-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Kendrick Lamar - good kid, m.A.A.d city |OT| No Beats By Dre
- Thread starter Macca
- Start date
- Status
PhoenixDark
Banned
It's good. There are a couple tracks that feel quite misplaced, especially Backstreet Freestyle. ASAP Rocky would tear that beat apart but Kendrick sounds like he's trying to pretend like he's someone he's not
The first half is a lot better than the second half
The first half is a lot better than the second half
IrishNinja
Member
Just listened through the album. As a whole the album is very easy to listen to, the sequencing is solid and the mix of bangers and 'album tracks' is perfect.
Production is as good as you could hope for. The beats certainly feel like they have been mixed and mastered for a full release album. I would say that the production falls short of Section.80, but that is always the case in a transition to studio albums. The album just does not offer the variety and jazzy production that made songs like Rigamortus so memorable. That's not to say that the album is not the collection of top tier beats that it is. Looking at the production credits, Kendrick has done a fantastic job at including a variety of producers while not sacrificing consistency.
Lyrically, I would have to listen a couple more times to form an opinion, but song themes seem to continue to be a strong point for K Dot.
Nice to see a Jay Rock feature!
Immediate standout tracks to me are
-track 1, Sherane
-Backseat Freestyle
-The Art of Peer Pressure
-Money Trees
-m.A.A.d city
-Swimming Pools
-Sing About Me
Time to seek out those bonus tracks!
Production is as good as you could hope for. The beats certainly feel like they have been mixed and mastered for a full release album. I would say that the production falls short of Section.80, but that is always the case in a transition to studio albums. The album just does not offer the variety and jazzy production that made songs like Rigamortus so memorable. That's not to say that the album is not the collection of top tier beats that it is. Looking at the production credits, Kendrick has done a fantastic job at including a variety of producers while not sacrificing consistency.
Lyrically, I would have to listen a couple more times to form an opinion, but song themes seem to continue to be a strong point for K Dot.
Nice to see a Jay Rock feature!
Immediate standout tracks to me are
-track 1, Sherane
-Backseat Freestyle
-The Art of Peer Pressure
-Money Trees
-m.A.A.d city
-Swimming Pools
-Sing About Me
holy shit this album is good, Kendrick is fucking going places
Time to seek out those bonus tracks!
The Return of
Banned
There is a female singing along Kendrick in the song before he says bitch don't kill my vibe and throughout the song.
dat Freudian slip
Face it Tiger..
Banned
YES I CAN FINALLY EAT!!
SCREW YOU GUYS, I CAN FINALLY EAT!
EDIT: Just started listening to Trap God.. Good kid is gonna have to wait.
SCREW YOU GUYS, I CAN FINALLY EAT!
EDIT: Just started listening to Trap God.. Good kid is gonna have to wait.
MidnightCowboy
Member
Jay Rock on Money Trees yessssssss
bobbychalkers
Member
This album is amazing....Every track is amazing but m.A.A.d city and Sing About Me were just....uggh....I wonder why Cartoons and Cereal didn't make the cut, its a perfect fit thematically and beat-wise. I'll probably do a track by track review later just for kicks and giggles.
CountBlack
Member
Made. me an Angel. on Angel. Dust
Don't bring that average overly preachy shit up in here.
IrishNinja
Member
eatin
gonna be interesting if i find any tracks i like more than recipe - which one's justo?
gonna be interesting if i find any tracks i like more than recipe - which one's justo?
CountBlack
Member
best description of it
ThanksVision
Member
I can't believe people dislike Backseat Freestyle. Kendrick goes full ignorant and absolutely dominates. He does not give one fuck, and it shows.
IrishNinja
Member
everything was good up to art of peer pressure, never really felt that track. money trees is bringing that vibe back round though...hey jay rock, cool
ChiefofCitadelSecurity
Member
Bitch, don't kill my vibe is so fucking good, shit is on repeat. Love the skit before it plays too.
Good kid is definitely an alright song but it so obviously a NERD leftover beat... its still too good for Kendrick. Which is kinda pathetic. It feels wasted. Even though Kendrick's album is amazing and better than any recent NERD album, the potential just wasn't really there, it isn't that special on the album. It is sadly a wasted effort for both sides.
IrishNinja
Member
kinda tired of Drake out've his lane lately, but Poetic Justice aint bad...rhyming over Janet like this works for me
ThirtyPlus
Member
Oh wow. Compton is back, I guess. Album of the year for me.
The Return of
Banned
It's pretty good, definitely my favorite major label debut album from the rappers who dropped in the past 2 years. I don't really strongly dislike any songs on here.
