Topher
Identifies as young
Actually for some of us consolidation in the gaming industry across the board is a bad thing. What about you? How does scale factor into both scenarios for you?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Valheim Is 6 Months Timed Xbox Console Exclusive, Will Come To PlayStation Later
- Thread starter Topher
- Start date
Actually for some of us consolidation in the gaming industry across the board is a bad thing. What about you? How does scale factor into both scenarios for you?
So were we not discussing Deathloop and Ghostwire Tokyo releases hitting Game Pass a year after it's PS exclusivity due to the contract lengths being visible in the trailers? What about Final Fantasy XVI being a 6 month exclusive? Forspoken for 2 years? Silent Hill being a one-year exclusive? Final Fantasy VII Remake ending in a year? What about Hogwarts and it's exclusive PlayStation content ending on Feb 10th, 2024? There are a number of topics on this forum generated from just screenshots of exclusivity lengths in PlayStation trailers.
Its either both count or nether count. Personally the best outcome is no abk deal but the end of money hats of major studios. But if Sony wants to accelerate money hats then Microsoft has the right to secure content in a way that makes business sense.
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
There's also some they don't announce. And some of them go further than 1 year.
Topher
Identifies as young
I agree. I think it doesn't matter either way. If it is a bad practice then it is a bad practice. Nothing would make me happier than the cessation of money hatting exclusivity and this seemingly never-ending cycle of consolidation.
NonPhixion
Member
Mr Reasonable
Completely Unreasonable
It's a good point, I just assumed he knew since he so confidently said it was bug free and had DLC.
DarkMage619
$MSFT
I hear gamers complain about consolidation but developers seem to appreciate having a larger company to be under so they don't have the same financial pressures. Companies like Bungie and Obsidian were happy to be purchased and spoke to additional creative freedom being part of a larger organization. Have you heard any actual game makers complain about being bought or consolidation in general.
More to the topic all companies get timed exclusives. MS tends to do so for smaller titles that haven't had lots of exposure on other platforms. It's a little different when a game like Final Fantasy or Street Fighter gets locked down. In the end business is business and no laws are broken when it happens.
Rhazer Fusion
Member
I understand what you mean, but I suppose these companies do this because they try to give consumers reasons to buy their consoles over the competition. To be honest, the competing consoles are almost identical to each other excluding a handful of exclusives.
Go on, give some examples for the class to see
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
You can figure it out if you want. Try googling "playstion timed exclusives PS5." Teachers usually get paid for their class time.
NonPhixion
Member
Thats definitely not true.
I don't have to figure shit out since I'm not the one trying to make a counter-argument on "trust me bro" while I'm providing facts.
Last edited:
Captain Toad
Banned
TLDR - If Microsoft does it, it's good. If Sony does it, it's bad.
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
Then believe what you want. I dont have time at the moment to debate you. You can Google it if you're actually interested. Im at the gym lol. With all the details in your last post it should be trivially easy for you to find out.
Last edited:
Your at the gym but have been responding back to me for the last hour or so... funny. Either prove your point with facts or just shut up. You directing me to Google to try and disprove the point I'm making is stupid.
Last edited:
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
I will just drop it. As I said above.
ulantan
Member
It's not that anyone has a problem with the deals it's just that one company has publicly said they were bad
Topher
Identifies as young
Selective reading/learning....^^^
Last edited:
Chronicle
Member
Damigos
Member
Meh..just one
SteelCurtain 59
Member
For all the "but Xbox does this too" people, I think this is just as dumb and a waste of money as when Sony does it. This doesn't actually help Xbox consumers. Timed Exclusive 3rd party content is always dumb unless the 1st party actually contributed something of note (i.e. not just a payment or marketing, but actually helped with the development in some way
Spukc
always chasing the next thrill
Then when the fuck would we be buying consoles
Ya hippy
Morrie’s wig shop
Member
I guess It’s nice to know the amount of time that was money hatted lol.
Hendrick's
If only my penis was as big as my GamerScore!
Or maybe they actually don't have plans to put it on PS at this time.Valheim devs can't even talk about a PlayStation version.
Valheim Devs Have No Current Plans to Release on PlayStation - IGN
There aren't any current plans to bring Valheim to other console platforms other than Xbox, but the possibility isn't ruled out.www.ign.com
Then people suddenly forget that Xbox also regularly does timed-exclusivity deals -- sometimes even more aggressively than PlayStation.
This is a stark reminder that both companies do timed-exclusivity contracts. And this is not in any way an excuse to buy multiplatform publishers. And that the following statements from executives are just PR brownie points and should be treated as such.
Bumblebeetuna
Member
And that company also said “they’re bad but we have to do them”. Yet for some reason people still act like it’s this “SEE??? LIAR!!!” moment any time a MS exclusive deal is revealed/confirmed. Bizarre.
Topher
Identifies as young
Maybe SE just doesn't "have plans" for FF games on Xbox. Or maybe..........we stop pretending these deals for both Microsoft and Sony are not exactly what they are. Bullshit timed exclusives.
Last edited:
Sleepwalker
Member
This game is like $10 on steam or less ($4.50 in my region) and can be played on a potato, who cares if it's exclusive on xbox for 6 months?
Captain Toad
Banned
There are people saying exactly the opposite
sainraja
Member
What point are you trying to make in defense of Microsoft here?
