Well, that's fucking bullshit.
Just decided to look at Blacksteel Katana +0 vs. Great Club +10. One has A-scaled DEX while the other has A-scaled STR. Katana had a bonus of 112 vs. the club's 182. I can't tell you how high the A is for the club, but upgrading the katana even once pushes it into S-scaling going off weapon charts. For clarity, I have 50 STR/DEX, giving a bonus of 155.
Seeing as base damage has nothing to do with scaling, you know what this means?
An A for DEX is an F for STR*.
*Exaggerating, but you get the point
If the DEX-based weapon you're using doesn't have innate poison/bleed damage, you may as well throw it away. Most DEX-based weapons deal shit base damage due to their weight and have shit scaling even if it says it doesn't. You could put the STR scaling to use, but if you're gonna do that, why not use an STR-based weapon?
I knew that my Claws +10 couldn't scratch heavily armored players, but knowing why they can't doesn't make me feel much better. Ugh.
Thanks for going through the trouble. The bolded really shows how bad stat scaling is.
I think base damage for weapons might be a bit too high actually. If they lowered unupgraded base damage, scaling would feel like it did more. An unupgraded mace will get you so far in this game. But on top of that they should increase STR scaling slightly and give a more moderate boost to DEX scaling. Then, have weapon buffs scale with stats so that resonant weapon with 50INT/FTH does as much as it would now with any stats. You shouldn't be able to spice down a buff and get the same damage output as someone with like 60 more levels invested in the stats.
Well, in that particular case, it may have to do with stat investments barely doing anything past 50 in the first place.
From 50 to 99, there's only a +45 boost to bonus and the Vanquisher's Seal gets 75% of STR bonus and 25% of DEX. Besides, at 50 STR/DEX, I'm already dealing a lot of damage with fists only. Seriously, Vanquisher's Seal is nuts and I thought dual Caestus +10 was already good (PvE wise, at least. You may have trouble against heavily-armored players).
While I'm at it, I should mention the Flamberge and Zweihander had C-scaling for DEX, which translated to around 25% from DEX bonus.
Agreed on buffing. Resonant Weapon in particular is ridiculous. Would like it nerfed for anyone that isn't heavily invested in INT/FTH. Not sure I agree on STR scaling needing even a slight boost, but DEX could certainly use one.
The dubsteps edits always gets me.
Yeah, they're just so perfect. lol
Holy shit. Guess I should have gone the way of the hex from the beginning.
I still find beating the crap out of people with my bare hands more fun, but yeah, embracing the dark is tempting. And, if you're up against something resistant to dark, you've got a high enough Faith investment to throw a few lightning spears.
Maybe when I finally get enough Twinkling Titanite for all my gear and finish NG+.