• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The Batman - Review Thread

I've been hearing the OST, and it has some straight-up horror film tracks in there. Fantastic stuff.

Check this one out.


Said it countless times and I'll say it again. I've wanted a horror focused batman for years. The character should be scary, imposing and intimidating. They briefly touched on that with Batfleck introduction in BvS. Those girls in that apartment building looked like they saw a ghost. THATS what got me pumped for that version until WB fucked everything up.

Pattinson version is said to have that same aura.
Fuck, tomorrow is going to be a long day at work.
 
Last edited:
Reviews mean nothing to me...I have been duped so many times by the hype machine...
What I find exciting however is the comments reporting that the movie feels like a thriller ala Zodiac. I have always hoped for Batman to be portrayed as the highly intelligent detective he is, conducting his vigilante business using his brains before his gadgets and physical prowess, and this adaptation might finally be it...
Plus, from the little snippets I have seen, Colin Farrell could very well get nominated for some prize for his performance as the Pinguin...
But this was what Matt Reeves had planned from the start even before principle shooting begun. A detective focused noir thriller.
It's been all over Google for ages. Looks like you just found this out?
 
But this was what Matt Reeves had planned from the start even before principle shooting begun. A detective focused noir thriller.
It's been all over Google for ages. Looks like you just found this out?

Yep. I honestly took a break from superhero movies to the point where I would rarely follow any conversation about them, but I did watch a couple of trailers for The Batman, hence why I mentioned Colin Farrell...I could not recognize him at all under his make-up. Not even his voice gave him away...
 
Last edited:

ManaByte

Member
But this was what Matt Reeves had planned from the start even before principle shooting begun. A detective focused noir thriller.
It's been all over Google for ages. Looks like you just found this out?
And when WB heard his pitch they even delayed their plans for the movie to wait for Reeves to finish War for the Planet of the Apes just so he could make it.
 

RavenSan

Off-Site Inflammatory Member
The people who are upset this wasn't a funny Marvel-esque movie make me sad. I am so tired of the Marvel every-three-seconds-a-joke formula. I wanted a dark, serious, Batman film. And it looks like I'm gonna get it.

I am SUPER excited. Tickets booked for Friday.
 

SafeOrAlone

Banned
It amazed me to see people on twitter crappy all over the casting as if Pattinson has not done any work since Twilight that might have proven he can actually act and act well.
The Snyder die-hards are very loud. They're still doing their thing - crying because it isn't Affleck.

This is just another situation like when Heath Ledger was cast as Joker and a bunch of ignorant people started trashing the idea, because they have no clue how movies or acting works and just want to see their favorite blue and grey Batman pajamas on the big screen.
 
I have always hoped for Batman to be portrayed as the highly intelligent detective he is, conducting his vigilante business using his brains before his gadgets and physical prowess, and this adaptation might finally be it...
YES, well said. In my eyes Batman is, first and foremost before anything else, a detective. His original stories were published in... Detective Comics. It's literally in the name 😂

I'm looking forward to this movie.
 

JCK75

Member
The Snyder die-hards are very loud. They're still doing their thing - crying because it isn't Affleck.

This is just another situation like when Heath Ledger was cast as Joker and a bunch of ignorant people started trashing the idea, because they have no clue how movies or acting works and just want to see their favorite blue and grey Batman pajamas on the big screen.

I thought Ben was awesome in the role, but the Snyderverse is shitty and I'm ready for a better quality take.
 

Heimdall_Xtreme

Hermen Hulst Fanclub's #1 Member
Excited to watch this.

But never forget:

star-wars-rotten-tomatoes-93.jpg

I better gonna wait the Neogaf review.
 

Men_in_Boxes

Snake Oil Salesman
It amazed me to see people on twitter crappy all over the casting as if Pattinson has not done any work since Twilight that might have proven he can actually act and act well.

I don't think it's about whether he's a good actor or not. It's about whether he was cast correctly.

Batman is a physically imposing, playboy millionaire, with an air of darkness to him. I think a lot of people can see Christian Bale and Ben Affleck in that role.

Pattinson is a skinny emo weirdo. He may be a good actor (I loved him in The King) but he's better cast as a Joker / Riddler character.
 

Dr Bass

Member
This is a Star Wars thing and we all know it. Their fan base essentially needs to like those films in order to stay sane.
I have no idea what you even mean by this. I'm an ex-Star Wars fan. Grew up with the original movies and was pretty obsessed with the "universe" as a kid. The new movies are bad. Not only how they tie in (and destroy the old stuff) but just ... as movies.

