• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic Season 4 |OT| Twilight Princess Returns

Zelias

Banned
Episode 8 title announced: "Rarity Takes Manehattan".

Good news for Rarity fans!
Nice to see that finally confirmed after the earlier leak about it (think it was a chapter book that got listed on Amazon or something?). We could always use more Rarity episodes, especially if they're as good as Sweet and Elite.

And hopefully another Rarity song. Kazumi Evans has dat singing voice.
 
So the "Something takes Manhattan" trope, where did it first appear, becuase Im seeing lots of things doing tributes to that title and I would love to know the original where ti came from. Its from the Muppets?
 

wildfire

Banned
Well it's not like anyone other than Applejack still cares about Spike.

483381.gif


Well Applejack is better than Rarity so Spike should get over his crush and upgrade.
 

Village

Member
For the next 11 days, and hopefully many days after, she's not disabled, fans are just jerks.

In world where horses have magic, disabilities are as moving as a death is in dragon ball z. When it doesn't fit the context of the world, its cruelty at that point.
 

Cheerilee

Member
Just saw episode 3. Great episode, all around. I was expecting the hooded figure to be Luna, playing with them, since they were up late and in a playground built for her, but the Pinkie reveal was fine too. They might have to tone Pinkie down a little though. Or not. As long as they keep things great, and right now I'm very optimistic.

Sadly, no. It was apparently a Lauren Faust idea. (That was the quickest link I could find about it)

Someone asked Lauren on Deviantart why Scoot can't fly yet, since young RD was noticably ahead of Scoot's progress, and Lauren responded "No reason. She just hasn't figured it out yet." Lauren also mentioned on Twitter that in her head, Scoot used to be bullied and get into fights over her inability to fly.

The linked interview is a secondhand account of a conversation, and it says "technically handicapped, for lack of a better word". It also goes into themes of Scoot wishing she was someone like RD, and having to come to terms with the fact that she's not.

I believe that in Lauren's vision, young RD was very far ahead of the curve in terms of flying ability, and young Scootaloo is currently very far behind the curve. Scootaloo wants to fly, but that won't happen until she grows up some more, and no amount of wishing will make it happen any sooner than nature intended, not even if nature was kinder to someone like Rainbow Dash. Scootaloo "won't fly" (in Lauren's show) because it's in her character to want something, not to get it. She needs to learn to let go and enjoy other things in the meantime.

I think that fan image of a grown-up Scootaloo as an eventual Wonderbolt is very touching and appropriate, but the show is unlikely to go that far into the future, which is kind of the point.


After that interview, fan theory got all creepy into "Oh, Scootaloo's disabled? I think her wings were crushed in the birth canal, come to me, my Scootaloo, and I will hug your pain away" and I think Meghan's show should back very far away from those people.
 

PaulloDEC

Member
After that interview, fan theory got all creepy into "Oh, Scootaloo's disabled? I think her wings were crushed in the birth canal, come to me, my Scootaloo, and I will hug your pain away" and I think Meghan's show should back very far away from those people.

I'll be happy so long as Meghan and her team tell the story they want to tell. If that means Scoots can't fly, fine. If it means she can, also fine. If we don't even get an answer one way or the other, that's fine too.

Whichever scenario actually pans out, I mainly hope it's good story, well told.
 
What's so wrong with Scoots being disabled? Heaven forfend kids that can't walk, for example, have people like them in their media... we could use more positive portrayals of disabled people (or ponies)
 

Tenumi

Banned
Someone asked Lauren on Deviantart why Scoot can't fly yet, since young RD was noticably ahead of Scoot's progress, and Lauren responded "No reason. She just hasn't figured it out yet." Lauren also mentioned on Twitter that in her head, Scoot used to be bullied and get into fights over her inability to fly.

The linked interview is a secondhand account of a conversation, and it says "technically handicapped, for lack of a better word". It also goes into themes of Scoot wishing she was someone like RD, and having to come to terms with the fact that she's not.

I believe that in Lauren's vision, young RD was very far ahead of the curve in terms of flying ability, and young Scootaloo is currently very far behind the curve. Scootaloo wants to fly, but that won't happen until she grows up some more, and no amount of wishing will make it happen any sooner than nature intended, not even if nature was kinder to someone like Rainbow Dash. Scootaloo "won't fly" (in Lauren's show) because it's in her character to want something, not to get it. She needs to learn to let go and enjoy other things in the meantime.

I think that fan image of a grown-up Scootaloo as an eventual Wonderbolt is very touching and appropriate, but the show is unlikely to go that far into the future, which is kind of the point.


After that interview, fan theory got all creepy into "Oh, Scootaloo's disabled? I think her wings were crushed in the birth canal, come to me, my Scootaloo, and I will hug your pain away" and I think Meghan's show should back very far away from those people.

