Interesting list. Of these, I've completed The Evil Within 2, Conker, and Prey. And I've dabbled in Pillars of Eternity, Enslaved, Sunset Overdrive, Gravoty Rush 2, and Vampire the Masquerade.
The ones I completed, I'm obviously a fan and wish they'd get sequels. Prey is an all-time classic, hurt by launch performance issues and lackluster reviews from reviewers who were salty they didn't get advance copies or didn't know how to play an immersive sim.
For the dabblers, they weren't my cup of tea or I wasn't in the right headspace.
I'd like to revisit Vampire the Masquerade at some point as it has the most vocal cult following. The others? Not so much.