Skyward Sword review thread [Newest Reviews - Cubed3 10/10, GC: A, AusGamers: 7/10]

Biggest-Geek-Ever said:
So I've just woken up. Anyone care to give me a summary of the last 30 pages? Much benefits will be given if you do.
Click to expand...

Reviews range from very good to perfect, everyone behaved aside from Yoshichan, TSA hated the game, someone at Gamestop confused Zelda for Skyrim, oatmeal hates everything, and I almost got plugged in the face by a silenced pistol.
 
Biggest-Geek-Ever said:
So I've just woken up. Anyone care to give me a summary of the last 30 pages? Much benefits will be given if you do.
Click to expand...

TSA Knows Zelda, therefore we must all suckle at the teat of his knowledge.

No real meltdowns. Much to EatChildren's chagrin.

British people either have far superior taste than people from Europe and America, or far inferior. Which I'm just stating for the sake of sounding fair, it's *clearly* superior.
 
Cygnus X-1 said:
People who want a Zelda game to become like an Elder Scroll game are broken into their mind.

Why can't both games co-exist?
Click to expand...

WHAT ZELDA CAN LEARN FROM SKYRIM

brandonh83 said:
Reviews range from very good to perfect, everyone behaved aside from Yoshichan, TSA hated the game, someone at Gamestop confused Zelda for Skyrim, oatmeal hates everything, and I almost got plugged in the face by a silenced pistol.
Click to expand...

Hey wait just one second.

For starters, thanks for mentioning me in a post *swoon*

Secondly, TSA didn't hate it. And I don't hate everything. I hate you, but I don't hate everything.
 
oatmeal said:
Nothing in it?

It has at least 3 heart container pieces (One you can get on the first visit, one you can get when you're halfway through the second dungeon, and one you get later when you return in the Dark World, use the mirror, and you're golden), several caves, and the second dungeon.

It's very small, too. You can run across it in 5 seconds.

Attached to it is the rock that takes you to the dark world.

And on the screen to the east is a hidden ruppee tunnel, a locksmith (who gives you a bottle) and another cave (I think a fairy?)...

That's quite a lot.
Click to expand...
Most of those aren't in the desert. If we are counting things on the fringes, then you could apply the same standard to the field in TP. There are a few heart pieces that you can find around it. They're actually quite similar in their designs.

Also, it's not fair to compare them in terms of time. 2D Zelda games are necessarily quicker to play.
 
StevieP said:
Speaking of perfectly realized, Nintendo should charge for horse armor too. $5.
Click to expand...
Not need worry man, Nintendo would subsidize us with all the money from selling old downloadable NES and SNES at what? 6 dollars a pop i think.

They are such classy lads :)
 
Mgoblue201 said:
Most of those aren't in the desert. If we are counting things on the fringes, then you could apply the same standard to the field in TP. There are a few heart pieces that you can find around it. They're actually quite similar in their designs.

Also, it's not fair to compare them in terms of time. 2D Zelda games are necessarily quicker to play.
Click to expand...

They're on the same screen as the desert.

TP's had the Arbiters Grounds, the Cave of Ordeals, annnnd the mirror? And it was all spread out over a massive, and quite dull landscape. No objects to climb or look in...just flat desert except for those two things.

Though everything related to AG was awesome.
 
Biggest-Geek-Ever said:
Hmm, I see. Gamespot's review hasn't dropped yet, so I've still got the popcorn in the microwave.
Click to expand...

Eh. The prime popcorn moments have already passed for the most part.

The only thing I could imagine that would really get GAF ruffled is a 3/5 G4 review by Morgan Webb.
 
BGBW said:
SKooT.gif
Click to expand...

Why are two chips levitating between her mouth and the bag?
 
No matter how much I know about Zelda guys, it does not make my opinion anymore valid than anyone one of your impressions that you'll eventually post. If you agree with what I say, that's fine, but please stop trying to make my opinions out to be more than they are - some other person's perspective. I'm glad some of you think that highly of what I say, but really, listen to what some of the others have said here and be more level headed about all this.

Big One, if you (or anyone else) do not agree with what I said after you play the game, post your counter points. I will welcome debate with you then.
 
Biggest-Geek-Ever said:
That'll teach you to give this game an 8/10!.... Wait, you didn't? Oh dear.
Click to expand...

Oh one more thing about the incident, when I talked to the people in the office they said that apart from the guy getting shot, that their toilet got shot the fuck up. Just found it somewhat amusing in light of something terrible.

TSA said:
No matter how much I know about Zelda guys, it does not make my opinion anymore valid than anyone one of your impressions that you'll eventually post. If you agree with what I say, that's fine, but please stop trying to make my opinions out to be more than they are - some other person's perspective. I'm glad some of you think that highly of what I say, but really, listen to what some of the others have said here and be more level headed about all this.

Big One, if you (or anyone else) do not agree with what I said after you play the game, post your counter points. I will welcome debate with you then.
Click to expand...

Man I am 100% fine with your opinions, I'm just having a riot with people about it. Your post was good and very well informed.
 
Refreshment.01 said:
Not need worry man, Nintendo would subsidize us with all the money from selling old downloadable NES and SNES at what? 6 dollars a pop i think.

They are such classy lads :)
Click to expand...

Super Mario 3 is worth every penny of that $5 I paid for it.

TSA said:
No matter how much I know about Zelda guys, it does not make my opinion anymore valid than anyone one of your impressions that you'll eventually post. If you agree with what I say, that's fine, but please stop trying to make my opinions out to be more than they are - some other person's perspective. I'm glad some of you think that highly of what I say, but really, listen to what some of the others have said here and be more level headed about all this.

Big One, if you (or anyone else) do not agree with what I said after you play the game, post your counter points. I will welcome debate with you then.
Click to expand...

This is how you stay classy!
stay-classy-post-and-courier.jpg
 
TSA said:
No matter how much I know about Zelda guys, it does not make my opinion anymore valid than anyone one of your impressions that you'll eventually post. If you agree with what I say, that's fine, but please stop trying to make my opinions out to be more than they are - some other person's perspective. I'm glad some of you think that highly of what I say, but really, listen to what some of the others have said here and be more level headed about all this.

Big One, if you (or anyone else) do not agree with what I said after you play the game, post your counter points. I will welcome debate with you then.
Click to expand...

HE HAS RISEN!!!!
 
TSA said:
No matter how much I know about Zelda guys, it does not make my opinion anymore valid than anyone one of your impressions that you'll eventually post. If you agree with what I say, that's fine, but please stop trying to make my opinions out to be more than they are - some other person's perspective. I'm glad some of you think that highly of what I say, but really, listen to what some of the others have said here and be more level headed about all this.

Big One, if you (or anyone else) do not agree with what I said after you play the game, post your counter points. I will welcome debate with you then.
Click to expand...
Could you please explain that what you meant by saying that Ghirahim 'never and ever' does anything more than fighting link?

I haven't played the game yet, but even in the trailers he does evil things beside fighting Zelda.
 
brandonh83 said:
Oh one more thing about the incident, when I talked to the people in the office they said that apart from the guy getting shot, that their toilet got shot the fuck up. Just found it somewhat amusing in light of something terrible.
Click to expand...

...OK, this makes the thread invulnerable to unworthiness
 
Refreshment.01 said:
And some people will argue the same thing about the horse armor. :)
Click to expand...

I don't see how, but everyone's entitled to their opinion. I wouldn't say "perfectly realized" about the world in any of these games, though.
 
Green Scar said:
...OK, this makes the thread invulnerable to unworthiness
Click to expand...

my girlfriend is terrified of living here now but I tried to assure her that even if our apartment is targeted, that they're just after the toilet.
 
Biggest-Geek-Ever said:
So I've just woken up. Anyone care to give me a summary of the last 30 pages? Much benefits will be given if you do.
Click to expand...


Great reviews >> Somehow turns into the fucking Skyrim OT. >> Post funny Gifs 2011 edition.
 
walking fiend said:
Could you please explain that what you meant by saying that Ghirahim 'never and ever' does anything more than fighting link?

I haven't played the game yet, but even in the trailers he does evil things beside fighting Zelda.
Click to expand...
And sorry, I forgot, but please also read this one too:
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=32619275&postcount=11651

I hope you don't think that I have something again your impression. But I find what people are extracting out of it to be unbalanced.
 
TSA said:
No matter how much I know about Zelda guys, it does not make my opinion anymore valid than anyone one of your impressions that you'll eventually post. If you agree with what I say, that's fine, but please stop trying to make my opinions out to be more than they are - some other person's perspective. I'm glad some of you think that highly of what I say, but really, listen to what some of the others have said here and be more level headed about all this.

Big One, if you (or anyone else) do not agree with what I said after you play the game, post your counter points. I will welcome debate with you then.
Click to expand...

The only difference now between you and me is that you played the game while I didn't. So, I'm going to give you the benefice of doubt. Mostly because I know you are particularly critic and insightful with the Zelda series. Further, some of your cited problems arose from other editors as well.

I would anyway like to read a complete review from your side.
 
I'm sorry, but can someone please explain to me why the Edge review is so highly regarded other than the fact that they awarded SS a 10? Because, in my opinion, it's one of the most annoyingly-written reviews of the bunch.

The eye-rolls started at "Freed from the shackles of buttons, Nintendo’s monster designers concoct a giddying bestiary of revamped favourites and startling debuts." (...seriously?) and didn't stop for the rest of the review. Granted, I like my reviews to be written with a little more flourish than "I didn't like this; I did like that." But with that said a few of the perfect score reviews seemed to be smothered in fanboy language.

I think I'm drawn more to the 4-star/8+ reviews for this reason. SS is getting generally favorable reviews, but the 8+ reviews seem to be a little more down-to-earth.

I'm playing SS regardless, but I prefer reading:

Skyward Sword is a great game and we recommend it, but it's very linear and there's a lot of backtracking involved. We don't like it when other games do this so Zelda isn't going to get a pass, either. Points deducted.

Versus,

Skyward Sword is a giddying trip into a Hyrule borne anew. Vibrant quests require you return to older areas and Skyloft is kinda sparse but GRANDEUR! FLOURISHING COLOR! SWEEPING OPULENT BEAUTY! Zelda makes it all feel like new!"
 
oatmeal said:
They're on the same screen as the desert.

TP's had the Arbiters Grounds, the Cave of Ordeals, annnnd the mirror? And it was all spread out over a massive, and quite dull landscape. No objects to climb or look in...just flat desert except for those two things.

Though everything related to AG was awesome.
Click to expand...
Why are we comparing the desert to the desert now? I was talking about the field in which the horseback fight took place in order to compare equally "barren" landscapes. If we are going to talk about the desert in TP, then you missed at least two grottos, a few heart pieces which required at least semi-elaborate puzzles, the "fort", the place where you find the pages in the book, plus the bugs and ghosts. It's not true that there isn't anywhere to climb or look in. There are several hookshot "puzzles" and a few hidden alcoves if you look hard enough. Anyway, my original point was that the game facilitated a good sense of exploration; there is stuff there if you look, but not too much to give it away easily.
 
royalan said:
I'm sorry, but can someone please explain to me why the Edge review is so highly regarded other than the fact that they awarded SS a 10? Because, in my opinion, it's one of the most annoyingly-written reviews of the bunch.

The eye-rolls started at "Freed from the shackles of buttons, Nintendo’s monster designers concoct a giddying bestiary of revamped favourites and startling debuts." (...seriously?) and didn't stop for the rest of the review. Granted, I like my reviews to be written with a little more flourish than "I didn't like this; I did like that." But with that said a few of the perfect score reviews seemed to be smothered in fanboy language.

I think I'm drawn more to the 4-star/8+ reviews for this reason. SS is getting generally favorable reviews, but the 8+ reviews seem to be a little more down-to-earth.

I'm playing SS regardless, but I prefer reading:

Skyward Sword is a great game and we recommend it, but it's very linear and there's a lot of backtracking involved. We don't like it when other games do this so Zelda isn't going to get a pass, either. Points deducted.

Versus,

Skyward Sword is a giddying trip into a Hyrule borne anew. Vibrant quests require you return to older areas and Skyloft is kinda sparse but GRANDEUR! FLOURISHING COLOR! SWEEPING OPULENT BEAUTY! Zelda makes it all feel like new!"
Click to expand...

I'm with you.

IGN's is filled with that kind of shit. Hard to take seriously.
 
Huge spoilers:

I'm at the gates to
The Temple of Time
. Currently looking for an alternate way in. This game is living up to the hype thus far, although it's still extremely linear.
 
royalan said:
I'm sorry, but can someone please explain to me why the Edge review is so highly regarded other than the fact that they awarded SS a 10? Because, in my opinion, it's one of the most annoyingly-written reviews of the bunch.

The eye-rolls started at "Freed from the shackles of buttons, Nintendo’s monster designers concoct a giddying bestiary of revamped favourites and startling debuts." (...seriously?) and didn't stop for the rest of the review. Granted, I like my reviews to be written with a little more flourish than "I didn't like this; I did like that." But with that said a few of the perfect score reviews seemed to be smothered in fanboy language.

I think I'm drawn more to the 4-star/8+ reviews for this reason. SS is getting generally favorable reviews, but the 8+ reviews seem to be a little more down-to-earth.

I'm playing SS regardless, but I prefer reading:

Skyward Sword is a great game and we recommend it, but it's very linear and there's a lot of backtracking involved. We don't like it when other games do this so Zelda isn't going to get a pass, either. Points deducted.

Versus,

Skyward Sword is a giddying trip into a Hyrule borne anew. Vibrant quests require you return to older areas and Skyloft is kinda sparse but GRANDEUR! FLOURISHING COLOR! SWEEPING OPULENT BEAUTY! Zelda makes it all feel like new!"
Click to expand...
Well, it makes totally sense.

Motion based sword fighting has been on the top list of most wanted on the Wii. And combat in Zelda was in need of added life.

In essence, SS does what TP failed to and was, imho deservedly, critized for: making motion control feel integrated and adding to the overall experience, rather than detracting from it
 
walking fiend said:
Could you please explain that what you meant by saying that Ghirahim 'never and ever' does anything more than fighting link?

I haven't played the game yet, but even in the trailers he does evil things beside fighting Zelda.
Click to expand...

Ghirahim mostly sits around and talks in this game. He does a few "bad things" as you've seen (some mentioned in passing that you don't see, either), but he's more of a menace than a terrifying villain. He lacks the presence that Zant had in Twilight Princess. Zant invaded Hyrule, had his minions kill people, forced Zelda to make a difficult decision and then still subjected the kingdom to the possibility of eternal darkness and despair, almost kills Midna and throws you aside like a rag doll - among several other things. Yes, he commits character suicide in the end, but up until that point, Zant was what I wanted in a Zelda villain. He seemed even more imposing than Ganon.

And to be fair, the crux of that "he doesn't do anything" point was mostly taken from another reviewer who I was talking with (but I do agree with their stance). I mainly found Ghirahim a weak character because he was just so shallow. I could suspend disbelief mostly that he was wreaking havoc around the land and, in the past possibly, was a feared demon as mentioned in the prologue (it says he and others murdered without hesitation). The problem is I'm still being told what he has done most of the time. I want to experience/see more of this stuff. I mean, I laughed at some of the stuff he says and his body language at time. Wait till you see what he says later on...what a weird batch of dialogue that was.
 
What do the reviews say about the difficulty of the game?

Recent Zeldas have been far too easy and the games suffer as a result.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

IGN's Legion Go 2 Review: A very expensive display upgrade 7/10
Review 
27
186
TrebleShot replied
Silent Hill f Review Embargo Broken - Dualshockers 9.5/10 (Review summary inside)
2 3
144
2K
PlayStaytion replied
TOTK is easily a 10/10 with the Switch 2 upgrade
2 3 4
156
4K
Jack Videogames replied
Hades 2 | Review Thread
Review  2 3 4
178
889
HYDE replied
Infinity Nikki Review - IGN (9/10) > Stellar blade: IGN 7/10
NSFW  2 3
123
11K
tTHANOSs replied
Top Bottom