A lot of the surrounding media-led outrage over the flag seems somewhat cold, given the horror of what last week brought. We had nine black people brutally murdered because they were black and sitting in a church with a history of fighting white supremacy. With all due deference to hatred for a Confederate flag on a pole at the statehouse, this seems like an almost childlike attempt to miss the seriousness of the situation. Its as if they expect us to say, Congratulations! You oppose the flag of an army that was defeated 150 years ago. Were all very proud of you, journalists! This generation seems to excel at inventing controversies, weighing in on those invented controversies, and then patting itself on the back for being so courageous and open-minded.
The murderer of the Emanuel nine has done something particularly bad, but he isnt the only person capable of evil out there. And getting rid of a flag is hardly the remedy for the racism and violence that infects our culture. How juvenile to think otherwise.
Still, its routine now for the media to respond to tragic events with a call for more government control. Its not just shown by responding to mass shootings with calls for gun control. Remember how, until all the facts got in the way, the media blamed a fatal Amtrak derailment on a lack of federal funding, of all things?
CNN actually went heretic hunting to call on businesses to ban any goods sold that in any way reference a Confederate symbol (which, of course, includes many state flags). Check out this piece headlined First on CNN: Walmart to stop selling Confederate flag merchandise. See, its first on CNN because CNN decided to trade journalism-ing for activism-ing:
I mean, OK? Even this type of Look! Squirrel! avoidance of the actual tragedy of the Charleston terrorism was better than the naked political point scoring
...
https://twitter.com/AndrewStilesUSA/status/613129182546132992
https://twitter.com/Tracinski/status/613192229935419392
Dear @politico: Republicans were for taking down that flag a lot earlier than Democrats--150 years earlier.
...
And now the media are hopping all over the place. Within a few hours they had moved on from their noble campaign of (largely meaningless but whatever) flag justice/posturing/attention in South Carolina to every state but Arkansas that is so tainted.
And then within a few minutes, they had moved on to renaming literally everything.
In a completely serious piece for Commentary, historian Max Boot writes:
Not only should the Confederate flag come down, but I believe its also time for Southern states to change place names in honor of traitors such as Jefferson Davis.
I know, I know: its a slippery slope that could eventually result in taking slaveholders such as George Washington off our currency or even renaming our national capital.
He thought that people would forgive Washington for having done good things, too. He has more confidence than I do in the progressive left.
A bunch of New York Times reporters jumped on the bandwagon:
Ross Barkan ✔@RossBarkan
.@hunterw teaches me that there's a street named after Robert E. Lee in walking distance of my childhood home
http://read.bi/1N2ghuQ
One wonders whether they understand the difference between men such as Jefferson Davis and Robert E. Lee or if the only thing that matters about them is their affiliation with the Confederacy.
And Stars and Stripes is polling people on whether to rename military bases named after Confederates.
Even Texas is experiencing some of the frenzy. The Texas Tribune reports, Momentum Builds to Remove UT Confederate Statue.
I cant help but notice that no one is calling to rename the Woodrow Wilson bridge right by my house, even though Wilsons racism was personal, political, focused on eugenics and far more recent than any Civil War-era leader.
...
One might be forgiven for thinking that is the goal of modern outrage politics to turn everything into power games and nothing more.
I agree with New York Times reporter Lydia Polgreen:
Lydia Polgreen ✔@lpolgreen
A risk in all the flag unanimity: everyone will think this whole race problem in America has been solved and we can move on.
This is in fact what outrage culture does. Were addicted to judgment porn, and this is just the latest example. And just like traditional porn, outrage porn serves only for momentary release. Confederate flag burning doesnt actually do anything to stop racism. Its a complete sideshow. And once weve blown up every confederate statue and smashed every tombstone with Confederate marks and erased all evidence of the Confederacy from our roads, well still have the scourge of racism and every other sin with us.