• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Samsung announces the Galaxy Note 4 and the Galaxy Note Edge

Status
Not open for further replies.
Still on the fence between the Note 4 and the LG G3.

I have a Galaxy S4 now and I can't say that I'm sick of it or I can't stand it anymore. So I'm looking to go for something that is significantly better. Going with the G3 would be just for the sexy look and the .5" bigger screen. But I'm not completely convinced that getting a .5" bigger screen is enough "change" for me.

So that leaves me with the Note 4. I can't think of a million things I'd like to do with the pen, but I'm on my phone now a ton. Maybe I will love it, I love messing around with things and spending time on my phone, so that may be the "change" i'm looking for in a new phone.

I dont know, just some inner monologue here, but I'm leaning towards the Note 4.
Get the Note 4.
 
For LG G3 owners, what's your experience with battery life thus far?

Mine's really good. Very close to the G2 if not around the same. But this also depends on the version I think. Some people seem to have bad battery life. I personally can get around 20 hours of battery life with about 4-5 hours screen time.
 

chrislowe

Member
will be using my note 3 for another year i think..
my note 2 never dropped my pen.. but on my note 3, the pen lose itself, and ive been searching under the seat of my car x times now. since the pen drops from the phone :(
really hope they made the pen stay better on note 4 =)
 

NotBacon

Member
Great design on the Note 4, although I'm still not a fan of the leather style. But other than that they're making steps in the right direction.

The edge looks........................... interesting.

And still TouchWiz......................
 

Parablank

Member
faux leather backing
physical button
touchwiz

profile_picture_by_upndisgustingplz-d5plrni.jpg


that edge design looks pretty cool though, but i wonder how it actually works it your hands. 160pxs seems too small to do anything actually useful besides just a simple app launcher or date/time thing. and the sides of your fingers might hit something on the side if you're holding it with two hands
 

FaintDeftone

Junior Member
Yeah, not feeling that Edge. It just looks awkward to look at and use.

Loving the Note 4 though. Kind of wish I waited for that instead of grabbing the S5.
 

NH Apache

Banned
I feel like I really want the Note 4, but only after XDA has their hands on it for a few months so they can hack it.

Running a custom on my S4 and loving it.

Which brings up a great point as to wtf XDA/others will do with that 160 pixels on the Edge.
 

Enduin

No bald cap? Lies!
I'm continually amazed at how ugly Samsung can make a phone both by physically and UI wise. My workmate just got a Nexus 5 and I'm stunned at how incredibly nice looking it is compared to my rather nice looking One X, which already makes my mom's S4 look like crap.
 

mrkgoo

Member
I'm right-handed, but I generally hold my phone in my left when using it.

Is the curved edge supposed to be used with the holding hand or the non-holding hand?
 
faux leather backing
physical button
touchwiz

profile_picture_by_upndisgustingplz-d5plrni.jpg


that edge design looks pretty cool though, but i wonder how it actually works it your hands. 160pxs seems too small to do anything actually useful besides just a simple app launcher or date/time thing. and the sides of your fingers might hit something on the side if you're holding it with two hands


I know I'm going to be leading the Leather Back Defense Force for the next few weeks.... but I felt the "NEW" Galaxy Alpha leather back (that this has) and it feels great. Much better than the Galaxy S4/S5 and Note 3.
 

Avixph

Member
faux leather backing
physical button
touchwiz

profile_picture_by_upndisgustingplz-d5plrni.jpg


that edge design looks pretty cool though, but i wonder how it actually works it your hands. 160pxs seems too small to do anything actually useful besides just a simple app launcher or date/time thing. and the sides of your fingers might hit something on the side if you're holding it with two hands

What are you talking about, physical buttons are the best.
 

Loxley

Member
Is it weird that - more than anything else - I'm glad they decided to color the aluminum frame on the black model to better match it? I mean, I could do without the shiny frame period, but I do think making it darker helps the aesthetic of the black version.
 
faux leather backing
physical button
touchwiz

that edge design looks pretty cool though, but i wonder how it actually works it your hands. 160pxs seems too small to do anything actually useful besides just a simple app launcher or date/time thing. and the sides of your fingers might hit something on the side if you're holding it with two hands

Is it just me, or does the back look more like the BB Bold's old leather backing and less like the S5's? I like the look, even though it has historically not looked great coming from Samsung. Thank god they've improved.

And I for one prefer a physical/off screen button.
 
The Galaxy Note Edge is good for one handed users. It would be hard to hold it with 2 hands with your other hand touching the Edge part of the screen.
 
In the case of the edge, they might actually have solved some of their left handed issues with on screen buttons. Sammy have done really well with the Note 4, I'm genuinely impressed in a way I haven't been since probably the S2.

If they insist on keeping with buttons, they need to put them in the right order (Back > Home > Multitask) and go full capacitive. No idea why they still insist on that physical home button, which is a throwback to the iPhone.
 

Maxim726X

Member
Not sure how functional the Edge is going to end up being, but kudos to them for trying something different.

I didn't think I'd like it, but after seeing it in action... I need my hands on one to play with. My contract has been up for a while.
 
I think I found my new phone in the note 4. Have a galaxy 3 right now and note 4 just seems amazing. Little worried about having a larger sized phone, but it is something I can get used to in order to get everything else the note has to offer. Still interested to see what apple will do next week, but I am 99% sure the note 4 is my next phone.
 
