I finally finished it with all the endings! Graduating to the SPOILERS thread now =).
Don't need to add much about how good the game is, since most of the other posts speak for themselves. I just want to add two points that I came up with after the experience:
1. If there are any forum lurkers hanging around wondering why it is that this thread has been alive for so long, I strongly recommend you to jump into the game feet first and with no expectations. Only know that storytelling is the game's most important asset, and as such you are in for a lot more reading than playtime. Notice how well the game has hooked players regardless.
2. If you already have the game, but have lost motivation to finish it due to the quirky "run through the whole game once again" experience, try to at least brave yourselves through it once more, and one more time, and again to get to enjoy the rewarding finale. If anything, do it for all of the puzzles that wouldn't otherwise being accessed without the replays.
The whole experience was a treat, and I really think people's enthusiasm on this thread helped fuel my want to complete the experience. I hope everyone takes advantage of that.