Even if the info turns out to be bogus, 10k shouldn't be banned.
If
most turns out to be false, he should absolutely be banned. *edited* (it's quoted later so whatever xD)
If someone has real info, then he/she has nothing to worry about. You want to talk? ok, no one is forcing you. But if you "leak" info from your sources, and then it turns out to be fake, then you never had "sources" in the first place.
If this turned out to also be fake, it would be fair to say that GAF has been a huge time waster latelly.
Someone 3D-prints a controller. To make think worse, one "insider" comes out and outright says that it may actually be real (ShockingAlberto), another one makes cryptic comments (Rösti). I still love you Rösti
By commenting on that thread, they added legitimacy to the rumor. It turned out to be a huge waste of time. Was all that story ok just because it was fun? I don't think so.
Then we've this thread. People have been discussing this rumor for 100+ pages. If
most turns out to be fake, then there was nothing to talk about.
I know that this is a gaming forum. People like to talk about this stuff, but we should make a distinction between people that help the discussion with real info, and people that don't.
I don't think that it's ok to post fake info without consequences. Someone passing info shouldn't be safe just because:
They've made it abundantly clear that they're just passing along info that should be treated with scepticism at nearly every turn.
He trusted his sources enough to show the info to the mods, he got verified, and now people are listening to him.
If
only part of the info turned out to be false, then that's fine.
But why should someone be able to write all that, have people talk about it, and then be fine if most turns out to be false?
I think that only "insiders" should be able to make those kind of claims, and you're not one simply because you got verified. You're one once what you said (at least partly) turns out to be true.
I don't have anyhting against 10k really. I appreciate the effort. I understand that he has put a lot of time into this thread.
By the way, when an insider gets banned for posting incorrect info, do they get banned for some months? or do they get perman-banned!? Does that change if they had posted real info in the past?