• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The New and Improved Cricket Thread© - Now Roadblock Free!

tri_willy

Member
i'll hold you to that irfan

what is dhoni doing, is he really challenging himself with a crappy handicap by going currently 3 off 25?
 

tri_willy

Member
semi retired from sportsbet for now... too many failed multis prompted my hand haha

presently aussies are $1.18 and india are $4.75 to win. maybe dhoni's deliberately increasing the odds to win? ;)
 

Grug

Member
This just makes the remaining two games irrelevant, why not just move on to the finals?

cash-in-hand.jpg
 

artist

Banned
Pathan can bat better than the top order, then why does Dhoni have him come down at 8 after the fucking likes of waste-of-space Jadeja? Clearly Dhoni favors Jadeja, you got to look back at this favoritism from the 2007 WC.

After India go back home, there needs to be thorough review and a complete overhaul. Should start with the sacking of Dhoni as captain.
 

tri_willy

Member
Pathan can bat better than the top order, then why does Dhoni have him come down at 8 after the fucking likes of waste-of-space Jadeja? Clearly Dhoni favors Jadeja, you got to look back at this favoritism from the 2007 WC.

After India go back home, there needs to be thorough review and a complete overhaul. Should start with the sacking of Dhoni as captain.

i think some serious questions will need to be asked of dhoni, the issue regarding tendulkar, sehwag and gambhir not playing together was a bit of an issue. even though the 3 failed 2nite, dhoni's performance wasnt exactly all that flash.

perhaps he needs time off, clearly he's not the same damaging player he was before he became captain... well at least imo
 

artist

Banned
i think some serious questions will need to be asked of dhoni, the issue regarding tendulkar, sehwag and gambhir not playing together was a bit of an issue. even though the 3 failed 2nite, dhoni's performance wasnt exactly all that flash.

perhaps he needs time off, clearly he's not the same damaging player he was before he became captain... well at least imo
If you go back in my post history, you'll see that I am very critical of Dhoni's current game.
 

tri_willy

Member
yea, feel as though dhoni's just lacks the hunger and drive, well in the least its reflected in his gameplay. not surprised if there was really a faction than what some of the indian officials are trying to sugar coat.

looks like bp for the aussies ;)
 

Rezbit

Member
I understand what he was trying to do, and it has worked before, but Dhoni giving away 30 odd balls for single figure runs is pretty selfish. Really needed to work it around during that period.

Good win for the Aussies, but I feel like a lot of the wickets were cheap.
 

artist

Banned
I understand what he was trying to do, and it has worked before, but Dhoni giving away 30 odd balls for single figure runs is pretty selfish. Really needed to work it around during that period.

Good win for the Aussies, but I feel like a lot of the wickets were cheap.
Its not just his personal game but his choices have been pretty wtf. He plays Jadeja with a guaranteed slot and that guy for the sake of his life cant hit big shots neither is he a specialist bowler.

Dhoni kept Pathan out of the team not just in ODIs but in tests as well. Besides he refuses to change the batting order like its one of the ten commandments.
 

artist

Banned
im sure we can't even begin to understand the game of politics in that locker room
I dont think Dhoni's got an personal issue with Sehwag though. I listen to Dhoni's hindi chat with Sehwag in the stump mic. Its just that Sehwag has been a disaster, much like Haddin this entire tour.

He wants to play Jadeja/Raina/Ashwin/Rohit over Gambhir/Tendulkar/Pathan. Its clear that he's got some great rapport with his "gang" as they play for CSK together but .. this is India and not CSK.
 

Grug

Member
Cricinfo

There is a provision, an escape clause in Law 33, though: "Notwithstanding 1(a) above, a batsman will not be out under this Law if he handles the ball to avoid injury."

Dussey Verdict: Not Guilty
 

hamchan

Member
I don't understand why the Indian team is so shit. They have a huge population base that loves cricket, so a large talent pool to choose from. They have so much money thrown at the sport. Even the current lineup seems pretty scary on paper with some big names. Why the heck have they been dominated this summer?
 

