DF: Switch 2 vs Steam Deck: Cyberpunk 2077 Benchmarked - Docked & Handheld Tested

Disagree on the Steam Deck, sold mine because it was such a cumbersome, lugubrious beast to use.

I haven't used a Switch 2 yet.
As someone who owns both, the Steam Deck is infintely more comfortable in the hands than the S2. A properly thick handheld with properly sized joysticks and bigger battery was on the cards, but Nintendo stuck with the ergonomic nightmare of a design that they came up with nearly a decade ago, replete with the same tiny Vita-style joysticks.
 
You are forgetting that this is also the Steam OLED, which got a memory bandwidth upclock to 102.8 gb/s (the original was 88.8 gb/s). Switch 2 is 66 GB/s in handheld mode, efficiency wise it's not even damn close.

Finally watching video, I didn't think they picked the OLED Steam deck, so that's even more powerful than the OG.
 
To Nintendo Switch 2 haters…
20Ts5FsQx8Gjz3MK.jpeg

🤣🤣🤣
 
I'd like to see Rich do one of these comparisons but with his RTX 2050 laptop he used to try to estimate the Switch 2's performance a while back.

It would be neat to see how that kit ended up comparing to the real thing.
 
A new arm processor is faster and more power efficient than an x86 apu from 6 years ago???
shocker-what-a-shocker.gif
Except it's not new, it's an Nvidia APU made around basically the same time as the Aerith AMD APU (2020-2021-ish)
As someone who owns both, the Steam Deck is infintely more comfortable in the hands than the S2. A properly thick handheld with properly sized joysticks and bigger battery was on the cards, but Nintendo stuck with the ergonomic nightmare of a design that they came up with nearly a decade ago, replete with the same tiny Vita-style joysticks.
While I agree the Deck's bigger, fuller ergonomics make it more comfortable for gaming, I can actually comfortably game in bed with the Switch 2 at night, which I absolutely can not with the Deck. The Deck feels heavier and more unwieldily, it's uncomfortable to prop up with your arms alone compared to the Switch 2. I also fucking despised the Switch 1 handheld ergonomics so the S2 being actually usable with big hands is a massive upgrade for me.

Utterly irrelevant, as thanks to the cheapskates that Nintendo are, the cheap ass, low capacity battery in the S2 lasts as long as the Steam Deck in spite of the 3 fold reduction in power consumption.
I disagree with the battery being a "cheapskate" move, the Switch 2 is like 1/3 of the thickness of the Steam Deck, I think it was more a choice of ergonomic design. The S2 would've likely been bulky as hell with a larger battery setup, which doesn't work right with the joycon design and whatnot. Considering the Pro Controller and Joycons themselves have excellent battery life compared to competing hardware, I highly doubt Nintendo deliberately put in a tiny battery to be cheap.

Plus, the Deck OLED is $100 (with the larger battery) more than the Switch 2, which is the one getting two and a half hours. The OG Deck barely can last an hour and 15 minutes playing Cyberpunk.
 
Last edited:
Just finished video

The image quality is not even comparable, even with lord and savior github tinkering for XeSS in the end 🤡

That's a nail in the coffin
For portable? Native resolution works, as those settings are lower than the Steam Deck preset, so no FSR or XeSS needed. Docked is naturally not even comparable, Steam Deck will never match that.
 
Just finished video

The image quality is not even comparable, even with lord and savior github tinkering for XeSS in the end 🤡

That's a nail in the coffin
Agree, this debate is over. For me was pretty obvious weeks ago… A W for the Switch 2. But some people are not going to take the L.
 
For portable? Native resolution works,

Yes because CP2077's TAA sucks and without having a Steam deck I can't imagine a 720p native is that good, lots of ghosting and too much flickering, even at 1080p, XeSS is recommended over it largely on steamdeck reddit, I can't imagine at 720p or 800p its suddenly fine.

But by all means, if DF thinks there's a solution with much better image quality on Steam deck and retains close to 30 fps, why not go through the demonstration?

