Tatami Galaxy-fin
Masterful is the word that comes to mind. It interweaves a complex narrative over enjoyable episodic material that at the same time conveys a heartwarming lesson. You can kinda predict how the story is going to unfold but the level of care put into the details and the overwhelming emotion put into the core of the story really makes it a transcendent work. The setting itself, taking place at college, is something I enjoy and the age of the characters also made it something unique. The early 20s is an age where a person can easily feel lost in trying to navigate through life and I'm sure there are plenty of people who wish they had redos. It's an age group that is rarely discussed in any serious manner in anime and it was refreshing to see a serious look at the emotional issues people in early adulthood are facing. The characters are all crazy to an extent but also sort of realistic in that there are people who are like that, even if they're not that insane. There are times where it seems like the show is losing control but Yuasa reigns everything in at the end.
The show won't win any awards for the animation but the art direction was really unique. I haven't seen much of Yuasa's stuff so the show had a really distinctive visual style to it. The character art in particular had this sort of surrealistic element to it that really worked. Yuasa plays around a lot with the character art such as with Ozu, and it helps with the narrative in that it reinforces the unreliable narrator bit. It also had a lot of energy and style to it that made the episodes just fun to watch. Episode 6 in particular was a riot. The soundtrack was also great at hitting those emotions and really nailing the tone in the scenes.
Something I never really note but struck out to me in Tatami is the VA work. Asanuma really had his hands full voicing Watashi. The breakneck speed of the narration really made it hard to follow at times and I'm sure Asanuma had his work cut out for him reading the script. It's so 'matter of factly' that I actually enjoyed this narration style as it was very dry and sarcastic to an extent. Another VA that I enjoyed immensely is Hiyama for Johnny. Oh man, Johnny's scenes were so good due to the influx of emotion from Hiyama.
The staff had a lot of fun playing around with the time travel elements, creating this complex universe composing of multiple characters in different stages. There's a lot going on in the backgrounds that can be very easy to miss if the audience isn't paying attention. However the interconnectivity is there and makes sense in the end. It reminded me of what I liked about Arrested Development's season 4 to a large extent. It's an impressive work just for that element alone.
The moral of the show isn't anything new. "Live life to the fullest and don't worry about making mistakes" isn't something new but the clever way Yuasa does it, really drives home the message. By watching Watashi repeatedly fail, the show makes it clear that there is no such as a perfect rosy life but rather just the one you're living. It's a fun show with a great and relevant message at the end.