Yagharek

Member
I don't understand why India is so shit. They have a huge population base that loves cricket, so a large talent pool to choose from. They have so much money thrown at the sport. Even the current lineup seems pretty scary on paper with some big names. Why the heck have they been dominated this summer?

Because they refuse to tell the greats who are out of form to retire.
 

tri_willy

Member
i always thought duncan fletcher was a pretty shit coach overall, i mean look what kirsten did for india

last time fletcher toured in australia with a different test team, did they not get whitewashed? ;)
 
I don't understand why the Indian team is so shit. They have a huge population base that loves cricket, so a large talent pool to choose from. They have so much money thrown at the sport. Even the current lineup seems pretty scary on paper with some big names. Why the heck have they been dominated this summer?

Policy and politics. Environment is poisonous.
 

artist

Banned
Donkey crap. What a ball and what a finish. The reactions were glorious.

What a defense and come back from England, especially after Pakistan were cruising at one stage.

England take both ODI and T20 series. Huge morale victory for Pakistan in the one T20 game and the test series.
 

artist

Banned
Dhoni wins a toss finally .. his success rate with the toss this tour must be a record. Anyway Zaheer is back and Dhoni replaces him with Pathan. WTF.

Pathan was in good touch when he was batting in the last game (after the collision) and from his fielding, he didnt look like in bother. Neither was Raina .. Dhoni's favoritism strikes again and that waste-of-space-Jadeja gets another game.
 

beast786

Member
Congrats to England for a thrilling 2-1 t20 series victory. What a competitive and a thrilling tour of England. Too bad our fellow subcontinent team couldn't be that competitive.

Pakistan wins a test series in a whitewash against a #1 team in the world , then England came back and won the limited overs format. too bad our fellow subcontinent couldn't be that competitive , but at least they provided not just once in a decade type moment but once ever in the history of cricket moment by losing record breaking back to back 4 match test series. But, all is not lost. Our subcontinent fellow team did WIN A HUGE MORAL VICTORY................

THEY WON A BROZE MEDAL IN THE CB TRI SERIES



*\o/*
 

Dynedom

Member
Dilshan put on a clinic. Incredible. Sanga finally getting his ton too. Shame he couldn't see it through to the end. Perera's wicket was silly but the damage had already been done.

India need 321 within 40 for the bonus point right? Around 8 an over. That's a big ask, given their form. If they do it, they deserve the tournament.

If India loses, the decision to bowl first is going to be hotly debated. Only the Indian commentators seemed convinced it was a good idea. Will be interesting to see if they flip flop given a loss. Given that India needed the BP, they didn't have much of a choice I guess.

I want to stay up for India's innings but too tired. Might watch the first 10. A few quick wickets and I might just call the match for SL and go to sleep.
 

tri_willy

Member
not to write india off but they need to get the bonus point to make it to the finals.

8 runs an over, i will be entertained if they go for it

lol sangakarra was bowled out by... kumar
 

artist

Banned
India need 321 within 40 for the bonus point right? Around 8 an over. That's a big ask, given their form. If they do it, they deserve the tournament.
Nah. Even then they would still be pretty erratic compared to the Australia/SL.

If India loses, the decision to bowl first is going to be hotly debated. Only the Indian commentators seemed convinced it was a good idea. Will be interesting to see if they flip flop given a loss. Given that India needed the BP, they didn't have much of a choice I guess.
It is because Dhoni has less (zero) confidence in his bowling unit atm and for good reason. I dont think it will be a hot topic at all.
 

pappe

Member
I think the biggest reason for the failure of the Indian team on this tour is the coach and his man-management skills.

When Kirsten was coach we did not get to hear any stories of unrest in the changing room which suddenly seem to be popping up. Obviously Dhoni and Sehwag might have played a role but i believe there is politics in each team its upon the coach how he handles these things. Fletcher just cannot command the respect of the team as Kirsten did.

Sachin Out. What a horrible shot.
 
Top Bottom