toastyToast
Member
Nintendo has been hitting it out of the park with the Wii iterations of their big franchises.
None of the games innovated.Diprosalic said:Both very deservingly so. RB3 is the pinnacle of music games.
Perhaps they should actually put the names of the reviewers at the end of the reviews, then.Chinner said:EDGE isn't a single entity, you know, just throwing it out there.
Mafro said:Perhaps they should actually put the names of the reviewers at the end of the reviews, then.
Shtof said:None of the games innovated.
But on the other hand, today they published a score and withheld the text...mclem said:One nice feature Edge themselves did a while back was an issue-wide feature on reviews and the effects they can have (the centrepiece being that there were no review scores on any of the reviews in that issue; all the review scores were bundled into a sidebox at the end of the issue.) Ultimately, their point was that reviews should not be boiled down to a score, and that people should read the *text* to form an opinion. The scores only quantify one person's opinion of the game; the text indicates *how* they came to that opinion and so a reader can see if they agree with the logic or not.
Stumpokapow said:They gave the GBA version a 4. They gave the DC version an 8. He searched some database for "Jet Grind Radio" not knowing that the DC version is called "Jet Set Radio" everywhere else in the world except North America.
The LittleBigPlanet score is also their score for the PSP version, not the PS3 version, which they gave a 10.
And I'm guessing his God of War "3" getting a 7 was that they gave a 7 to Chains of Olympus. They gave an 8 to God of War 3.
LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL.
liger05 said:Not sure whether I should get this on Japanese Import or make my GF give me her Pal Wii for this game.
Baiano19 said:So edge really gave it a 10...
fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
beast786 said:Congrats. Great score.
beast786 said:Congrats. Great score.
He just corrected the score to a well deserved 6 (rating the platformer gameplay, not the editor here).krYlon said:They gave LittleBigPlanet a 10 not a 6
holy shit!Stumpokapow said:
I like your upgraded avatar, it suits you well.Stumpokapow said:They gave the GBA version a 4. They gave the DC version an 8. He searched some database for "Jet Grind Radio" not knowing that the DC version is called "Jet Set Radio" everywhere else in the world except North America.
The LittleBigPlanet score is also their score for the PSP version, not the PS3 version, which they gave a 10.
And I'm guessing his God of War "3" getting a 7 was that they gave a 7 to Chains of Olympus. They gave an 8 to God of War 3.
LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL.
[Nintex] said:Haha Nintendo dedicated a trailer to this single review score.
Where?[Nintex] said:Haha Nintendo dedicated a trailer to this single review score.
Wait when did you revert back to be a king again?Stumpokapow said:Ah yes, Nintendo bias.
oh that review[Nintex] said:
[Nintex] said:
krYlon said:They gave LittleBigPlanet a 10 not a 6
Scorpion is back!!! WHOOO!![Nintex] said:
Hiltz said:Impressive score. Edge said that the next issue doesn't come out until October 25th so we'll have to wait to see the full review.
Looks shinier like a beetle's carapace too. Not sure which I like best. Looks good anyway.Nintendo-4Life said:Scorpion is back!!! WHOOO!!
[Nintex] said:
Except for the whole "bass, vocals, and drums" thing they experimented with for RB1. Probably just a fluke.Shtof said:None of the games innovated.
Dina said:EDGE has lost its relevance to me ages ago as a reviewing mag I trust, but w/e. 10 is 10.
Sn4ke_911 said:lol it's pretty weird hearing trailer music in a zelda game.
[Nintex] said:
Huh, the Edge review was allready quoted in that trailer?[Nintex] said:
Who can help me find a cheap wii?Dr Eggman said:If Edge gives it a 10, I'll buy a Wii and post pics.
Evlar said:But on the other hand, today they published a score and withheld the text...
Always-honest said:Huh, the Edge review was allready quoted in that trailer?