Backseat Freestyle is definitely a pass for me, it's just something I don't feel at all. I was very close to hating Money Trees in the first 20 seconds with the whole ya bish thing, it's very lame, but luckily the rest of the song is actually good.
One thing I personally kind of don't like is how hamfisted some of the themes are like it's very obvious this album has the whole peer pressure thing going on in different songs which is fine, but the need to put a skit to reinforce it as if I couldn't tell it was peer pressure going on. Right now it's just a minor complaint, but something that could just annoy me the more I listen to it.
But yeah, good album, I don't think it really has really lows but few songs are just okay to me while others are really great.
Backseat Freestyle is definitely a pass for me, it's just something I don't feel at all. I was very close to hating Money Trees in the first 20 seconds with the whole ya bish thing, it's very lame, but luckily the rest of the song is actually good.
One thing I personally kind of don't like is how hamfisted some of the themes are like it's very obvious this album has the whole peer pressure thing going on in different songs which is fine, but the need to put a skit to reinforce it as if I couldn't tell it was peer pressure going on. Right now it's just a minor complaint, but something that could just annoy me the more I listen to it.
But yeah, good album, I don't think it really has really lows but few songs are just okay to me while others are really great.
Holy shit...
SafeinSound
Member
Had no idea this was coming out. Really into Kendrick. Where are people listening to the album already? I assume downloaded? Is there a stream anywhere?
edit:
nevermind I found it
.
edit:
nevermind I found it
.Yeah, weak track, especially that boring ass beat. And coming right after the superior Bitch, Don't Kill My Vibe doesn't help.
Syph Medwes
Member
All y'all saying Backseat Freestyle isn't fire are crazy
As K.dot himself said
"This voice here is golden so fuck y'all I goes in"
KENDRICK HAVE A DREAM
seriously though can't stop listening to this album so happy it's living up to my expectations
As K.dot himself said
"This voice here is golden so fuck y'all I goes in"
KENDRICK HAVE A DREAM
seriously though can't stop listening to this album so happy it's living up to my expectations
GKMC - Kendrick delivers a cohesive album with a strong concept and storyline that offers depth while never feeling forced or in anyway detrimental to the song making process. He showcases a variety of flows, changes pace at will, and is self-aware enough to preach without abstaining himself of guilt. Sure the topics are quite familiar and a bit predictable at times, but Kendrick's passion is pretty much unparalleled. Some of the song structures are quite inventive, as are the beats, which helps the album from feeling repetitive despite its long length. GKMC is an album with layers that might be readily accessible, especially in this age of instant gratification and impersonal swag-toting self-ignorance. It reaches a level of introspection and emotion that other rappers would never touch. It's a shame how unsafe it has become to be real. GKMC is the album Kendrick wanted to make, not the album his studio told him to make.
10/10
Album Lows - Compton, Swimming Pools (Extended Version)
Album Highs - Everything Else
10/10
Album Lows - Compton, Swimming Pools (Extended Version)
Album Highs - Everything Else
MidnightCowboy
Member
Sing About Me wow
I think this my be my favourite track. Good Kid and Don't Kill My Vibe are up there also.
Still boring me a bit overall...only two listens so far, though.
LightOfTruth
Member
Cant believe people dont like Compton. Damn.
BSF is the lame song.
BSF is the lame song.
No one these days makes songs like Kendrick. I can't stress how important that is to me. Sure, Killer Mike is a better MC than Kendrick, and his album is great: dope beats, dope rhymes, solid thematic songs. But Kendrick's songwriting is just on another level. The fact that he makes the songs fit on a cohesive album makes him my favorite MC right now, by far.
Section.80 was my AOTY 2011. I still need to listen to it a few more times, but I'm pretty sure this will be my AOTY 2012.
Highs: m.a.a.d. city, swimming pools, sing about me (some was asking the other day the best three song stretch on an album - this is a contender), cartoons & cereals, money trees
Lows: Compton (I love Just Blaze, but that beat doesn't fit the album at all. Not a bad track, should have been saved no Detox), Poetic Justice (damn, Ab-Soul should be on this, not Drake...)
Section.80 was my AOTY 2011. I still need to listen to it a few more times, but I'm pretty sure this will be my AOTY 2012.
Highs: m.a.a.d. city, swimming pools, sing about me (some was asking the other day the best three song stretch on an album - this is a contender), cartoons & cereals, money trees
Lows: Compton (I love Just Blaze, but that beat doesn't fit the album at all. Not a bad track, should have been saved no Detox), Poetic Justice (damn, Ab-Soul should be on this, not Drake...)
Yeah, its easily one of the best songs on the album.
- Status