Icy said:
There's nothing broken about the server. Thats the sad part. Pubbers do not like custom maps. Horus and a few others are large downloads. Thats fine. a good portion of gaffers who play on it like them. So they will stay. Don't like the maps? Thats fine. Go elsewhere.
Also the server historically along with most others are dead after 10pm pst. This was true before the holidays. Throughout the holiday there was a huge surge of orange box players and people off from school,etc and were on late. Its back to the real world and time now. So people are not on as late. Its literally back to the way it was 2 weeks before christmas. To sit there and assert its because the server is broken, or because of a map you dislike. is pretty dumb, especially when you don't have the information in front of you to back up your assertions or claims.
The timers are bad. Other servers have matches that play a couple of well timed matches and then move on. Gaf tends to linger on forever, or worse, suddenly quit at the worst moment. I haven't played a ton of servers, but I've seen this occur no where else.
The spectate when dead is broken. Fog of war is supposed to mean something. Your server is the only server I've ever seen where you can spectate the other team when dead and discover exactly where all their sentries/teleports/etc are.
There was a time when you used to have auto-balance and I went a week where I could only join the blue team (I was blue no matter what team I picked.) I know it wasn't just me, because the Storyteller was having a similiar thing. In fact, in one match, he kept quiting and restarting to try and get on the other team. We were in sudden death, he died, quit, restarted to try and get to the other team, and RESPAWNED alive on the same team while in sudden death. He had two lives in sudden death and was placed on the team he didn't want both times. He was my medic, I witnessed him die, saw him respawn, and heard him tell the story about it. So this isn't a second-hand story.
EDIT: It was sudden death.
I've quit playing this server, but it's been pointed out that only rocket crits and demo crits are disabled, fast fire crits still work (despite being unnecessary since everyone's around 4-5 percent of occurances and it's just unnecessary whining. Crits may not be ideal, but it's better than randomly rebalancing a perfectly balanced game) I can only wonder what kind of balance there was when you were rebalancing all the damage for all classes.
The map rotation is horrible. I like quit a few customs. One server I'm playing on has Castle3, Mach3, Grand Canyon and I like them all. I'm curious to play the rest of their customs because they have really good taste.
I've played on other servers that have had reserved slots (or say they do on their splash screen) and they aren't constantly kicking the last player to join.
SECOND EDIT: I forgot about the whole various timer schemes that flat out broke numerous maps. Not opinion that they broke, but broke if you had any idea of what the game was about. If you had any skill at the game, it would take you 5 minutes of play to see it broke the map.
I'm sure I'm forgetting other things, but it's always something. The gaf players rock, but the server leaves a lot to be desired and I don't blame pub players for choosing others. I love the gaffers and I've chosen others. I'm not trying to actively rag on the server, but I'm pointing out why others that don't belong to Gaf would move on. Plus you asked for examples, so those are some.
JoeFu said:
The only crit I have problems with are the soldier ones.
I when I'm 10 feet from the wall with full health, and a crit rocket misses me but hits the wall, which im far away from... and I die? thats just stupid.
To be fair, a heavy can take a crit to the head (full strength and no medic) and survive it. The second rocket will kill him, but he survives a direct hit. Every other class you have to lead because rockets are so slow and you'd never hit a thing if you actually aimed for a person instead of a spot. So no splash on the soldier would make him worthless. Slow moving and unable to shoot anything.