You know, they are trying to do BOTH, they are buying publishers (1 is
, while the other is 
pending) + making exclusivity deals.They aren't just buying small-time publishers here. So, if people are saying they should just continue to do those (exclusivity deals) vs. buying big publishers, they simply mean that BUT, again, MS isn't doing just that, they are doing BOTH. I don't know how/why you think the other hasn't already taken place once with the second in a paused state at the moment.
Last edited:
Hendrick's
If only my penis was as big as my GamerScore!
Nah. The studio behind Valheim is like 8 people. It wouldn't be out of the ordinary that they would not have the bandwidth to handle multiple ports at once.Maybe SE just doesn't "have plans" for FF games on Xbox. Or maybe..........we stop pretending these deals for both Microsoft and Sony are not exactly what they are. Bullshit timed exclusives.
Topher
Identifies as young
Nah, Valheim sold 10 million. Come on, dude. Be real.
Last edited:
Sleepwalker
Member
The small team argument doesn't make sense because the core Valheim team is not porting the game
Valheim to sail onto Xbox in Spring 2023 after Fall 2022 Microsoft Store and PC Game Pass launch — FISHLABS | PLAION GmbH
Announced at the Xbox Games Showcase Extended, the hit Viking survival game will land on Xbox shores and its Game Pass catalogue in early 2023, after the game launches on Microsoft Store and onto PC Game Pass in Fall 2022 Watch the announcement trailer here . SKÖVDE, Swe
www.dsfishlabs.com
I assume microsoft funded the port, or at least that some of the gamepass money went to it, so it makes sense that it isn't coming to playstation for 6 months.
Hendrick's
If only my penis was as big as my GamerScore!
Fair enough. I didn’t know they were farming it out.The small team argument doesn't make sense because the core Valheim team is not porting the game
Valheim to sail onto Xbox in Spring 2023 after Fall 2022 Microsoft Store and PC Game Pass launch — FISHLABS | PLAION GmbH
Announced at the Xbox Games Showcase Extended, the hit Viking survival game will land on Xbox shores and its Game Pass catalogue in early 2023, after the game launches on Microsoft Store and onto PC Game Pass in Fall 2022 Watch the announcement trailer here . SKÖVDE, Swe
I assume microsoft funded the port, or at least that some of the gamepass money went to it, so it makes sense that it isn't coming to playstation for 6 months.
Sony
Nintendo
Ah so that is your agenda.
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
My "agenda" is facts?
DenchDeckard
Moderated wildly
What point are you trying to make in defense of Microsoft here?
You know, they are trying to do BOTH, they are buying publishers (1 is
They aren't just buying small-time publishers here. So, if people are saying they should just continue to do those (exclusivity deals) vs. buying big publishers, they simply mean that BUT, again, MS isn't doing just that, they are doing BOTH. I don't know how/why you think the other hasn't already taken place once with the second in a paused state at the moment.
So, I think MS and Sony obviously carry on doing what they are doing. It's shit and none of them are going to stop. Theres no point in painting anything other than what it is. Absolute BAB!
What's the point in going either way on it apart from saying it's shit. Sony's not gonna stop, and MS isn't going to stop unless somehow someone stepped in legally and made the deals stop...which isn't going to happen.
I guess, let the Phil Spencer quotes continue? crack on
DenchDeckard
Moderated wildly
Just out of interest, what more aggressive deals has MS done over Sony recently. I genuinely may have missed them. 1 year and beyond, two years ?
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
Aggressively as in quantity. PlayStation goes after bigger but fewer games. Xbox goes after smaller-scaled but more games and more frequently.
DenchDeckard
Moderated wildly
What games are these and what is the exclusivity period. I would consider aggressive as 1 year, 2 years or more etc.
Are you talking game pass gets?
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
Different definitions. Here are only some of them: https://culturedvultures.com/timed-xbox-console-launch-exclusives-list/
Games like Tunic, Yakuza 7 LAD next-gen version, Death's Door, The Medium, Naraka, etc. are not even in this article. So the actual list is a lot bigger.
DenchDeckard
Moderated wildly
Oh I was hoping that page was going to have both xbox and playstation deals listed but it's just xbox.
I found the ps5 one but at a glance it doesn't have deathloop, ffxvi, ffxvii..maybe more?
Last edited:
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
Off the top of my head, I remember, since the new consoles launch:
- Deathloop
- Ghostwire Tokyo
- Final Fantasy XVI
- Arcadegeddon
- Stray
- Sifu
- Tchia
- Final Fantasy VII Rebirth
- Forspoken
- Pathless
- Godfall
Cherrypepsi
Member
150h playtime on steam
this game is probably among my top 10 games of all time, congrats game pass owners that you get to play this for free. I downloaded it on my Series X to see how it runs and I really liked the performance mode.
It sucks that Playstation players have to wait 6 more months though.
this game is probably among my top 10 games of all time, congrats game pass owners that you get to play this for free. I downloaded it on my Series X to see how it runs and I really liked the performance mode.
It sucks that Playstation players have to wait 6 more months though.
You're going on like that is completely out of the question. Seems like you don't remember ME2.
Rykan
Member
My point was that it's hard to determine how much of a role it's art style played in its success because nearly every game released of that type is succesful on steam.
Most popular chart is fairly useless in this context, as it is very much a fotm genre, with games abandoned as soon as the next flavor comes out.