I'd pick this myself. I never will understand the Geno craze and I'm cool with that.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Next Super Smash Bros. discussion thread, Community Edition
- Thread starter Snakeyes
- Start date
- Status
I'd pick this myself. I never will understand the Geno craze and I'm cool with that.
IntelliHeath
As in "Heathcliff"
Chrono from Chrono Trigger. :3
Chet Rippo
Member
Chrono isn't relevant. At least not relevant to Square Enix.
IntelliHeath
As in "Heathcliff"
Obviously.
Nocturnowl
Member
Flawless.
This too, I don't see why Geno has some kind of elevated status that puts it above every other partner only character from various Mario RPG games as a likely and actually possible option for a playable character. Really none of them are.
Chet Rippo
Member
Probably because he doesn't look like your run-of-the-mill Mario character.
but neither do a lot of the characters in paper mario & mario & luigi
Chet Rippo
Member
That's true too. If any character from the RPG Mario games gets in Smash, it should be Fawful. Considering the fact he's been in 3 games.
Black-Wind
Member
Pretty much what I have been saying
I don't expect him but I wouldn't care if he made it ...
Green Mamba
Member
Mario, Luigi, Peach, and Bowser are all more than enough representation for the Mario RPG games. It's almost like asking for a Mario Kart character.
Hot Coldman
Banned
Oh maaaaaaan I really want Smithy
or Booster
or Booster
i don't think that's fair. the mario rpg series all have their own universes and unique characters, while mario kart doesn't have any original characters, since it's a party racer.
We got a Mario Kart stage. Because Mario Kart is a significant and different aspect of the Mario series that deserves representation. If they presented unique characters with the potential for unique move sets like Fawful and Paper Mario, then people might consider the potential for a Mario Kart character.
Toadette.
damn, you got me. and she's one of my favorite characters.
Actually now I'd kinda like to see a Mario Kart character just because a character driving around in a kart the whole time would be hilarious. He could shoot shells and drop bananas and use a feather from the SNES game to jump and whip out a Mario Kart 7 glider for recovery and have a blue shell for his final smash.
Hey, that's how you could make Waluigi playable. His limbs are long enough to reach out of the kart for normals attacks.
Hey, that's how you could make Waluigi playable. His limbs are long enough to reach out of the kart for normals attacks.
Blue shell as the final smash, instant KOs the person winning with no way to dodge it.
Hot Coldman
Banned
Oh yeah, he'd be excellent. Him and Bomberman.
His Final Smash has to be the Shooting Watch. Hammer the A button as fast as possible to increase damage, and then BOOM!
IntelliHeath
As in "Heathcliff"
Just no, Just no.
Too be fair it'd probably be less broken than Sonic's final smash
Hot Coldman
Banned
Yeah but that's the only way you can KO people in that game apparently, besides ring-outs I think.
Hot Coldman
Banned
Haha, yeah I know, was just being daft. (The odd thing is that some characters have insta-kills and others just have more Final Smash-y things. Balance on that game is gonna be weird.)
It's Crono not Chrono :<
Hours Left
Member
Playable Toadette would be amazing.
Sorry if this was discussed and done with, but if so I'd like to put it back on the table: Phoenix Wright.
Just being a wishful fan but, guys, he was in UMvC3! Let us not forget he was a Nintendo-exclusive character (GBA, DS, even Wii), unless we count iOS ports... and he was seriously considered for Wii-exclusive Tatsunoko vs. Capcom, anyone remember that scan? They were even thinking of a moveset for him and all.
So, my point: Phoenix Wright. It's been proved he works for fighting games, so what about Smash? If Hotel Dusk characters were Brawl stickers, we could at least get an Ace Attorney reference or two.
Also, Professor Layton, but I'm pretty sure that's been overly discussed here. Although I do believe both him and Wright are way too awesome not to be considered.
EDIT:
Practically debunked.
Just being a wishful fan but, guys, he was in UMvC3! Let us not forget he was a Nintendo-exclusive character (GBA, DS, even Wii), unless we count iOS ports... and he was seriously considered for Wii-exclusive Tatsunoko vs. Capcom, anyone remember that scan? They were even thinking of a moveset for him and all.
So, my point: Phoenix Wright. It's been proved he works for fighting games, so what about Smash? If Hotel Dusk characters were Brawl stickers, we could at least get an Ace Attorney reference or two.
Also, Professor Layton, but I'm pretty sure that's been overly discussed here. Although I do believe both him and Wright are way too awesome not to be considered.