There is a weird thing among some people that like to blame the people that want to like the product for the shortcomings of the work. Like movie producers/directors/writers are infallible. Bad movies are constantly made. Don't blame the people that the movies end up driving away.
 

Dr Bass

Member
I don't think it's about whether he's a good actor or not. It's about whether he was cast correctly.

Batman is a physically imposing, playboy millionaire, with an air of darkness to him. I think a lot of people can see Christian Bale and Ben Affleck in that role.

Pattinson is a skinny emo weirdo. He may be a good actor (I loved him in The King) but he's better cast as a Joker / Riddler character.
I liked him in Tenet personally. Can't blame the guy because girls like him in Twilight.

People should learn that we should give actors a chance. Everyone thought Ledger as the Joker was an awful idea until it released. The Nolan movies are by far my favorite batman movies for many reasons, but I think this could be great and am looking forward to it. As long as it's well made, all of these different takes on Batman have the opportunity to be good, and they don't detract from what might be your current favorites. It's not a zero sum game.

Bottom line, I hope the movie is great. :messenger_beaming:
 
The way they introduce Batman for the first time was perfection. Really loved it. The whole movie is really good with only a few complaints, mainly the
Joker scene was really bad. Didn't get me excited at all. Needed a lot more subtlety. The way Nolan did it with the joker card was much better and hyped everyone up. This was just cringe worthy and felt out of place, like it was added last minute or something.

And they just had to add in Catwoman complaining about the corrupt rich white people :rolleyes:

Dano's performance wasn't that great either. Serviceable but I expected better based on his previous roles. Seemed he was overacting a bit in this.
 
Last edited:

RiccochetJ

Gold Member
Just got back from a screening. It was an IMAX screen and there were no trailers beforehand. The theater was less than half full as far as I could tell.

My friend absolutely loved it. Said it was the best Batman movie yet.

I didn't care for it whatsoever.

I can't put my finger on why it didn't click with me. It's well made, acted, and the cinematography is fantastic. I just never cared for one minute what was happening on the screen. In fact, the action scenes and the climax at the end are when I was my most disinterested.

I'm definitely going to be in the minority by not caring for this film and I'll have to check it out again once it hits streaming. Maybe I just wasn't in the proper mindset tonight.
 
Wow, surprisingly boring movie.

No, I did not expect a marvel esque, movie. Far from it.

I knew it was a Fincher-esque noir film with Batman, but by god does Fincher show how he is a master class at these kind of films with how he mastered pacing and execution of dialogues.

Way too much derivative talking in this film.

Batman is OP as fuck without ever explaining why his armor is impervious to any damage whatsoever.

Also, apparently his armor is light enough to carry in a backpack and apparently he can switch out of it into civilian clothes as fast as superman.

Also. He walks around like a tank, sounds like a tank, never hiding is arrival, but somehow halfway through the movie someone remembered Batman is known for being sneaky so they added two whole scenes where he disappears mid conversation.

Which makes no fucking sense because you KEEP ESTABLISHING hes walking around like a tank.

Alfred was the most useless character.

Story was basically ripped from the developers of Walking Dead game's take on The Batman in their game series.

Who the hell cares about Bruce Wayne if he's just a brooding moody emo boy 24/7?

What makes Bruce Wayne loved and known by Gothan is his fake persona, this one had none and still looked upon like a celebrity.

Whatever, it was a GREAT BATMAN movie in terms of atmosphere and mood and tone.

Story could have been cut down by 30 mins tbh.

Also, lol white incels bad. You heard it folks.

6/10

- The Dark Knight still did it better.
 
Wow, surprisingly boring movie.

No, I did not expect a marvel esque, movie. Far from it.

I knew it was a Fincher-esque noir film with Batman, but by god does Fincher show how he is a master class at these kind of films with how he mastered pacing and execution of dialogues.

Way too much derivative talking in this film.

Batman is OP as fuck without ever explaining why his armor is impervious to any damage whatsoever.

Also, apparently his armor is light enough to carry in a backpack and apparently he can switch out of it into civilian clothes as fast as superman.

Also. He walks around like a tank, sounds like a tank, never hiding is arrival, but somehow halfway through the movie someone remembered Batman is known for being sneaky so they added two whole scenes where he disappears mid conversation.

Which makes no fucking sense because you KEEP ESTABLISHING hes walking around like a tank.

Alfred was the most useless character.

Story was basically ripped from the developers of Walking Dead game's take on The Batman in their game series.