DF's own words is that there's no solution to beat T239's handheld resolution results. The handheld "smooth" 30 fps on steam deck is also with FSR3 and not XeSS which gets a hit on performance.

as those settings are lower than the Steam Deck preset,

Ok? DF I believe set the Steam deck to those settings he found are closely matched? Some out of bounds in upper and lower range but still how much we expect the impact difference really.

isn't switch 2 hardware from 2021?

T239 was tape out in 2021 yes. There can be slight revisions afterwards to correct errors after production attempts but the overall product, architecture and design is frozen.

With Samsung 8nm node, they are so fucking efficient, witchcraft

Blow Your Mind Wow GIF by Product Hunt


Was AMD APU just that bad all this time because there was no competition or something?

Makes me wish either Sony or Microsoft would have went with Nvidia to spice things up. Imagine Xbox handheld Nvidia but a lot higher clocks, more SMs and better node. Would have been way more interesting than ROG Ally Xbox.
 
Last edited:
The issue with 2 in 1 devices is that one of the use cases will be compromised. Due to the Switch 2 being a handheld, you'd assume that the most compromised aspect would be the docked mode due to the power restrictions. However, the handheld mode is actually the worst way to use the switch 2. That in itself is wild because if you have the ability to use the Switch 2 docked, then you can also use a proper console or pc docked.

Handheld mode being the worst way to use the Switch 2 just makes the whole thing sad. Barring the known issues with the Switch 2 in portable mode being weaker than the Deck Oled or almost all other pc handhelds, it's just completely uncomfortable to use. The ergonomics make it less than ideal for handheld mode. The joycons which while bigger are still just as bad as the first joycons.

Honestly, the best way to use the switch 2 is in docked mode where it actually delivers respectable performance. However due to the design choices made by Nintendo, the switch 2 is once again relegated to a "Nintendo games" only device instead of a general gaming device. Unfortunate really as 3rd party games are basically better on any other platform both in handheld mode and docked mode.
 
So. who won at the end for better image quality? Steam Deck or Switch 2 not docked ? (Docked is a 100% win for the S2 ).
 
I think so. So yeah you could pretty much throw anything out there in a modern form and it would outdo the older platforms without DLSS.
It'll be fun to see it outperform the upcoming ROG Xbox Ally as well.
The thing with Switch 2, besides dlss, is that devs do proper ports for it. PC handhelds just get the normal PC versions and has to brute force through bad optimization, which is difficult on a handheld with no extra headroom.
 
Switch 2 beat a 3 year old system, how unexpected. Keep in mind there's eventually gonna be a new Steam Deck with FSR4 dominating the S2, before you have a ticker-tape parade.
 
It'll be fun to see it outperform the upcoming ROG Xbox Ally as well.
The thing with Switch 2, besides dlss, is that devs do proper ports for it. PC handhelds just get the normal PC versions and has to brute force through bad optimization, which is difficult on a handheld with no extra headroom.

Rog ally xbox I doubt, I mean they are inefficient with so much compute and bandwidth starved, but they'll brute force their way. But one thing remains, they are stuck with non AI FSR. So...

A demo of Wild hearts just dropped on Switch 2 btw



4k is probably capture but it seems to hit high fps, 60 ? Seem to be frame for frame on Youtube for 60

Switch 2

l4i1o4v.png



Xbox Series S

pPGlKtC.png


PS5

VoCKbKD.png


Steamdeck has a rough time with this game, I thought every systems did actually, that this was badly optimized



ZmVBStmWOO3pJ518.jpg


The hitch on steam deck as he approachs the "loading" passage compared to switch 2





Oh No Fire GIF
 
Switch 2 beat a 3 year old system, how unexpected. Keep in mind there's eventually gonna be a new Steam Deck with FSR4 dominating the S2, before you have a ticker-tape parade.

Switch 2 2021 taped out SOC on Samsung 8nm beat Steam Deck 2023 OLED on TSMC 6nm, by a factor of nearly 3 times in efficiency

Yes, unexpected. Nobody predicted that when they announced the specs and the samsung foundry, not even DF.
 
Rog ally xbox I doubt, I mean they are inefficient with so much compute and bandwidth starved, but they'll brute force their way. But one thing remains, they are stuck with non AI FSR. So...