EDIT:
Edit: Is this junk for real?
Practically debunked.
Professor Beef
Banned
Wolf is quite fast and quite big.
Edit: Is this junk for real?
Sometimes it feels like this thread is on repeat.
Wolf is quite fast and quite big.
Edit: Is this junk for real?
With those avatars, I like to imagine that John F. Kennedy came back from the dead to ask about Smash 4.
I'm pretty sure if Capcom's gonna include anyone first, it'll be MegaMan. Or at least I would be if it weren't for the Blue Bomber's current situation... Sad times, really.
We're really just grasping every time we mention 3rd-parties, really. We don't really know if Sonic and Snake being in Brawl means an expanded 3rd-party presence in future Smashes... Unless Sakurai specifically said so... He didn't, did he? I honestly don't know.
And I will refrain to talk about Nintendo vs. Capcom for the sake of sanity.
Nocturnowl
Member
It probably is but whose gonna go through this thread to find out? lol. Speculation can only last us so much. Hopefully we'll get some info this E3.
Only chance for that is a playable Toad with a Toadette alt color scheme.
Well EXCCCUUUSEEE me, Professor Beef.
Mario RPG characters?
I'd like to see the
as a boss, and possibly the Peach version of her as one of the colors.
As for characters,
Vivian
Rawk Hawk
Jellyfish Sisters (Like an Ice Climbers type character)
I'd even like to see Paper colors of the characters like Mario, Peach, Luigi, etc.
And Pennington as a Trophy please.
I'd like to see the
Shadow Queen
As for characters,
Vivian
Rawk Hawk
Jellyfish Sisters (Like an Ice Climbers type character)
I'd even like to see Paper colors of the characters like Mario, Peach, Luigi, etc.
And Pennington as a Trophy please.
ScraftyDevil
Banned
So I've been fooling around with the Smash roster creater, and I've finally come up with my ideal roster. Please keep in mind that this is in no way realistic by any fathomable stretch of the imagination, and I do not think this will ever happen. Check it out:
Boss Doggie
all my loli wolf companions are so moe
People should be shot for suggesting Geno IMO.
Okay fine, maybe just pelted with tomatoes. But if Geno and Waluigi are in their suggestions, THEN they should be shot.
Wolf isn't really that big. He's as big as Fox and Falco... well maybe slightly bigger, but his stance puts him in a low position.
Actually I have no problem with Wolf's B moves save for his up B. Maybe make his B deal more damage and has a huge knockback when the bayonet hits. His Reflector move is fine and is pretty much the best of the three (yeah much better than Falco's). Side B is actually pretty unique when things are considered, it looks graphically different from the other space furries' Side B (it's no more "similar" to Pikachu's side B being similar to Luigi's side B). It's his Up B that needs improvement. Change his final smash sure, but make it as good as his Landmaster.
Okay fine, maybe just pelted with tomatoes. But if Geno and Waluigi are in their suggestions, THEN they should be shot.
Wolf isn't really that big. He's as big as Fox and Falco... well maybe slightly bigger, but his stance puts him in a low position.
Actually I have no problem with Wolf's B moves save for his up B. Maybe make his B deal more damage and has a huge knockback when the bayonet hits. His Reflector move is fine and is pretty much the best of the three (yeah much better than Falco's). Side B is actually pretty unique when things are considered, it looks graphically different from the other space furries' Side B (it's no more "similar" to Pikachu's side B being similar to Luigi's side B). It's his Up B that needs improvement. Change his final smash sure, but make it as good as his Landmaster.
You missed this:
Sure you mentioned them but the pics mean something
Bowser grows and shrinks within a single game though. Not to mention that growing and shrinking is a well established property of the universe. Not a good comparison.
The best counterargument is Charizard, IMO.
DICKS AHOY
Banned
Storyline wise doesn't Ridley usually come back because the Space Pirates have rebuilt him? Just say they rebuilt him smaller than usual, christ.
Neoriceisgood
Member
Geno .. Ridley's size ...
I guess in a short while we'll discuss how Lucario will totally get replaced?
I guess in a short while we'll discuss how Lucario will totally get replaced?
DICKS AHOY
Banned
Now that I think about it I don't think Mario is that relevant to Nintendo anymore. Why not replace him?
hydragonwarrior
Member
Cloud Sephiroth would be pretty badass and unexpected.
And make Geno an assist.
And make Geno an assist.
- Status