I get why Destiny diehards don't like Bdobbins, but the game would be better with his suggestions.
I don't care about the fact that he's critical, or dislike him
personally, I dislike everything about what he's
doing with the format. In fact I hate it. As a result I hate anyone who does it in general (this includes "positive Destiny clickbait" too, agree or disagree), not him in particular. All this stuff you're saying plays exactly into his strategy on YouTube
The comments section for that video was full of people doing exactly what he talked about in the video, which was hilarious.
People seemed to only read the title of that video and before replying instead of listening to the content (it was titled "Destiny needs Overwatch heroes" or something along those lines).
All of this is by design. He names the video something clickbaity, puts even more controversial phrasing into the thumbnail in huge font, gets you to click, rants for 10+ minutes about something he doesn't like, the algorithm favors his videos. He is leveraging a system to maximize viewership and thus ad revenue.
Even if all of his criticisms were both valid
and I agreed with them all (I take major issue with several, and am more sympathetic to others including stuff that has been cited in this thread today), he is negating the value of all of that by playing to the negative preconceptions general audiences may have or, even worse, those that mostly enjoy "hate-playing" games. It's toxic. Even if good content can be found within the clickbait, it is by nature a negative enterprise.
An example of someone who has a lot of criticisms of the game, but offers them constructively and doesn't take part in these tactics would be TheJez, and I think his content is also generally much better for it.
They go up, but will always remain below your gear level so you won't be able to climb with them. It's mostly so you can boost alts higher, or for getting a higher powered weapon in a class you don't have a strong one in to infuse.
Yeah, still useful to get stuff "up to speed," I like it.