• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

American Horror Story: Asylum |OT| Nuns, and nazis, and scares! Oh, my!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Loved the episode, and the season. I thought the alien stuff wrapped up real nice, Kit and Jude had good closure as well.

The Lana video was very reminiscent of the documentary Willowbrook: The Last Great Disgrace Geraldo Rivera did in the 70's.

Youtube - Warning, very disturbing, NSFW
 

Persona86

Banned
When I saw this I was instantly reminded of Lana Banana's Son haha, any one else see the resemblance?

the-last-of-us-940x500.jpg



Loved this season as much as the first, I'm interested to see what they do next season and which actors will return. :)
 

TheSeks

Blinded by the luminous glory that is David Bowie's physical manifestation.
Were we supposed to know that woman who was at Kit's house when he rolled up with Jude?

Nope, which makes me think a hint of Season 3 is there.

And no fleshing the aliens out or resolution of them is making me also think they're going to continue that in season 3. American X-files Theme: doo doo dee doo doo doo...
 

TheSeks

Blinded by the luminous glory that is David Bowie's physical manifestation.
I still don't get the ending scene with the weird shot of Jude looking at Lana like the devil was thrown into Lana and the devil is "fame." (Since Jude wanted the Monsignor to become pope and ride his success) But the statue final shot also threw me for a loop. It's important in the credit theme but not really seen for the whole series besides "WHORE! *throw and break*" Arden scene and this scene.

And no, the intro episode had Lana and Jude walking down the stairs. They go outside and see Kit coming in. But the going down stairs bit was shorter than this scene.
 
Nope, which makes me think a hint of Season 3 is there.

And no fleshing the aliens out or resolution of them is making me also think they're going to continue that in season 3. American X-files Theme: doo doo dee doo doo doo...

Not necessarily. There really was no resolution to the baby/kid from last season. I was really looking forward to seeing a second season with the kid growing up and doing whatever crappy things he may end up doing. This was before I knew that each season would be its own story.

I'd like to know about the aliens, but I wouldn't be surprised if they just leave it as is.
 

TheSeks

Blinded by the luminous glory that is David Bowie's physical manifestation.
The baby was Bloodyface's Son's son! WhatATwist.jpg


But yeah, they went no where with that one. But I could see them shoe-horning that into "I don't want to say Aliens but... it's Aliens" territory despite season 1 being ghosts. :/
 
I really think it needs to be said again what an amazing actress Jessica Lange is -and last night I finally had a realization of what a tremendous actor Dylan McDermott is too. I had always had this "impression" of Jessica Lange, but taking both of these characters she's portrayed on the show-and the level to which she was willing to unglamorize herself this year really made me appreciate her.
 

White Man

Member
Not necessarily. There really was no resolution to the baby/kid from last season. I was really looking forward to seeing a second season with the kid growing up and doing whatever crappy things he may end up doing. This was before I knew that each season would be its own story.

I'd like to know about the aliens, but I wouldn't be surprised if they just leave it as is.


Pre-season 2 (and possibly pre-season 2 production) didn't someone close to the series say something along the lines of "you haven't seen the last of that baby?" I remember being kinda confused when it was announced that S2 was completely unconnected.

Anyway, liked the episode a ton. The biggest swerve of all was that there really wasn't a swerve. Only big shitty part was dyin' Jude's way overwrought and cheesy deathbed speech to the kids.
 

RatskyWatsky

Hunky Nostradamus
Pre-season 2 (and possibly pre-season 2 production) didn't someone close to the series say something along the lines of "you haven't seen the last of that baby?" I remember being kinda confused when it was announced that S2 was completely unconnected.

I remember Ryan Murphy saying something like that yeah. That he wanted to eventually return to that storyline and delve into it a little more or something like that.

Also,

Was the latest Horror Story all a hoax?

Some seem a bit confused about what the season finale’s callback to the premiere’s Jude/Lana scene meant – namely, there is speculation that perhaps Lana fabricated her asylum stay in the name of selling a book. What show boss Ryan Murphy shared after a press screening of the finale, though, puts that to rest. “Our jumping-off point for the whole season [was to have Lana] go in there, become a prisoner, do her shock-corridor tenure and then go back to tear the joint down,” he said. “That was the ending we had from the very beginning [and] I thought it was a very heroic ending for her.” Murphy also revealed that “for a split second” they considered having Bloody Face Jr. turn out to be Season 1′s Ben Harmon, “But I really like that the seasons have their own story.” Looking ahead to Season 3, Murphy teased that the story will be “more historical in nature,” include a “star-crossed-lovers-from-different-tracks thing” and perhaps not be quite as deviant as Asylum’s antics. “As a person right now,” he explained, “I do feel lighter and wanting to embrace something a little bit more fun.”
 

TheSeks

Blinded by the luminous glory that is David Bowie's physical manifestation.
Native American confirmed.