I think I found my new phone in the note 4. Have a galaxy 3 right now and note 4 just seems amazing. Little worried about having a larger sized phone, but it is something I can get used to in order to get everything else the note has to offer. Still interested to see what apple will do next week, but I am 99% sure the note 4 is my next phone.

this is where i normally say "get the Apple 6" but just for you... GET THE NOTE!!!
 

Homeboyd

Member
As someone who has never used TouchWiz... tell me why everyone (here) seems to hate it pls.

I'm going to regret asking this aren't I?
 
I think I found my new phone in the note 4. Have a galaxy 3 right now and note 4 just seems amazing. Little worried about having a larger sized phone, but it is something I can get used to in order to get everything else the note has to offer. Still interested to see what apple will do next week, but I am 99% sure the note 4 is my next phone.

I don't see what the GN4 does that's so thrilling coming from a GN3... Am I missing something?

The most interesting 2 things to me the GN3 don't offer (Yet) are the Oculus Rift compatible headset and the Ultra Low Power mode (Both things that could easily come to the GN3 via software update)

As someone who has never used TouchWiz... tell me why everyone (here) seems to hate it pls.

I'm going to regret asking this aren't I?

People complain that it's slow and/or laggy. A complaint I honestly haven't seen make sense, since the Galaxy S4. Most complain because it looks too different and often delays the handsets getting updated Android versions.

I use an S3 often and havent seen a problem. I even use the stock launcher. Only thing I disabled was S-Voice and a few other auto-startup Samsung services. The fact that you'd have to spend a minute to mess with settings to do that often disgusts phone purists.
 

Gattsu25

Banned
As someone who has never used TouchWiz... tell me why everyone (here) seems to hate it pls.

I'm going to regret asking this aren't I?
It's slow to update than stock, has dozens of gimmicky features that no one uses, and comes with dozens of samsung apps that are shitty shadows of other better apps

It's not the worst skin...but it's not the best. It's hovering somewhere near that middle ground
 
this is where i normally say "get the Apple 6" but just for you... GET THE NOTE!!!

Check cut, now the waiting game begins.

I don't see what the GN4 does that's so thrilling coming from a GN3... Am I missing something?

The most interesting 2 things to me the GN3 don't offer (Yet) are the Oculus Rift compatible headset and the Ultra Low Power mode (Both things that could easily come to the GN3 via software update)



People complain that it's slow and/or laggy. A complaint I honestly haven't seen make sense, since the Galaxy S4. Most complain because it looks too different and often delays the handsets getting updated Android versions.

I use an S3 often and havent seen a problem. I even use the stock launcher. Only thing I disabled was S-Voice and a few other auto-startup Samsung services. The fact that you'd have to spend a minute to mess with settings to do that often disgusts phone purists.

Well for me, there are a few reasons. While my S3 is nice, the screen is cracked and I am due for an upgrade/contract renewal. Better camera, build quality, battery and a much better screen. Overall, it would be a nice step up from the S3.

Now my S3 doesn't seem like a dinosaur or anything like that. It actually runs well and if the screen wasn't cracked and I wasn't due for an upgrade, I could certainly wait a while to upgrade.
 
As someone who has never used TouchWiz... tell me why everyone (here) seems to hate it pls.

I'm going to regret asking this aren't I?

it sucks! it's not stock AOSP and looks different!



I don't see what the GN4 does that's so thrilling coming from a GN3... Am I missing something?

The most interesting 2 things to me the GN3 don't offer (Yet) are the Oculus Rift compatible headset and the Ultra Low Power mode (Both things that could easily come to the GN3 via software update)

that's what i said about the Note 3 because i have the Note 2.
 
As someone who has never used TouchWiz... tell me why everyone (here) seems to hate it pls.

I'm going to regret asking this aren't I?

Couple of reasons,

1) Subjective, but most agree that visually it's worse than stock Android. It's been given a makeover recently, so it's not as bad as it was.

2) Performance. The Touchwiz skin is notorious for slowing down Android. Noticeable frame drops, and sometimes taking a while to load apps such as the camera or gallery. Even to the point where UI performance on the flagship S5 has been trumped by low to mid range handsets. Hopefully Sammy has optimised the UI on the Note 4 so it may be a thing of the past. Reviews will let you know.

3) Delay in updating to the latest version of Android. Due to the sheer number of changes Samsung make to the Android framework it can take a while for updates to come to your handset of choice. Amongst OEM's Sammy are by no means the worst and are usually good (eventually) for supporting Android updates on their flagship phones. They have recently been put to shame by Motorola and obviously, Nexus phones.

4) Software bloat and gimmicks. Samsung tend to duplicate the Google Apps, in many cases for debatable value, with most inferior to the Google alternative, for example S Voice. Then there's gimmicks such as smart scroll (scroll using your eyes rather than your fingers). In theory sounds awesome, in practice it doesn't always work and isn't particularly practical. It's a case of Samsung throwing stuff at the wall and seeing what sticks. They can be disabled, but it does lead to the impression that their software execution can be shoddy.

I think that pretty much covers it. Much of this may be corrected in the Note 4, time and reviews will tell.
 

Homeboyd

Member
Ah, thank you kindly. Never used stock Android either (other than playing around on other's phones), so a lot of the stuff you're talking about I'm not familiar with. Thinking of jumping ship from ios to this though so I was curious. Thanks for the responses.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom