I'm down to watch anything really. My highest rated shows are typically shonen animes, but I've watched most genres.
I've recently gotten into sports animes so I'd like to watch some of those.
- I've watched Kuroko's, Haikyuu and Ping Pong the Animation.
Here is myanimelist which shows what I've watched so far.
http://myanimelist.net/animelist/keffri
I completely missed this, welcome!
Selfishly, I'll point you directly at
Clannad and
Clannad After Story, just because it's an amazing experience and from your list, you can appreciate good drama / Romance. Same with
Cross Game with is a good sports/drama series.
Barakamon, which is a really good SoL series.
D-Frag is a really funny comedy,
Eureka 7 has a little bit of everything,
Golden Boy(Crunchyroll) is a short ecchi comedy.
Little Busters(Crunchyroll) is a good conedy/drama, and if you don't mind sone fanservice and a lot of dialog, some action and some comedy start the *Monogatari series with Bakemonogatari and enjoy the ride.
A few others
all on Crunchyroll)
Toradora
Blast of Tempest
Working
Usagi Drop
Kokoro Connect
Yamada-kunand the Seven Witches
ef-A Tale of Memories
Sabagebu!
I don't watch a lot of your action Shounen series, but I'm 50 episodes into
Fairy Tail and it has been really good so far.
That should keep you busy for a while, lol.
Don't watch Fairy Tail, it's not worth it. (Sorry Cornbread)
Can't comment on those others as I haven't watched most of them, besides
Blast of Tempest,
D-Frag and
Eureka 7, but I can recommend those.
If you want a really good longer shonen anime, maybe give
Gintama a try. It's usually a hilarious comedy, but also features action, plenty of emotional moments, etc (I doesn't go into serious mode often, but when it does, it
really does..
It's 316 episodes. The beginning is mostly regarded as a slow burn and it's starts getting really good for most somewhere in the 20ies, but after that it's consistent greatness.
Or you could also try diving into
JoJo, where its 4th part is currently airing. It's a campy, over-the-top, bizarre and fabulous action shonen.
Glancing over your Plan to Watch list:
Another - I just watched that last weekend, and I can recommend it. It's hilarious as a dark comedy with an eerie undertone, not sure how it holds up if you watch it as a 'serious horror' show. It picks up steam somewhere in the 3rd episode iirc.
Code Geass - Judging from the other shows you enjoyed you're most likely going to have a lot of fun with this one. It's a very entertaining ride.
Grimgar surprisingly turned out to be something that really grew on me, even though I was also initially very offput by the stupidly unnecessary LN trash dialogue it had at times. Also has probably one of the best action episodes of last season.
Tokyo Ghoul - If you're even remotely interested do yourself a favor and forget about the anime, read the manga instead. The anime is an abomination.
Can't comment about the others.
No rush in 'catching up'. There's way too many good anime out there.