And Ben Harmon being Bloodyface would've been hilarious in a jumping-the-shark way.

I really do hope they go back to the season 1 baby. That cliffhanger is just bad to end on. We need to see how EVIL the baby is (and before Jessica Lange gets "old"er/retires from acting. D:)
 

Persona86

Banned
Jessica Lange, the guy who plays Lana's son and Kit's actor are all great actors. It's amazing when you compare them to season 1. And did you see how many different roles Jessica Lange had act do this season, she showed us many different sides to the character, Oscar worthy.
 
I absolutely loved the season and loved this finale. Hell, Paulson's costumes and styling alone in the flashback sequences made this episode sparkle! I thought that the ep also did a great job of paying off some of the themes of the season-- redemption, forgiveness, learning from one's mistakes. And that final flashback scene made perfect sense; we get a snapshot of Lana's early ambition before going into full bloom and we get to recall the horror that it wrought for her and for others, namely, her girlfriend at the time and later, her son. I thought that the ruthlessness of her shooting him when he made himself vulnerable was just perfect and gave the great, tart punch of a satisfyingly mixed ending. Fucking awesome and surprisingly effective.
 

Replicant

Member
Now that I've seen the episode again, the ending was just a way of saying that there's evil in everyone of us and if we're not careful, it'd get the best of us just like it got the best of Lana, Jude, and almost every other character.

Having said that, if Lana hadn't followed her ambition (her 'evil' side), she also wouldn't set off a chain of events which made life better for other people, namely Kit and Jude. if she hadn't gone to Briarcliff, Thredson may still going on killing women, Kit will be falsely sent to electric chair, and Jude will continue on her self-destruct path. Even though her choice caused her a lot of pain (and personal success), it also brought about better life path for others she met along the way. And oh, Briarcliff wouldn't have been exposed for their mistreatment of the mental patients if she hadn't gone there either.
 
I enjoyed the last episode and it was satisfying from a story perspective, tying up loose ends, but it was a bit of a damp squib in terms of actually being a horror story. When you think back to the first half of the season it was absolute insanity, each episode introducing a whole host of bizarre scenarios and characters and a smorgasbord of different horror tropes. From the moment Mary and Arden died the story took a more linear path, tying up the remaining threads of story but losing a bit of what makes the show fun -- the horror.

Granted, I never find the show scary, more ridiculous, but I feel a season should build to a climax, as a good horror film does, yet the horror climaxed a few episodes back and it's been running as a character drama with a few drops of horror since. That's not to say it was bad, I enjoy the characters and the end of their story, I just hope next season they have a more clear beginning, middle and end for the actual horror story.
 
did I miss he previous episode? wat happened to Keith's crazy girlfriend and his resurrected wife?

really like the slow closing of the series. "very smooth" transition to the end.
Lana cold blooded to the end
 
yeah, the horror in this one was on and off....I want something scarier next season I am still campaigning for the carnival freak show run but that might be to similar to an asylum ...but clowns man!
 

Killthee

helped a brotha out on multiple separate occasions!
did I miss he previous episode? wat happened to Keith's crazy girlfriend and his resurrected wife?
You must have, they explained that last week.
Alma ends up killing Grace cause she wouldn't shut up about the aliens. Alma then gets sent to Briarcliff and eventually ends up dying there. During his visits Kit spots Jude in there and that's how he finds out she's still alive.
 

braves01

Banned
I was hating the horrible melodrama of the final episode, up until the
Lana/McDermott
tete-a-tete, which redeemed the whole episode. A bitch to the end. lol

I hope next season is some New Orleans/Katrina voodoo horror a la Skeleton Key. I would love that.
 

woolley

Member
Sometimes it feels like I'm watching a different show then everyone else on here. I felt this season was boring and just all over the place and found the finale to be really boring and things were wrapped up too nicely.
 

TheSeks

Blinded by the luminous glory that is David Bowie's physical manifestation.
Sometimes it feels like I'm watching a different show then everyone else on here. I felt this season was boring and just all over the place and found the finale to be really boring and things were wrapped up too nicely.

Okay.

Anyway, if they jump on the Ass Creed 3 wagon/Native Americans I hope they don't shoe-horn/phone-it-in like Ass Creed 3 did. :/
 

braves01

Banned
Sometimes it feels like I'm watching a different show then everyone else on here. I felt this season was boring and just all over the place and found the finale to be really boring and things were wrapped up too nicely.

Up to the break, I thought the show was much better than S1. Maybe not scarier, but better overall. After about episode 9 it really fell of though imo. That said, I liked the last 10-15 minutes quite a bit. The nice thing is that AHS is an anthology of sorts so the relative weakness of the end of the season won't carry over like in a traditional serial drama.
 