That makes a lot more sense, and would provide a good message to send to kids, about 'just because you can't do something now doesn't mean you never will. Everybody develops at different rates.' Could also be mirrored as well with unicorns and Sweetie Belle's lack of magic use.

I just personally think the entire "handicapped Scoots" feels too off, like that it feels a little "out there" for the show, at least for a major character. I'm not opposed to such a story with a recurring or once-off pony.
 

DrForester

Kills Photobucket
Dropping disabled Scootaloo now would be off because we've seen her have some flight ability. We've seen her hover and we've seen her zipping around above the ground without her scooter.
 

Hitokage

Setec Astronomer
The persistence of a significant disability in a society of magic puts huge question marks on the morality of that society.
 

UberTag

Member
I wonder if fans would be so adamant about Scootaloo not being able to fly if she wasn't called Scootaloo.

I mean, just the name itself implies that she'll be tied to the ground on her scooter only using her wings for hang time.
Is it possible to "scoot" while flapping?

Well, I'll be... there's an airline that flies out of Singapore calling themselves Scoot. I suppose it is possible. Their planes are even in Scootaloo's color scheme.

970751-scoot.jpg
 

PaulloDEC

Member
The persistence of a significant disability in a society of magic puts huge question marks on the morality of that society.

I offer you two possible answers to that statement:

A) Shh, you're not supposed to think about stuff like that!
B) We've been shown on many occasions that not every problem can be solved with magic. Additionally, we've seen that there are both vets and hospitals in Equestria, which implies that health problems are dealt with via non-magical techniques.
 
Not a fan of Daring Do being real. Previously you could say that the reason DD is a Rainbow Dash recolor is because RD was projecting herself on the character in her imagination while reading.
 

Zelias

Banned
So, the moral is that it's perfectly OK to write self-insert fics so long as you're actually a badass. Right?
 

DrForester

Kills Photobucket
Rarity, AJ, Pinkie and Fluttrershy were pretty pointless to this episode. It really should have been Twilight and RD only on the adventure.
 

Myke Greywolf

Ambassador of Goodwill
So, the moral is that it's perfectly OK to write self-insert fics so long as you're actually a badass. Right?
The twist is that they were not fics, but chronicles. But yeah, I'm also not a fan of Daring Do being a real character in Equestria, either.

Not to mention that Ahuizotl's plan was just plain dumb. Celestia would never have let him go through with it.
 

Tenumi

Banned
I loved the episode. Yeah, Rarity, AJ, and Pinkie didn't really need to be in the episode, but I'm not really complaining. And as for
Daring Do being real
, hey, we've seen weirder. I mean, a lake that clones ponies, time travel, changelings, a disappearing empire. That really didn't register much on the scale to me.
 

Boss Doggie

all my loli wolf companions are so moe
Yeah it feels like it's wasted.

Honestly was expecting something like having to deal with doting fans or writer's block.
 

Nohar

Member
Swag.

I loved this episode. I found it incredibly fun to watch, though RD was borderline too annoying to my tastes. I also loved to see RD and Twilight having their nerd-argument. Overall, a very enjoyable experience.
 

Hitokage

Setec Astronomer
The adventure part wasn't too engaging although it was serviceable. What made the ep was the nerd/fangirl aspect.

Also, adventurers selling stories of their own exploits is hardly new, but if one would wonder why she lays out everything in the open yet has issues trusting others.

Overall, another solid S4 episode.
 

Zelias

Banned
I thought the episode was cheesy, but enjoyable. I'm just trying not to think about it too hard, because it doesn't really stand up to that kind of scrutiny and down that road madness lies.

Though I'm disappointed that this means the teasing about Twilight Velvet being the author of the books was just that, teasing.
 

Myke Greywolf

Ambassador of Goodwill
Swag.

I loved this episode. I found it incredibly fun to watch, though RD was borderline too annoying to my tastes. I also loved to see RD and Twilight having their nerd-argument. Overall, a very enjoyable experience.
Yeah, that was the best part. Twilight and Dash trying to outnerd each other was hilarious.
 

McNum

Member
Well, if Twilight is learning to do Sonic Rainboom caliber sky effects, Rainbow Dash has to come back at her somehow. So... she tries to outgeek Twilight.

I liked the episode, it was fun. It's probably one of those episode that won't hold up that well if you take it apart, but Daring Do being real was unexpected for me, but pretty cool. I'll never learn how to spell the villains name, though. Ahui...what?

In any case, Season 4 is batting four for four with me. And i thought this one sounded like the weaker of the first 6-8 episodes from synopsis alone. So... we're off to an awesome start.
 

$200

Banned
At this rate season 4 is indeed set to become the best season. Now we just need to hear the songs they promised.
 
Top Bottom