the dilemma. The ending is fantastic.
Still, while the camera and editing works really well, the movie does such a good job of separating you from its characters that I never really built an emotional connection to the main character. That might have been the idea, and the movie largely works without it, but it never elevates the plain story.
I can recommend it to anyone who can handle dark material.
Odd Man Out (1947) takes a bit of time to get started, but once it's up to speed it's gets very good. Johnny's desperate wanderings through the town towards safety reminded me a bit of Raskolnikov's feverish dito through St. Petersburg in Crime and Punishment. Since everyone he meets in the movie recognises him as the killer it's gripping to see how the character's face the dilemma. The ending is fantastic.