That was quite a lovely finale. I really liked how Kit came back and rescued Jude and she spent her final days, you know, loved. We didn't get closure with the aliens, but I'm kind of alright with that. I loved Kit's final shot as he's about to die and they come for him. I hope we see the aliens return at some point in the series. And hey... Lana's tough, but she ain't no cookie. Too bad Howard didn't get eviscerated with an alien ray gun. I'm a little disappointed about that :/ I hope they give Fiennes a meatier part if he returns next season.

Great finale. Except... they didn't explain the Bloody Face imposters from like Episode 3. Why were they there?
 

Zoe

Member
Can someone more hip than myself explain the best way to search Tumblr? I wanna see if anybody got a capture of that mystery woman.
 

braves01

Banned
That was quite a lovely finale. I really liked how Kit came back and rescued Jude and she spent her final days, you know, loved. We didn't get closure with the aliens, but I'm kind of alright with that. I loved Kit's final shot as he's about to die and they come for him. I hope we see the aliens return at some point in the series. And hey... Lana's tough, but she ain't no cookie. Too bad Howard didn't get eviscerated with an alien ray gun. I'm a little disappointed about that :/ I hope they give Fiennes a meatier part if he returns next season.

Great finale. Except... they didn't explain the Bloody Face imposters from like Episode 3. Why were they there?

I suppose we're just supposed to take that at face value? They were impostors that may or may not have been caught. A little disappointing, you're right.

From Fiennes suicide I get that he never really overcame his pride in that he chose to kill himself rather than face his crimes. I REALLY liked Lana's end however. She was (or became) the evil that she (or Jude in this case) came face-to-face with. It's open to interpretation of course, but in my mind she along with Fiennes was the evil ambitious figure who knew no bounds, unlike Arden who valued the purity of Sister Eunice.

Can someone more hip than myself explain the best way to search Tumblr? I wanna see if anybody got a capture of that mystery woman.

The woman/angel in black? Or Lana's later lover?
 

Judderman

drawer by drawer
Amazing finale. That scene with Jude and Death was incredible.

Great finale. Except... they didn't explain the Bloody Face imposters from like Episode 3. Why were they there?

Seems to be a pattern with the series. Didn't the first season have some people trying to recreate the murders in the house?
 

Nemesis_

Member
Great finale. Except... they didn't explain the Bloody Face imposters from like Episode 3. Why were they there?

I was thinking about this after you raised the question but I got a Prometheus effect where it made less sense as I thought about it.

Basically I interpreted it to mean that Ryan and Brad were playing around with the idea of how someone who does horrible things can become so infamous (this is reaffirmed by Lana's speech at the beginning of her interview during the modern day and how she didn't want to give him as much coverage) and it kind of calls back to the second episode of the first season where some nuts want to reenact crimes that happened in the Harmon house so many years ago.

But then I also wonder why would they go to Briarcliff? Were they literally just wanting to explore an abandoned place where Bloody Face was purported to live? Or were they following Leo and Teresa to mess around with them? Or were they just weird teenagers who got a little bit weird as soon as they put on the mask (this is a psychological phenomena, btw).

There are a few questions surrounding it, you're right. I think honestly it was just written in to keep the modern day sub plot going and to keep us guessing for the first few episodes, and also to foreshadow that Bloody Face would remain infamous both now and then.
 

Zoe

Member
The only people I recall being in Kit's house were his wife (the black one I don't remember her name), Grace, and Jude at the end. What episode?

This last one. There was a woman that the camera lingered on when he drove up with Jude.
 

Killthee

helped a brotha out on multiple separate occasions!
The only people I recall being in Kit's house were his wife (the black one I don't remember her name), Grace, and Jude at the end. What episode?
The mystery woman was in last nights episode. I think she appears when Kit first takes Jude home.
 

Nemesis_

Member
The friends I watched the episode with also claim they saw her at the wedding, I tried to find her but I couldn't.

Could she just be a Nanny or something? Or Kit's "current" girlfriend?

tsRwXF9.png


xfGPgzK.png
 

Judderman

drawer by drawer
The friends I watched the episode with also claim they saw her at the wedding, I tried to find her but I couldn't.

Could she just be a Nanny or something? Or Kit's "current" girlfriend?

tsRwXF9.png


xfGPgzK.png

How much time passed between the time Lana and Kit talked and his wedding?
 

braves01

Banned
The friends I watched the episode with also claim they saw her at the wedding, I tried to find her but I couldn't.

Could she just be a Nanny or something? Or Kit's "current" girlfriend?

tsRwXF9.png


xfGPgzK.png

Is that the woman Kit married later on? There was a marriage scene but I didn't get a good look at his new wife.
 
You must have, they explained that last week.
Alma ends up killing Grace cause she wouldn't shut up about the aliens. Alma then gets sent to Briarcliff and eventually ends up dying there. During his visits Kit spots Jude in there and that's how he finds out she's still alive.
Ah thanks for the recap.
 

Revolver

Member
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom