We are in the age where consumers will defend getting screwed over. You know why we have season passes and DLC? Because consumers are stupid enough to buy it and publishers know they are.
-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Dishonored |OT| The belle of the ball
- Thread starter Salsa
- Start date
Rickenslacker
Banned
Have multiple people claimed it to be 4-5 hours long? Or is it just one dude blitzing right through it? While I don't care for games that overstay their welcome I do hope it's more than Prey in length.
That's great to hear [that enemies are dangerous]. I'm not worried about length at all myself. As I've said a few times, I expect the game to take around 10-12 hours for the average person.
I'll be playing it on one difficulty higher than normal on my first time through, taking advantage of all my abilities and stealth, killing people when I feel my character would deem them worthy of dying.
I generally play through games only once, unless they've sucked my soul into their depths, like Persona 3/4 did, but I have nothing against paying full retail for 11 quality hours of gaming.
I'll be playing it on one difficulty higher than normal on my first time through, taking advantage of all my abilities and stealth, killing people when I feel my character would deem them worthy of dying.
I generally play through games only once, unless they've sucked my soul into their depths, like Persona 3/4 did, but I have nothing against paying full retail for 11 quality hours of gaming.
You don't. Still doesn't make complaints about time based on easy any less silly. Gears of War has a casual mode where you can tear through it without penalty, that game sucks too I guess!
I would figure a gaffer would choose at least normal.
The Wizard
Member
Out of interest, anyone here actually see the stream?
Dyni Crippler
Member
There are other people claiming it took them about 7 hours with the same approach.
Vinterbird
Member
I only play on easy, but that's because I'm not into frustration and retrys.
phantomspiker
Member
.I feel that many people on GAF are over-hyping this game.
I'll wait for reviews and people's opinions on this game before even considering it. While cool, a single player only game with a what? 10 hour campaign for $60 doesn't cut it.
People did the same thing for Darksiders 2, and we all know how that turned out, especially for PC.
I'll wait for reviews and people's opinions on this game before even considering it. While cool, a single player only game with a what? 10 hour campaign for $60 doesn't cut it.
People did the same thing for Darksiders 2, and we all know how that turned out, especially for PC.
I'll most likely wait for the Steam sale
IcyRhythms
Member
In the end, the only opinion or review that should matter is that of your own.
Alexios
Cores, shaders and BIOS oh my!
Well, I probably couldn't do that in Thief, Hitman or Deus Ex on my first playthrough (though maybe someone somewhere did) so while it obviously doesn't tell the whole story, it does tell some of it. Being on 4chan doesn't give people magic powers so as long as it's actually true (people said they've seen the stream, I'm not going to spoil myself) I don't see what that has to do with it.
D
Deleted member 80556
Unconfirmed Member
There's a difference between Brink and Dishonored and that is that people said that Brink needed work, while everyone has praised Dishonored so far. I think you're jumping to a conclusion here.
Hopefully it's just "yes, any approach REALLY WORKS" rather than just "this is a very short game".
Though another angle to think about: many of the games with the most freedom ARE fairly short, and if there's multiple methods to accomplish a goal (not just violent/non-violent) then I can definitely see why it can be that short on the easiest difficulty with the simplest method.
And $45? Or even $50?
No, it was just a bit worrisome to here the initial report. I am going to be playing completely opposite to what this player did and at a higher difficulty, so am expecting at least 10 or so hours from going stealthy and taking it all in. With that taken into account along with the replay value due to multiple paths and choices, I should be good. But on the other side of the coin, I hope the stealth does not end up feeling like a way to make the game longer. The mechanics and way you play is supposed to effect everything, though, so I kind of doubt that will be the case.
phantomspiker
Member
What self-imposed restrictions?
Playing the game on hard in a stealthy manner is going to take longer than playing the game on easy and killing everything in sight.
They are just different play styles.
You can it off GMG with 25% off.
Thief was designed in different age. The difference between the easiest difficulty in Thief and the easiest difficulty in modern games is fairly vast.
The easiest difficulty in Dishonored is probably a "you can beat this with one hand" mode, as is in most games nowadays.
Spider_Jerusalem
Member
Monday morning, 06:00 CET. Should be sunday 21:00 PST, if my math is right.
fluffydelusions
Member
I don't think I could justify even the $45 for a game only 4-7hrs long. Well whatever I'm just going to wait on reviews.
I think it'd be more interesting to know about normal with stealth, playing on Hard IS arguably a "restriction", while normal's the intended baseline for anyone competent with games and wanting something resembling a challenge (I believe).
Though given how much stuff you can just flip off it's definitely fair to question how long the game will actually be with these "self imposed restrictions" anyway.
Got my copy for 45 dollars! Never pay retail for PC gaming, too many deals.
I don't have a problem with people complaining about time. If it's too short for you, wait for a bigger price drop! I just can't understand the complaint from someone rushing through the game on easy mode.
It does indeed have autoaim, so yea probably true. Plus, the hints for puzzles and whatnot, and you can probably easily shorten the length by a couple hours.
Alexios
Cores, shaders and BIOS oh my!
But as I said before I find that problematic. If any approach works no approach should be less challenging and thus less time consuming, killing enemies should have good, varied and challenging gameplay that doesn't take that much less time than the stealth approach. Because when I'm discovered if it's a viable choice then I will kill the fuck out of someone rather than restart without having died. At least on my first playthrough. Just as I occasionally kill guards/zombies/whatever in Thief when it seems viable, ie, it's just one and I have a lot of health, although I still die sometimes. Generally, knowing I have alternatives lessens the tension and importance of my primary choice even if I do bother posing silly restrictions on myself. It's one thing to be tense because I could die if I fail and a whole other thing to just fail my personal achievement or whatever.
But yeah, knowing that you can have objective markers etc which I won't be using does indicate that it'll take me a bit longer than that at least, as that's a pretty big deal depending on the level design. As long as it's not actually annoying to find your way around without aids, it needs to feel good to explore your surroundings and not have illogically hard to find objectives, but cool to discover.
MrCookiepants
Member
You can turn hints and hud elements off in the PC version if you don't want the help. Not so sure about consoles though.
Skiesofwonder
Walruses, camels, bears, rabbits, tigers and badgers.
Is there any major differences between the PS3 and 360 version?
Currently I have the PS3 version pre-ordered.
Currently I have the PS3 version pre-ordered.
GrayFoxPL
Member
People who try to justify this saying that game X can be finished in few hours need to realize there's difference between first time playing game and speedrun when you know everything about it.
Everything points to that it is a short game. Maybe that 20 hours was for playtesters...
Everything points to that it is a short game. Maybe that 20 hours was for playtesters...
Apparently the AI is bad and the ending was anti-climactic, but that's just hearsay.
I'd have to find out how it's "bad". Is it in a fun way? MGS can have stupid AI but it's far more sophisticated than you'd see in Elder Scrolls, where they pretty much have two modes: don't know you're there/aggressive, and know you're there/aggressive. Also why I don't place any value in stealth for them.
phantomspiker
Member
Everything points? All we have to go on right now is a live stream from 4chan...that as far as I know, none of us have seen.
Anyone speak Greek? A review from HellinicGaming, whoever that is.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=haLrnOrApio
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=haLrnOrApio
Skiesofwonder
Walruses, camels, bears, rabbits, tigers and badgers.
Damn, I'm really questioning a purchase of this game now.... I rarely play games twice, so it might be a better rental if length concerns are true.
Why pull the link?
Interesting comments. Calling Dishonored a once in a generation type of game and game of the year. Bu bu bu 4 hours.
Edit: I see you made a new thread.
Due to a 4 hour run on Easy, folks.
This is why we have embargoes...
And maybe you need to realize there's a difference between a mode admittedly designed for "casual players", which apparently contains auto-aim and gives you solutions to puzzles isn;t an indication of what you're going to experience when playing on a normal difficulty level.
Alexios
Cores, shaders and BIOS oh my!
The embargo is what caused this, actually.
Not that I'm eager to believe the first "official" review yet.
That sounds absolutely terrible. How much longer could the game even be, if a rush is that short?
That embargo is the only reason why gamers are clamoring to seedy live streamers for info.
phantomspiker
Member
Yup, everyone having doubts should watch that.
Nothing wrong with grinding.
Skiesofwonder
Walruses, camels, bears, rabbits, tigers and badgers.
Obviously I'm not going to go and cancel my pre-order right now, but if I find out that the game is a 7-10 hour playthrough on hard (or below) for most experienced gamers, then yes I would seriously consider a weekend rental. I was expecting close to 20 hours honestly.
Similar threads
- Locked