Who the hell cares about Bruce Wayne if he's just a brooding moody emo boy 24/7?

What makes Bruce Wayne loved and known by Gothan is his fake persona, this one had none and still looked upon like a celebrity.

Whatever, it was a GREAT BATMAN movie in terms of atmosphere and mood and tone.

Story could have been cut down by 30 mins tbh.

Also, lol white incels bad. You heard it folks.

6/10

- The Dark Knight still did it better.
You make some good points.
I was wondering about the suit switching too. At first I thought it just time jumped to a different day but I think it happened again later and I'm like, wait a minute where did he stash his suit? The armor thing also started to bug me. When Batman got blown up at close range and didn't have a scratch on him and suit still in tact :pie_eyeroll: Even the new mayor taking a rifle shot to the chest/shoulder area and climbing out of the rubble like she was completely fine was weird too.
 
D

Deleted member 1159

Unconfirmed Member
Heading out to see this at lunch tomorrow. Batman is the only comic book character I give two shits about, so this should be relevant to my interests. And this theater has good food 👍
 

SafeOrAlone

Banned
Great but not as good as the films it aspires to.

Best version of Batman on screen though. Pattinson is given the coolest moments Batman has ever had in a movie and he shines in them.

I love long, atmospheric movies, but I would have trimmed this. Too long.

The movie was very good but also very slow. I need to see it again to fully digest it and form a stronger opinion. Especially because I was hyped up and expectations can do a number on you.
 
6/10

- The Dark Knight still did it better.
What are some movies considered 8s, 9s and 10s in your opinion? I'm trying to get a feel for what you're into so I know what a 6 means to you and to me.

Edit: Also don't worry this isn't bait to break down your taste in movies. I'm not looking for an argument.
 
Last edited:
Great but not as good as the films it aspires to.

Best version of Batman on screen though. Pattinson is given the coolest moments Batman has ever had in a movie and he shines in them.

I love long, atmospheric movies, but I would have trimmed this. Too long.

The movie was very good but also very slow. I need to see it again to fully digest it and form a stronger opinion. Especially because I was hyped up and expectations can do a number on you.

I've never seen a 3 hour movie and thought it was a good idea. 120 minutes is just perfect
 
Last edited:

G-Bus

Banned
Holy fuck, 3 hours!?

I'll probably watch this eventually but why are movies getting so long these days.
 
Holy fuck, 3 hours!?

I'll probably watch this eventually but why are movies getting so long these days.
Did you see the justice league Snyder cut? That was nearly 4 hours I believe. This one dragged slightly towards the end of the 2nd act but it wasn’t too bad overall length wise. Went by pretty fast imo for a 3 hour movie.
 

Rockondevil

Member
As a lifelong Batman fan I loved it.
I expected Pattinson would be great and he’s now my second favorite Batman.
The movie is probably my favorite Batman movie, though I still prefer Affleck as Batman. Completely different from each other though.
 

WoodyStare

Member
This blew me the fuck away. A swift kick in the ass the superhero genre desperately needed. WB/DC really gave Matt Reeves $200 million and let him go all out and it shows. The direction, music, production design, cinematography, and acting is all top notch.
 
I liked it, gonna have to watch it again tomorrow evening with booze to digest it again.

I think I still prefer Nolan, but that may also be just me being younger and more impressionable.
 

FunkMiller

Member
Nowhere near as good as Nolan’s movies.

Waaaaaaaaay better than that Snyder shit.

They really did go for a much grimmer, dirtier, more toned down version of the character. So much so, it felt like a dude in a suit more than Batman in places. Reeves owes David Fincher a lot.

8.5/10.

And that fucking cameo at the end was absolute shit.
 
Last edited:

AV

We ain't outta here in ten minutes, we won't need no rocket to fly through space
Going on Saturday, bought into the hype for this one from the start and it looks like it'll pay off. I don't expect it to be better than The Dark Knight but I'm not a big Rises fan so we'll see where it lies next to that.
 

SafeOrAlone

Banned
It’s my second favorite Batman movie. It’s slow but once I get the home-video, I’m going to love soaking it in.

The Dark Knight is so hard to top. It especially shines in terms of pacing, after you watch this movie.

No shame on The Batman though - so glad to have this movie.
 

deriks

4-Time GIF/Meme God
Bought for sunday. I'm neutral about it

I was neutral about Joker too and got shocked on how good it was. Was neutral at Resident Evil and got sad as hell. Let's see this shit
 
Top Bottom