It all makes perfect sense until you get to the end of the game I think, anyway.
Huge ending spoilers:What I don't get is, shouldn't Noel have known letting Caius die would cause that to happen? Why didn't he take the power of the guardian instead? Also, Lightning would never "admit defeat" as the datalog says, and enter a self-induced crystal sleep... that part is just BS. She says right before this all happens in New Bodhum 700 AF "I will never stop fighting" and the game just expects me to believe she gave up? Thirdly, is there some other way to kill the goddess, or was it Caius's plan all along to be killed by Noel? Would Caius have never succeeded if Noel and Serah did nothing?
Questions for the first piece of story DLC? As for Lightning, I think either Etro did it for some reason or Lightning got defeated rather than give up. In any case, I am positive, the first piece of Lightning story DLC, will clear that up.
Caius wanted Noel to kill him but Noel refused so Caius did it himself using Noel. In the end, Caius is the cause of it rather than Noel. Well, at least that is what I gathered
Caius might have done the Cocoon thing regardless as shown in the Oracle drive but that may have just been a back-up plan had Caius not gotten Noel to kill him/had Noel been defeated before hand
What I really want to know though is where is Snow? How did Sazh and his son get to the future? and how will Lightning fix all this... if she can in this next piece of story DLC? And if she does and the paradoxes are fixed, will Noels future cease to be meaning he will also cease to be and will Serah be revived?
The story made sense, at the end, it just left you with asking questions which is meant to make you want the story DLC to see if it answers those questions.
Caius wanted Noel to kill him but Noel refused so Caius did it himself using Noel. In the end, Caius is the cause of it rather than Noel. Well, at least that is what I gathered
Caius might have done the Cocoon thing regardless as shown in the Oracle drive but that may have just been a back-up plan had Caius not gotten Noel to kill him/had Noel been defeated before hand
What I really want to know though is where is Snow? How did Sazh and his son get to the future? and how will Lightning fix all this... if she can in this next piece of story DLC? And if she does and the paradoxes are fixed, will Noels future cease to be meaning he will also cease to be and will Serah be revived?
The story made sense, at the end, it just left you with asking questions which is meant to make you want the story DLC to see if it answers those questions.
Lots of spoilers talking about the ending... lovely.
Noel didn't inherit the power because he had a strong will. If he hadn't had one he would have inherited the power as seen in one of the paradox endings, or so one of the fragments says. And it was Caius's plan all along going by the secret ending.
I guess that paradox ending is Cauis versus Noel on his own? Not gotten that one yet and won't til the weekend probably. Same with the secret ending so my stuff above was based on the normal ending itself