For these last few weeks i have been playing the heck out of this, leveling first my conjurer, then my arcanist, so i could unlock the white mage job.
Here are some of my impressions from the game so far:
Ill start with the cons
1. Solo, solo... solo questing you go from zone to zone. It's a single player FF game until you decide to go into the duty finder.
2. Map/zone design, it lacks exploration, too constricting and is nothing more than go to quest hub A do quests, that lead to a second quest hub and then your done, nothing more to see until you proceed to the next zone.
3. Fates, i know this is supposed to be group content, an interesting way to keep players engaged, but these fates are extremely uninspired and lack tiered progression. When in GW2's events you could progress through multiple stages of an event, here its just the single one, and rinse repeat.
4. Lack of voice overs, coming from other mmo's with great voice overs, its very jarring to have to read everything again in FFXIV, it's a shame because some of the writing fits right into the universe, but the cheesy animations and the constant text bubbles make me skip through most of it.
Pros
1. Class system, this is how you should do a well balanced and intuitive system with complexity at key points. The Secret world system is nice and all, but overly deep for new players for example.
2. Graphics, this game looks and runs beautifully, its incredibly optimized and has perfect art direction and aesthetics in line with the series. (i'm running this almost maxed, except for shadows on a 3 year old rig).
3. Duty finder, awesome tool, very fast, very intuitive, all kinds of content available and unlocked as you go. For me its the current gold standard for any mmo who wants to implement and "dungeon finder".
4. Traditional mmo combat, i have to say i'm not a big fan of the current trend, the latest being ESO. I love playing a healer, tab targeting, choosing unit frames, selecting skills from hotbars... FFXIV enables this to perfection.
5. Newb friendly, the community, the game systems, the help system, everything is geared to making the game as smooth as an experience as possible for new players. Its perfect that way for anyone wanting to try out an mmo.
6. Population, the game is teaming with players and guilds (Free companies) recruiting, so your in for a good time if you enjoy that.