• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

My Hero Academia (Shonen Jump) move over pirates, ninjas, reapers, its Hero time

Veelk

Banned
I feel like he does a good job more often than not. Momo's and Ashido's are the only ones I see as kinda on the eh side.

But I mean, Tsuyu wears a skinsuit as her outfit. It'd be REALLY easy to have that basically serve as painted on clothes but it feels like an actual suit. Ochako looks fine, Jirou looks fine. Invisible girl is naked, but.....well, that's the gag. And kendou's outfit just looks like a cool chinese themed battle outfit.

The BDSM teacher is probably the only one I find to be actually bad. Mount Lady is wearing a tight spandex too, but I don't think that one is a big deal.


Also, keep in mind that this is superhero based, and a good portion of Superhero designs are done so that they show off the body. I recognize there is a distinction of the purpose of the showing off for men than women, but even today your average superhero outfit is going is one that hugs the hero's body so tightly that you can see their individual obliques. I personally never liked that design. I like hero suits to look like actual suits. That doesn't necessarily mean they wear armor or some shit, but I was always wierded out by how often it looked like the hero was actually naked and just had the suit painted on them. Point being that some element of "Check out the body" is built into the genre of superheroes, both for men and women.

The significant thing to take away all this is that I don't feel that Horikoshi is excessively exploitative about it, baring a few individual instances. Potentially, you could have scenes of uncensored naked women, but it can be done so that it's done done to be exploitative or objectifying. And that's the important part, and I get the feeling that Horikoshi knows and tries to walk that line.
 

Lunar15

Member
Mount Lady's outfit always looks slightly baggier when she's normal sized, so I assumed it was elastic so it could expand with her. That said, he knew what he was doing.

Wonder if we'll get an update on the clearly canon pairing between Kamui and Mount Lady.
 

Philippo

Member
I easily get turned off by fanservice in shonen mangas, and in MHA i've probably actively noticed fanservice no more than twice.
And it still is leagues from being any kind of offensive.
 

caliph95

Member
i enjoy fanservice

giphy.gif
 
Bubble Girl twitter sketch

according to reddit, there's one more fan-character making an appearance soon

That sketch looks better! He pulled the underboob back into more of a crop top.

It gives me the impression that he had to go with whatever the fanart winner was, but is perfectly aware how skeevy it is.

I was just in a PM debate with someone about it actually a few days ago. Horikoshi does fanservice. There's no talking around it, he just does do it.

But I atleast get the feeling he's aware that he's playing with fire when he does it, so he keeps it to a minimal where possible and makes sure to add other stuff so it's not just female body exploitation.

Mt. Lady and Momo? Slime Girl (RIP) maybe? He does do it, but it's sparingly.

i enjoy fanservice

5969838+_a34604a712f31ff80f72f17be54d00aa.gif


Stop underboob shaming Bubble Girl.

She's real.

In my heart.


We openly accept your shame.

I honestly can't deride a person over fanservice, I'm just not a huge fan of it myself. I did make it through 60 some-odd chapters of Freezing and all of Air Gear/Tenjo Tenge, so never let it be said that amazing art will get me to overlook some shit.
 

cntr

Banned
Mt. Lady and Momo? Slime Girl (RIP) maybe? He does do it, but it's sparingly.
yeah Horikoshi does go a bit eyebrow-rasingly far sometimes, but at least he knows it's an issue and tries to avoid it. and well, there aren't any characters that exist only for fanservice, which is the real problem, right? even Mount Lady has some depth! so while it's not perfect, I'm okay with cutting Horikoshi some slack there.

I honestly can't deride a person over fanservice, I'm just not a huge fan of it myself. I did make it through 60 some-odd chapters of Freezing and all of Air Gear/Tenjo Tenge, so never let it be said that amazing art will get me to overlook some shit.
you got through Air Gear and Tenjo Tenge? damn, dude
 

Nightbird

Member
OH! Great is probably my favorite artist ever, but his plots are nigh incomprehensible and he loves his fanservice.

But every few chapters you'd get stuff like this:



Amazing.

Never wanted a mangaka to take on a co-writer as much as Oh! Great.

Damnit, you're making me want to read Air Gear again, but i wanna keep my sanity :(
 

cntr

Banned
Oh! Great is doing Biorg Trinity with a co-writer...but his co-writer is the guy who did fucking Jorge Joestar. So it's even worse than his normal stuff.
 

HStallion

Now what's the next step in your master plan?
I absolutely loved Blade of the Immortal but I wouldn't go looking up the author's other works anywhere in public. Dude loves his guro which in part explains the incredible graphic nature of Blade of the Immortal.
 
lol I'm just joshing around. Bubble Girl ain't my hill to die on and I really like MHA's lack of fan-service considering how intrusive it is in other series where it's completely unnecessary.