A demo of Wild hearts just dropped on Switch 2 btw



4k is probably capture but it seems to hit high fps, 60 ? Seem to be frame for frame on Youtube for 60

Switch 2

l4i1o4v.png



Xbox Series S

pPGlKtC.png


PS5

VoCKbKD.png


Steamdeck has a rough time with this game, I thought every systems did actually, that this was badly optimized



ZmVBStmWOO3pJ518.jpg


The hitch on steam deck as he approachs the "loading" passage compared to switch 2





Oh No Fire GIF

IDK Koei Tecmo are really bad with game optimization, so I wouldn't use it to measure the performance of anything... I can't see the demo in the US eshop BTW
 
IDK Koei Tecmo are really bad with game optimization, so I wouldn't use it to measure the performance of anything... I can't see the demo in the US eshop BTW

Yea seems to be europe so far

Yea the game looks like a fucking mess, any consoles, to be honest. Still somehow they managed to transfer the mess better than I thought they would. For sure there's gonna be cutbacks, it seems to be unlocked fps and very variable, seems to aim 40 fps, but it looks fucking clean ? Unexpected.. Switch 2 left, Series S right. I think it might have better parity in cutscenes, a bit less comparable in gameplay as it seems also the devs have worked on Switch 2 to tweak things around. It seems right now that on switch 2 they have fixed the global illumination bug that consoles were affected with that didn't have proper shadow. Look at the underside of the leave where the bug is in the screenshot. Its the same for when the character is underneath something overhead like a cave, the other versions are lit from everywhere while Switch 2 is dark as one would expect. Will be an interesting DF video for sure. I see they removed SSR water on switch 2. It was so bad on consoles too, not sure if a loss.

TzlcPSI9IZPsnyRb.jpg



M1CMAnwBtFXNNPhC.jpg
 
Last edited:
Yes because CP2077's TAA sucks and without having a Steam deck I can't imagine a 720p native is that good, lots of ghosting and too much flickering, even at 1080p, XeSS is recommended over it largely on steamdeck reddit, I can't imagine at 720p or 800p its suddenly fine.

But by all means, if DF thinks there's a solution with much better image quality on Steam deck and retains close to 30 fps, why not go through the demonstration?

DF's own words is that there's no solution to beat T239's handheld resolution results. The handheld "smooth" 30 fps on steam deck is also with FSR3 and not XeSS which gets a hit on performance.
Native gives you better resolve than DLSS at resolutions this low. Even in Cyberpunk. Come on man, you game on PC you know this. DLSS doesn't match native, even at 1080p, much less 720p. Old DLSS 3.x would only surpass native at 4k/DLSS Quality or maybe 1440p/DLSS Quality. This isn't using the newer transformer model, it's not going to pull miracles upscaling from 450p to 810p. You have a PC, try native 720p vs DLSS Quality at 720p for example. XeSS is recommended on the deck because people want to use higher settings than what the Switch 2 uses (the higher Steam Deck preset I mentioned), or not have such severe FPS drops in Phantom Liberty, Switch 2 is shit out of luck there.

It's also clearly shown (from 22:15) that the native results on the Deck still offer higher performance (albeit only slight) than the DLSS results on the Switch 2, so you don't need to use FSR or XeSS if you want comparable performance at the same graphical settings.
 
Last edited:
By the way



I'm sure Rog ally X is smoother, but without performance metrics, is it that obvious? Incredible what its doing with 9 watts

I'll wait for a DF analysis where image quality can be compared and docked vs undocked. Wild guess is that Switch 2 takes that one because of dlss and real dev optimization.
 
So the Steam Deck is the better portable device because it has a bigger battery and draws more wattage. Plus it has OLED. Plus is has better ergonomics. Plus it has Steam OS/Steam sales. Plus you don't pay for online or cloud saves. Cyberpunk Ultimate is $38 bucks right now on Steam and It's $70 on Nintendo's eshop. Steam Deck came out like 3.5 years ago and it's neck and neck with a Nintendo console that came out last month?! Come on, Gaf Bros …

I get it. Nintendo games have that secret sauce but they are bending their fan base over hard.

Are You Crazy GIF by The Roku Channel

The elephant in the room...

0vMGTuUOeOFemjaR.jpg
 
Handheld mode being the worst way to use the Switch 2 just makes the whole thing sad. Barring the known issues with the Switch 2 in portable mode being weaker than the Deck Oled or almost all other pc handhelds, it's just completely uncomfortable to use. The ergonomics make it less than ideal for handheld mode. The joycons which while bigger are still just as bad as the first joycons.
The large screen, kickstand and thin profile make it the perfect device for tabletop mode, where you can use the Pro controller. What is more comfortable than holding a portable device with an ergonomic grip? Not holding the portable device at all!
 
Very impressive! So much so that I'd be tempted to pick it up on Switch 2, despite owning it on PC and PS5. Obviously not for £60 but if it drops to around £25-30 I'll be all over it for a second playthrough.
 
I have Switch 2 and Steam deck OLED and cyberpunk and Street Fighter 6 on both.

Digital Foundry are still bitter about being left out of the Steam deck launch and have gone above and beyond to trash it or ignore it.

When you put a switch 2 and a steam deck oled side by side with these games running on them (forget docked), there is no comparison. A child could see the difference. Steam deck looks a generation ahead.

Switch 2 is another underpowered Nintendo.

Sorry. But it's the truth.
I don't know man, I've got both and when playing Cyberpunk 2077 next to each other they look and perform extremely close. The only real advantages the deck has is faster loading and a superior display. Could just be the OLED that makes it look so much better for you?

The only game I've played so far that might qualify as a generation ahead is Hogwarts Legacy, the Switch 2 has last-gen assets while the Deck has the full current generation. But even then the Switch 2 can look a bit sharper due to the higher output resolution.
 
Last edited:
I don't know man, I've got both and when playing Cyberpunk 2077 next to each other they look and perform extremely close. The only real advantages the deck has is faster loading and a superior display. Could just be the OLED that makes it look so much better for you?
That means you're not a child, otherwise you would've seen it. I showed my 2 yo son and he was like "the higher contrast of the screen of the OLED coupled with the XeSS upscaling technology puts the Steam Deck version a generation ahead of the Switch 2, which isn't surprising considered Nintendo's history with hardware over the past 20+ years".

Which was surprising cause he doesn't even speak english.
 
Last edited:
So in conclusion, in portable mode the old OLED Steam deck performs better(screen is lower resolution), haa a much better screen, the battery lasts as long, games are cheaper, it can be expanded to several TB of storage, its a PC so completely open, can be used as a PC when docked.
 
So now the Switch obviously performs better, we have people starting about cheaper games and storage in a comparison thread between 2 versions.....
Talk about moving the goalpost.
moving-goalposts-goalposts.png
 
So now the Switch obviously performs better, we have people starting about cheaper games and storage in a comparison thread between 2 versions.....
Talk about moving the goalpost.
moving-goalposts-goalposts.png
Yet others get a bit upset when you point out that the Switch 2 doesn't look or perform better in handheld mode. Wasn't the narrative before launch that the Switch 2 utterly destroys the Steam Deck in portable play in this game?
 
Yet others get a bit upset when you point out that the Switch 2 doesn't look or perform better in handheld mode. Wasn't the narrative before launch that the Switch 2 utterly destroys the Steam Deck in portable play in this game?
Well i believe that's because people are being obnoxious about it.
Also, SD framerate is more stable but image quality is crap, for the average user Switch2 will be the better experience.
 
So all the talk about Switch 2 needing lower than low crowd density was complete rubbish.
I've played Cyberpunk quite a bit (more than 200h, I believe), and I think it uses a system where NPC quantity is greatly reduced when driving (specially at high speeds)

Most videos of it running on the S2 before release were of driving, so maybe thats why
 
Native gives you better resolve than DLSS at resolutions this low. Even in Cyberpunk. Come on man, you game on PC you know this. DLSS doesn't match native, even at 1080p, much less 720p. Old DLSS 3.x would only surpass native at 4k/DLSS Quality or maybe 1440p/DLSS Quality. This isn't using the newer transformer model, it's not going to pull miracles upscaling from 450p to 810p. You have a PC, try native 720p vs DLSS Quality at 720p for example. XeSS is recommended on the deck because people want to use higher settings than what the Switch 2 uses (the higher Steam Deck preset I mentioned), or not have such severe FPS drops in Phantom Liberty, Switch 2 is shit out of luck there.

It's also clearly shown (from 22:15) that the native results on the Deck still offer higher performance (albeit only slight) than the DLSS results on the Switch 2, so you don't need to use FSR or XeSS if you want comparable performance at the same graphical settings.



Cyberpunk 2077's TAA solution is shit

And DF covered it also for PS4

But do tell me why 99% of steam deck Reddit recommends XeSS over native then?

You say better or equivalent image quality and higher FPS… why would anyone enable upscaler then?

Yet others get a bit upset when you point out that the Switch 2 doesn't look or perform better in handheld mode. Wasn't the narrative before launch that the Switch 2 utterly destroys the Steam Deck in portable play in this game?

DF for handheld says in their video that switch 2 has the edge for visual clarity

For the bolded part, lol my dude, you can't be serious?

Steam deck boys had ONLY the dock footage available and were all saying it looks better on steam deck. Entire DF YouTube comment sections and even here on neogaf filled by the dozen of SD fanboys making sure everyone knows that steam deck exists and is an option, spreading the good word like Jehovah witnesses.
 
Last edited:


Cyberpunk 2077's TAA solution is shit

And DF covered it also for PS4

But do tell me why 99% of steam deck Reddit recommends XeSS over native then?

You say better or equivalent image quality and higher FPS… why would anyone enable upscaler then?



DF for handheld says in their video that switch 2 has the edge for visual clarity

For the bolded part, lol my dude, you can't be serious?

Steam deck boys had ONLY the dock footage available and were all saying it looks better on steam deck. Entire DF YouTube comment sections and even here on neogaf filled by the dozen of SD fanboys making sure everyone knows that steam deck exists and is an option, spreading the good word like Jehovah witnesses.

version 1.62 rly???
 
Well i believe that's because people are being obnoxious about it.
Also, SD framerate is more stable but image quality is crap, for the average user Switch2 will be the better experience.
It's native 720p. Absolutely nothing crap about that. DLSS 3 is not better than native at those resolutions, and no serious PC gamer has ever bothered to make that claim.



Cyberpunk 2077's TAA solution is shit

And DF covered it also for PS4

But do tell me why 99% of steam deck Reddit recommends XeSS over native then?

You say better or equivalent image quality and higher FPS… why would anyone enable upscaler then?

I already explained why, as XeSS allows you to get back more performance, especially in Dog Town. Unless you think playing well under 30fps is good? Because that is what happens when you drive anywhere in Dog Town, be it with the Switch 2 or if your play at native on the Steam Deck. Switch 2 can drop to a buttery 18fps in those scenarios, at least with the deck you can trade in a bit of visual fidelity for a closer lock to 30fps. Hence the obvious XeSS recommendations.
DF for handheld says in their video that switch 2 has the edge for visual clarity
Yes, Richard said image quality is cleaner when comparing the Switch 2 to the Steam Deck when using FSR or XeSS. Notice they never said anything about it looking better than native at those low pixels counts, because only the most extreme PC fanboys would ever claim anything like this. Anybody who knows anything about PC gaming knows that at the more your resolution drops, the more DLSS 3 struggles to offer a comparable or better image as native. You have a PC, I'll reiterate, test it for yourself. You'll quickly notice that while DLSS has the upper hand in stability, in looses in clarity, especially in motion.

Hardware Unboxed did a good video about this:



That's at 1080p no less, dropping the resolution further does DLSS no favours.
For the bolded part, lol my dude, you can't be serious?

Steam deck boys had ONLY the dock footage available and were all saying it looks better on steam deck. Entire DF YouTube comment sections and even here on neogaf filled by the dozen of SD fanboys making sure everyone knows that steam deck exists and is an option.
Of course I'm serious. Don't try and gaslight me, or does Gigabowsers nonsense not count? I can pull up dozen posts on this forum which claimed the Switch 2 will outperform the Steam Deck in portable play, including yours.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom