Interfectum
Member
Haha I was compiling a list too. Time to close some browsers before chrome crashes. ;o
The Last of Us - Review Thread [Emargo up, scores in OP.]
- Thread starter Canis lupus
- Start date
- Status
Haha I was compiling a list too. Time to close some browsers before chrome crashes. ;o
pharmboy044
Member
Why would they give him their scores?
WeAreStarStuff
Member
Wow.
You don't need to open them in new browsers, just click the little plus icon below someones avatar. Even if you go to the next page of posts, it saves the quote in your log. You can keep clicking the plus icons on different avatars to link quotes together in one quote reply
Yeah, but will it be a softer or a harder punch compared to Spec Ops The Line?
Nice way to break the embargo and get some hits while technically not breaking the embargo I guess...
Interfectum
Member
You don't need to open them in new browsers, just click the little plus icon below someones avatar. Even if you go to the next page of posts, it saves the quote in your log. You can keep clicking the plus icons on different avatars to link quotes together in one quote reply
Wow. Never knew that. lol
UnluckyKate
Member
whoever win, we loose
-Plasma Reus-
Service guarantees member status
I won't use the term 'harsh'. I just think that Edge reviewers has their own set of criteria that could be slightly unconventional compared to other mainstream outlets.
Storm Chamber
Banned
I'm totally read to not let hype influence my opinion of the game next week.
That's always a setup for disaster.
That's always a setup for disaster.
I'm still waiting for Sterling's review. I have a feeling he will deduct points based on narrative device emphasis over gameplay. He is a pull no punches type of guy.
revolverjgw
Member
They only look harsh in comparison to the rest of the industry and its comical scale where anything less than 7 is bad
Acquiescence
Member
Said it before, I'll say it again - TLoU will make The Walking Dead look like Kindergarten Cop by comparison.
I think that Mama Robotik post was harsh, People have kneejerk reaction on the forum.
Im pretty sure if any popular game on gaf with a huge fanbase like HL3 or Nintendo games will get a surprisingly score and the review content is different compared to what we read from other users impression, its bound for some people to not take the review seriously.
Imo two things people wont see -
1 - Some users had played the game just when reviews started to appear since game was leaked early.
2 - Uncharted 3 haters were dismissing all other reviews apart from EG when even they didnt play the game
Im pretty sure if any popular game on gaf with a huge fanbase like HL3 or Nintendo games will get a surprisingly score and the review content is different compared to what we read from other users impression, its bound for some people to not take the review seriously.
Imo two things people wont see -
1 - Some users had played the game just when reviews started to appear since game was leaked early.
2 - Uncharted 3 haters were dismissing all other reviews apart from EG when even they didnt play the game
We're now trying to downplay Edge? The same Edge people were hoping on trashing the game to cause a meltdown and come out with a 10? I swear people aren't going to be happy until this game gets another 8 type situation.
I remember the fan reaction people had when Twilight Princess didn't score 10 out of 10s. It was just as alarming as Uncharted 3. People have expectations, deal with it.gif.
~Devil Trigger~
In favor of setting Muslim women on fire
the first perfect game in history
No, that was -- and still is -- Tetris.
I think you misunderstand my intentions, believe me I'm rolling my eyes at the people seemingly only here "for the meltdowns" just as hard as the rest of you, but I really don't put much stock in Edge's opinion these days. That's all I wanted to say.
Mama Robotnik always comes off as self-righteous with his posts but he's as much of a fan as any of us. I'd rather be WTF over reviews even if it makes me look foolish because at least it's an honest reaction.
Interfectum
Member
I tend to agree with most of Sterling's reviews. From not playing this game yet it looks like something that most gamers will really enjoy, Sterling included. I can easily seem him dropping a 9/10 or 10/10. But maybe there are some flaws that haven't come out about the game thus far.
Magic Mushroom
Member
Deducting points based on narrative device emphasis over gameplay would be weird as both are very strong.
FonkyByNature
Member
My hype meter is trough the roof !
Cannot wait for this bad boy to release ! I think i'll play this in one or two settings with my Pulse headphones, it's gonna be good !!!
This kind of games is why i love Sony first party developers. You can't find those experiences anywhere else.
Next week is gonna be sweet, E3 + "The Last of Us" !!
Cannot wait for this bad boy to release ! I think i'll play this in one or two settings with my Pulse headphones, it's gonna be good !!!
This kind of games is why i love Sony first party developers. You can't find those experiences anywhere else.
Next week is gonna be sweet, E3 + "The Last of Us" !!
Acquiescence
Member
You spelt final fantasy ix wrong
No no no, seven in roman numerals is VII, not IX.
Pretty much. Its not as if haters wont troll. Im pretty sure they are ready to dismiss
OPM uk - 10
"its the official mag, sure they would give 10"
Edge - 10
"edge is hardly credible, they gave skyward sword 10 lol"
IGN - 10 or 9
"lol ign"
Destrctroid - 10 or 9
"lol its jim sterling who takes him seriously "
I guess Eurogamer review will only matter to them i guess now unless they give it higher then 8 lol
Acheteedo
Member
Super Mario Brothers 3 would like a word.
But not before Tetris gets it's say.
Tell that to VI master race.
Tummi Gummi
Member
These two have already happened so it's just a matter of time.
uncleniccius
Member
Did they?Eurogamer gave AC3 a 10
That game had issues, 2 is superior in every way too.
Tricky I Shadow
Banned
So true.
Acquiescence
Member
You leave George out of this dammit!
GalacticMouse
Member
Tomorrow.
Sums it up too perfectly.
Tummi Gummi
Member
Sorry just checked and it was a 9. Weird, I could've sworn reading it at the time, and it was a 10 despite the review being incredibly negative.
MrChocolate
Member
Tell that to VI master race.
Move on bro. VII is way better than VI.
And lol at IX being perfect.
- Status
Similar threads
- Featured