I also realize I have a significantly higher tolerance to that shit because I read Tsugumomo which is like an inoculation against fan-service.
 

Puruzi

Banned
Tsugumomo is dope as shit. Love it. Shame the anime adaptation is looking kinda botched, but if they can manage to give the important fights good animation i'll tolerate it.
 
Tsugumomo is dope as shit. Love it. Shame the anime adaptation is looking kinda botched, but if they can manage to give the important fights good animation i'll tolerate it.

Oh, I haven't been keeping up with the animation, why is it botched?

Are they spending all the sasuga budget on making sure the folds of the labia are properly pulled down by gravity and cutting the fights?
 

Puruzi

Banned
Oh, I haven't been keeping up with the animation, why is it botched?

Are they spending all the sasuga budget on making sure the folds of the labia are properly pulled down by gravity and cutting the fights?
They dumbed down the art significantly and it looks very generic.
 
Uuuuuuugggghhhhhhhh whyyyyyyyyyyy

Why do anime productions take a manga series that is known for it's art and make it look like every other fucking show...

Why can't they all be like Mob Psycho 100
 

Crocodile

Member
Uuuuuuugggghhhhhhhh whyyyyyyyyyyy

Why do anime productions take a manga series that is known for it's art and make it look like every other fucking show...

Why can't they all be like Mob Psycho 100

Simpler character designs are way easier to animate. Hence why the character designs and art of many manga get downgraded in anime adaptations. It's rare that you have animation team together, or one that has the resources, that can pull off something like Mob Psycho 100.
 

HStallion

Now what's the next step in your master plan?
Simpler character designs are way easier to animate. Hence why the character designs and art of many manga get downgraded in anime adaptations. It's rare that you have animation team together, or one that has the resources, that can pull off something like Mob Psycho 100.

Yeah MP100 is like the exact opposite case where the original manga isn't what man would call a looker as its pretty rough and simple. The anime actually improved quite a bit on the manga in a lot of ways and it was already a solid manga.

On topic, I hope we get a super hero/heroine that fights with their genitals or something to see the reactions. We already had a dude in bondage gear with super teeth.
 
Like, if your power was your wang grows to tremendous size and gets spikes on it, what really are your choices in life? Would the Hero Association let you be a hero? Would you flaunt public decency laws?

It's like Mallrats, I'm always amused thinking about the logistics of if superheros had inappropriate powers or what they can do with them.
 

Nightbird

Member
Well with a quirk like that you either end up the hero with the most inkonvenient weapon ever, or the most successful male porn star ever.

Either way, you'll end up pretty famous lol
 
Uggggggggh. I don't want to pick up another fanservice manga, but that art is tight in certain parts.

Tsugumomo has some of the best action and paneling done in the manga medium, but I can't in good faith ever recommend the series due to it's love of nudity for the sake of nudity. If you do decide to pick it up, please don't read it in public or where someone can see what your doing....shit can flip to nudity at a moments notice. It's a damn shame to, since it's a really well done manga; but sadly a manga that mangka has said (in the volumes) he wouldn't draw if he wasn't allowed to do his nude/ecchi pages.
 

Moaradin

Member
Tsugumomo is indeed top tier when it comes to the art and fights. You really need a high tolerance to read that shit though, because the fanservice is on a whole different league compared to anything you've seen.
 
Uggggggggh. I don't want to pick up another fanservice manga, but that art is tight in certain parts.

Ha ha ha ha. It's not fan-service, it's pretty much just a nudie rag that happens to have the best drawn fight scenes in manga today because apparently the mangaka wants to make it impossible for me to actually recommend it to people.

Yo the fights is Tsugumomo are in the upper echelon imo. The art is so good.

Shit is fucking godlike

Tsugumomo is indeed top tier when it comes to the art and fights. You really need a high tolerance to read that shit though, because the fanservice is on a whole different league compared to anything you've seen.

Yep. I will put money down that the man has a better eye for choreography and paneling and a better hands for drawing that kinetic motion and weight than any other mangaka currently drawing today.

Tsugumomo doesn't have fanservice, it has straight up smut

This is also true!
 

Seesaw15

Member
I'd bet that it was much shorter when he was a kid, and he practiced to extend the time limit in the same way the students train their quirks

I'm sure we'll learn more later but how it's described in this chapter seems really OP. Letting Sir Nighteye have that kind of tactical knowledge for a full hour is like Eraserhead without the dry eyes. Horikoshi's really good at balancing quirks for the most part so the fact that "gaze" and "see" were emphasized in the quirk description must mean something. Maybe if Sir Nighteye's glasses get knocked off it interrupts his quirk.
 
Top Bottom