• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Nintendo Switch Discussion Thread (Question of the Day, Countdown, etc)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Their responses to reader questions are not framed as highly-researched intellectual discussion. They're quick-responses question and answer segments. As I said, I'll wholeheartedly agree that making this a breakout video gives a different impression, and they shouldn't have done that. But I'll gladly agree to disagree when it comes to responses to that section of the podcast. It is not the job of everyone at IGN to know 100% of everything that's coming out. That's why the have a team of people who get assigned to different things. That's why NVC is its own podcast.
Oh Im not even commenting that. Im saying when they are in discussion.
 
D

Deleted member 752119

Unconfirmed Member
Storage will be an issue if you want too go all digital. I won't. Since Nintendo games hold their value, and I replay few of them, I'll just buy he carts with Prime/GCU discount and easily sell for around what I paid for them (or more for some).

Digital I'll reserve for things like MK and Splatoon that I'll revisit a lot for years. Patches could be an issue I guess, but I"m used to uninstalling games after beating even on PS4 (had 2TB, now 1TB with the pro) and PC as I don't like having games I won't replay cluttering up things.
 
Everyone is entitled to their opinions so if you want power and 4K then I can see the Switch not being an attractive console, my biggest problem is the fact these guys are journalists that people listen to them and in all in tense and purposes they are giving out false information.

Maybe I am wrong but I don't get the impression you would have had the same if Colin and Greg were still working at IGN.

IGN doesnt train journalists. They push out personalities and entertainment

So honestly the role of the person consuming the content is to decide whether or not interests align

Plus its vidya games... if you just want straight facts there are way easier and better outlets for that.
 
Call it Mario Kart Infinity. It is an evergreen title and thus...

This is the only Mario kart you are getting for Switch. They will invest into other games. I'm sure Nintendo views Wii U as a "do over" and the Switch as their last stand as a console maker.

They will port as many Wii U games to Switch as possible and that make sense for the system. Those dev costs were high, and they most likely did not achieve "Nintendo like profits" on all of them.

Plus if Switch sells 40-60 million units, most of those people did not have a Wii U. So the game is not retread to those people.

I fully expect most Wii U games ported to the Switch. Just not all at once. Probably 5 to 6 a year over 4 years. They can be ported and given a remix or additional content far cheaper than making a new game from scratch.

It is also the only way Nintendo will avoid the "droughts" that plague every Nintendo system since N64.

The more games you sell, the more attractive the hardware to consumers and third party, hopefully it entices third parties to support Switch.
 

Shahadan

Member
In terms of storage, they could allow you to connect an external HDD to the dock via USB, I just wonder how that'd be managed once the Switch is removed from the dock. It's doable, right?

I guess it would be very dangerous for both the Switch and the hdd. Removing the switch would probably cause damage and then there is little point to use portable mode at all.

At best they might allow you to store data on somewhere and/or expect you to swap it on you sd card or something
 
IGN doesnt train journalists. They push out personalities and entertainment

So honestly the role of the person consuming the content is to decide whether or not interests align

Plus its vidya games... if you just want straight facts there are way easier and better outlets for that.

Which is what I have done and decided I would prefer to listen to discussion based on fact and will not be viewing or listening much IGN content from this point forward.
 

oti

Banned
Call it Mario Kart Infinity. It is an evergreen title and thus...

This is the only Mario kart you are getting for Switch.

I'm not seeing it. I'm more inclined to believe Nintendo is getting this out of the way to check the box on their "must have IP" to do list to take their time and really innovate on their next Mario Kart and Smash games. Like, Nintendo Kart in 4 years or something.
 
D

Deleted member 752119

Unconfirmed Member
I guess it would be very dangerous for both the Switch and the hdd. Removing the switch would probably cause damage and then there is little point to use portable mode at all.

At best they might allow you to store data on somewhere and/or expect you to swap it on you sd card or something

They could/should just allow hooking to an external HDD to move games back and forth between it and the internal storage. Just build in an easy to use data management app.

Having games only playable on the internal storage is fine if that was the case. Then people with slow internet, data caps etc. can at least have all their digital games at hand without having to wait on redownloads.
 

LordRaptor

Member
I guess it would be very dangerous for both the Switch and the hdd. Removing the switch would probably cause damage and then there is little point to use portable mode at all.

