So Cataclysm has been out 2 months and I'm curious as to what your overall opinion of it is now that the newness has worn off.
Overall I'd give it somewhere in the B- or C+ range. The problem is, I've come to expect at least A- quality from Blizzard.
I've played it a ton since it was released, probably 3-4 hours a day, at least 5-6 days a week. I've gotten 3 toons to 85 - SV hunter, kitty druid, and DK tank. SV hunter ilevel = 346, kitty druid ilevel = 342, and DK tank ilevel = 339. I've also levelled up 2 new toons - and now sit with a 47 lock, and a 25 warrior. I checked out the re-designed old world content with these new toons.
The problems I have with it start at the very beginning of the expansion. Everything is on rails and linear. This is a great departure from Lich King, which gave you 2 different choices of wide open zones to start Northrend. Inside these zones were sub areas and you could pick and choose where you wanted to go. In Cataclysm, you are forced to do quests in exactly the right order before quests in other parts of the zone will even open up to you. I found myself missing some quests and getting lost and not sure where to find the things I missed - happened twice to me in Uldum and Vash'jir. I eventually found what I missed but not without a lot of backtracking and help over general chat.
I'm not a fan of the on-rails questing in a MMORPG. Luckily I play on a PvE server. If I played on a PvP server, especially one that was population imbalanced, it would be pure hell in those opening days of the expansion. I personally like for players to be spread out and to have the choice of where to go. Blizzard couldn't even be bothered to seperate the factions in far different areas either. Everyone was funneled into the same places to compete for mobs (or against each other in the case of PvP servers). This was a big departure from both Burning Crusade and Lich King.
The next problem I had was with the massive amount of bugs that I encountered and still encounter to this day. Neither BC nor Lich King were even close to being as buggy for me as Cataclysm has been. I know my own experience is anecdotal and I've had people tell me that Lich King was far buggier for them. This is just my own personal experience though. I won't forget the game night ending bug I hit on night 2 in Vash'jir. Inside Nespirah there is a series of quests with this brain thing. One of them has you go upstairs to kill 10 of a certain mob, and the mobs wouldn't spawn. Since the mobs wouldn't spawn, you couldn't complete the quest, and since all the quests are on rails, you couldn't go to the next series of quests. What this meant is that the night was over, at least those of us in Vash'jir, at 7:30pm when the mobs stopped spawning. It was hotfixed the next day, but it was still annoying when it happened.
I found some other things that were quite annoying, such as phased nodes. Not so much annoying anymore since I know where they're at now after flying around them at least a hundred times, but very annoying in the beginning. You fly around Uldum for 5 minutes looking for Ore - you find it, only to have it disappear on you when you land. That's a nasty little cocktease Blizzard is pulling on us.
Dungeons and Raids - I need to preface this by saying that I play on an extremely casual server. I play on Nesingwary and this server has never been in the top 100 in terms of downing progression content. We're also listed as a 'New Players' server even though its been open for at least 2 years. What people find out is that if they want to raid and actually down bosses, its best to transfer somewhere else. There is an extremely limited amount of progression guilds on the server for both factions. You can count them on one hand and they seldom recruit. When they do, they only take the best of the best and the most dedicated - meaning, you don't miss a single raid night ever or you're benched. In fact, Nesingwary lost its top Alliance progression guild last night. They were 8/12 10-man, and the GM and officers disbanded the guild and transferred to another server.
I'm in somewhat of a casual guild. 250 toons total, maybe 10-15 people on at a given time. Good enough to do heroics, but not good enough to raid. What we found was that the regular dungeons were too easy, and the heroics were a little too hard at first. Once most of us got into the ilevel 340+ range, the heroics became easier, but still time consuming and unforgiving if you weren't really on your game and paying attention to boss mechanics. Sadly, it seems that most everyone in my guild, once they ran through the heroics a couple of times and got their toons into the mid ilevel 340s, just didn't want to do heroics anymore. They stopped doing them and started levelling up alts. The majority just seemed to feel like they were more of a chore instead of fun.
We tried BD twice and Bastion once. We didn't down a boss in either of them. Not sure what the problem was with Haifus, but we had 10-12 wipes with no progress. On Magmaw, DPS just wasn't getting down the adds fast enough. We could never figure out what the problem was as all the DPS were at least 13k+ in the encounter. Anyway, we haven't tried anything in about 3 weeks and everyone is just levelling alts or they've disappeared completely. It just feels like any enthusiasm for the game is dying in my guild. And as I mentioned earlier, its a pretty shitty server, so jumping to a better guild is just a crapshoot and I would probably end up in the same situation.
I will say that I'm probably the only person in the game who enjoys Tol Barad. Probably because we're on a very balanced server in terms of faction numbers and PvP skill and gear. Its working as intended on my server for some strange reason. The Horde will have it for a day or two, and then the Alliance will capture it and hold it for a day or two. Lots of back and forth on who owns it.
I think overall though, I'm pretty much done with the expansion. Like I said, my guild seems to be losing steam, the LFD is absolutely worthless, we're not good enough to raid. All of my reputations on all my 85s are maxed to where I want them - not all to exalted, but they all didn't need to be exalted because not all of them needed gear from the exalted level. In fact, only piece of rep gear left for me to get on any of my toons is the Tol Barad trinket for my kitty druid and about 2-3 more days worth of commendations and I'll have it. I find myself logging in and only doing dailies and a little bit of farming every day and that's about it. I'm pretty well bored with it.