well objectively Sonys conference was just great that it confirmed these games existed. TLG looked nearly identical to a few years ago, was actually not that impressive imo. FF7 is only timed exclusive and Shenmue also on PC. It was great fan service, but in the grand picture it doesn't help selling more PS4 (the COD announcement is more for that), but they have this gen on a lock imo, so they don't need to make the console desperately more attractive.
Horizon on the other hand was awesome. And many exclusive content deals were also very good.
Nintendo has the (dis)advantage, that every game they show is propably a true exclusive (outside of indies). They still have a chance to win E3. But propably Sony will win in the media and for most people. I mean, Splatoon came our of nowhere last year and is inkredible.
PS: I have never played Ico, SOC, FF7 or any Shenmue game, so maybe I just don't feel the hype. But I also own a PS4, although I would call myself a Nintendo fanboy ;-)