At best they might allow you to store data on somewhere and/or expect you to swap it on you sd card or something

Its just a UI issue.
Most phone owners understand the difference - for a real world eample - between their music cloud library and their music on device library; you just have two windows, one is 'game bank' (or whatever) and one is 'device', and you can't play anything directly from 'the bank' without moving it from one window to the other first.
 

TLZ

Banned
I don't want leaks actually, but we are getting really close to the event, so things may leak.
Well Yea. So far we've had a couple fake ones. Even those I ignored because I wouldn't want anything spoiling the event for me.
 

Blobbers

Member
The way the PS4 handles storage is fucking horrible tbh, in that it requires a complete HDD swap for every upgrade. At least the X1 supports USB storage.
I mean, when third parties are making ugly ass HDD caddys as a solution, its transparently clear that the official solution is inadequate.

Worst case scenario for the Switch is you have a bunch of SD cards you have to swap around and you either buy SD cards as needed, or do "fridge cleaning". Either of which are still less of a hassle than guesstimating future storage needs and buying and replacing expensive laptop drives.

Well yeah, that seems like a bad scenario. I don't have any SD cards laying around and I'd rather not spend an exorbitant amount of money on storage. The fact that the other consoles' alternatives are so much cheaper would make me feel like that much more of a sucker.

I agree the way the PS4 handles storage is shit and needs to implement full external hdd support
 
That would be terrible.. a bunch of micro SD cards sound like a clownish solution

Look at it this way

You gonna buy over 232GB of games within the first year?

Get enough capacity for now and upgrade later when microSD capacities go up and prices go down

512GB cards will hopefully be affordable in the next year or two

Plan ahead until then
 
D

Deleted member 752119

Unconfirmed Member
I'm not seeing it. I'm more inclined to believe Nintendo is getting this out of the way to check the box on their "must have IP" to do list to take their time and really innovate on their next Mario Kart and Smash games. Like, Nintendo Kart in 4 years or something.

That's not really mutually exclusive. Mario Kart infinite could still be a service and be the only pure Mario Kart game for Switch. While there's a Diddy Kong Racing or Smash Racing or whatever later with characters from multiple IPs, different vehicles etc.

Nintendo really needs to embrace the games as service approach for thinks like MK, Splatoon, Smash etc. though. That's the future of MP series, and there's tons of money to be made as you can sell the base game for years, and keep getting money from the base for cosmetic items, expansions etc.
 

Yagami_Sama

Member
I think that price will be quite an issue for the console.

I am expecting it to be U$ 290,00. I think that games will cost the same as Wii U game, something like U$ 60,00 and I hope that Wii U ports cost less, like U$ 40,00. And also, I really wish that the console allow to have multiple accounts from different regions. Like on my Wii U, I have a Brazilian account and a US one. The Brazilian to play online and the US to purchase stuff from eshop.
 
I am 100% convinced that the next "Switch is doomed" conversation will center around memory. Micro SD cards just aren't at an affordable price yet. However, they'll at least lower over time unlike the memory cards for Vita.
 

Gartooth

Member
Wii U owner here and I feel terribly underwhelmed by the 1st party rumors. Having all the ports is great for the people that don't own a Wii U, but to me I can't justify double dipping (triple dipping in Smash's case) if the added content is the equivalent of $10 to $20 of DLC.

Mario Kart is the only one I'm excited for since it sounds like a huge amount of development went into it. Improved battle mode, new item switching, and the large amount of rumored characters and tracks would make it at least feel like an expansion pack level upgrade.

Other than that I just hope 3D Mario is the headlining launch game. Zelda is something I would get if I got a Switch, but I wouldn't get a Switch for Zelda with the Wii U version existing.
 

LordRaptor

Member
Well yeah, that seems like a bad scenario. I don't have any SD cards laying around and I'd rather not spend an exorbitant amount of money on storage. The fact that the other consoles' alternatives are so much cheaper would make me feel like that much more of a sucker.

Given its a portable and that the 3DS already allows this, backing up data to a PC as bulk storage and playing the "clean the fridge" game with onboard + a single SD card should still be possible.

Obviously the ideal scenario is support for external USB storage on the dock and a built in file manager that lets you move things without the need for a "Now connect via USB to your PC" middleman stage.
In fact its such an obvious step, that if Nintendo do not provide that functionality themselves I feel fairly confident a third party will.

e:
I mean, its literally just having a screen like this to make it clear
U95SM7f.jpg
 

Plum

Member
For storage couldn't they just do what Steam (and the Wii U/Wii I think) does and let you choose where you install games before you download them? Then they'd simply just lock all the games installed on the external hard drive connected to the dock when using the device in handheld mode.
 

oti

Banned
That's not really mutually exclusive. Mario Kart infinite could still be a service and be the only pure Mario Kart game for Switch. While there's a Diddy Kong Racing or Smash Racing or whatever later with characters from multiple IPs, different vehicles etc.

Nintendo really needs to embrace the games as service approach for thinks like MK, Splatoon, Smash etc. though. That's the future of MP series, and there's tons of money to be made as you can sell the base game for years, and keep getting money from the base for cosmetic items, expansions etc.

Nintendo is already selling the base games for full price for years though. Getting people to buy their games and play them for a long time is not a Nintendo problem. They could expand those games with more DLC like they did with Mario Kart of course but why give up on $60 every few years if people are willing to spend them? I would want to see some service elements in there, don't get me wrong. A weekly changing mode would be fun and a serious eSports mode could do wonders.
 
Wii U owner here and I feel terribly underwhelmed by the 1st party rumors. Having all the ports is great for the people that don't own a Wii U, but to me I can't justify double dipping (triple dipping in Smash's case) if the added content is the equivalent of $10 to $20 of DLC.

Mario Kart is the only one I'm excited for since it sounds like a huge amount of development went into it. Improved battle mode, new item switching, and the large amount of rumored characters and tracks would make it at least feel like an expansion pack level upgrade.

Other than that I just hope 3D Mario is the headlining launch game. Zelda is something I would get if I got a Switch, but I wouldn't get a Switch for Zelda with the Wii U version existing.
Better pray
 
So excited for this week's presentation. The moment they start taking orders, I'm smashing that preorder button. Grew up with Nintendo, have yet to be let down by them.
 
I don't think it had, thanks for posting. Looking like £199/$250/€250 is a lock then.

That's a decent(not amazing) price point.

That's the best price it could have realistically been. I thought people were crazy thinking it could be $199 since 1) Nintendo wanted to make a profit day 1, and 2) the 3DS costs $199
 

Plum

Member
$250 is definitely good, it's in-between the console and handheld price ranges which makes sense considering what you're buying.

...I expect a lot of people on Friday saying the console's doomed because it's not $50 cheaper.
 

NSESN

Member
250 all but confirmed then
About memory, i think a good choice would be letting people use an external HD as a type of secondary memory, like you can't play the games on hd, but can freely move games from internal memory and micro sd and the external hd.
 

Gartooth

Member
$250 is a great price. It's priced out of the handheld market so this will definitely be pushed as a new console in the US.

What why?

The Switch is synomonus with Zelda. This is a console defining launch game, regardless if it launches in 2 spots.

For existing Wii U owners an all new 3D Mario is a much better upgrade incentive than getting the chance to play Zelda a week or month early.

Also Super Mario Run got attention back on the franchise so I think it would be wise for them to lead with that to regain momentum.
 

jwillenn

Member
In terms of storage, they could allow you to connect an external HDD to the dock via USB, I just wonder how that'd be managed once the Switch is removed from the dock. It's doable, right?

System Setting #1: Warning: Do Not Remove Switch From Dock Until Copying Is Completed!
If player attempts to play a game while docked (from external hdd), then a check to see if the game is also available internally/micro sd card is performed. If failure, then the game will be copied.

System Setting #2: Warning: Do Not Remove Switch From Dock While Game Is Running!
The game does not need to also be stored internally/micro sd in order for user to play from external hdd while docked.

Heh... Thursday! :)
 
I am 100% convinced that the next "Switch is doomed" conversation will center around memory. Micro SD cards just aren't at an affordable price yet. However, they'll at least lower over time unlike the memory cards for Vita.

200GB are 40-50

128GB are 30 or lower
 

Plum

Member
So, 300€ for console + Zelda at launch. March will be good.

If it's £200 (which is doubtful, I'm betting on £220 or £230) then my plan is the console, three games, a pro controller and a decently sized SD card. I've budgeted £500 in total so that should hopefully cover it.
 

Oregano

Member
Yeah, I think $199 would have been amazing but $249 is definitely quite solid.

Yeah, I think $199 would have been really cheap for what this is.

That's the best price it could have realistically been. I thought people were crazy thinking it could be $199 since 1) Nintendo wanted to make a profit day 1, and 2) the 3DS costs $199

The only concern is the fact that 3DS and Vita struggled at $250 but Switch provides more value(on paper at least).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom