Mr.Deadshot
Member
Yeah no "Baldur" is striking and ridiculous. Baldur's Gate 2 easily is Top 10 material.Ctrl-F "Baldur"
(No results)
Both Destiny and Horizon are better than the Witcher 3 though. So I'll give them that.
Yeah no "Baldur" is striking and ridiculous. Baldur's Gate 2 easily is Top 10 material.Ctrl-F "Baldur"
(No results)
Doom 2016 but no original Doom? Are EDGE hiring undergraduates now?
Yeah, truth be told.. it's not a good list. You're going to have to really explain why you're leaving out classic RPGs like Final Fantasy VII, IX and X that have aged well to this day whilst including in XII, a good game that is however not considered to present the finest the series can offer.
Yeah no "Baldur" is striking and ridiculous. Baldur's Gate 2 easily is Top 10 material.
Both Destiny and Horizon are better than the Witcher 3 though. So I'll give them that.
Yeah no "Baldur" is striking and ridiculous. Baldur's Gate 2 easily is Top 10 material.
Both Destiny and Horizon are better than the Witcher 3 though. So I'll give them that.
More than anything, this list shows that we've reached a point where there are just too many great games to rank. There are so many more games just as worthy of being in a top 100, its almost silly.
It's a good, valid list. But you could make another top 100 with entirely different games and say the exact same thing.
Eww Super Mario 3D World? Worst 3D Mario.
Great list. No prob with BotW at #1. Easily well deserved by a mile.
Also, super happy to see the From games, Dark Souls 1, Bloodborne and Demon's Souls all well positioned in the top 25.
One thing that I find odd is how can games like Splatoon 1 and
Kerbal Space Program be justifed being above A Link to the Past. Those, even though great games in their own, are not in the same league as THE legendary Zelda classic.
What was #1 before though, Dark Souls???
FF7 has not aged well. And while FF9 is a classic and a great game compared to tge modern era of all gaming, it is not a glaring ommission by any stretch. Have FF10 but never played.
=
97. Final Fantasy XII
83. BioShock
77. Xenoblade Chronicles
72. Metroid Prime
70. Castlevania: Symphony of the Night
62: Persona 4 Golden
46. Dead Space
35. The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
16. Super Mario World
14. Super Mario 64
9. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
2. Dark Souls
If I was going to make a top 100 list these are the only ones that would feature and not in that order. Not that I would have ever expected there to be much overlap between me and Edge
I find it odd that anyone could think Resogun is one of the greatest games ever made but everyone's entitled to their opinion
Happy to see Monster Hunter and Tetris make it in. Seeing Puyo Puyo is awesome even though Puyo Puyo 2 holds up a lot better.
No Shenmue? Can't take this serious
FF7 has not aged well. And while FF9 is a classic and a great game compared to tge modern era of all gaming, it is not a glaring ommission by any stretch. Have FF10 but never played.
Yeah, not including Shenmue or Shenmue II is pretty weird. Both games are still so incredible.
It's a pretty good list and Witcher is right where it should be maybe even higher than it should but Destiny is in a good place as is GTAV and Red Dead.Destiny above Witcher
GTAV above Red Dead
GTAV at number 3
What the fuck even is this list
Ctrl+F "Portal 2"
Nowt.
Last of us and bloodborne in top 5? Umm.....
RDR should be higher than gta5. And Witcher 3 is too low