Unknown Soldier said:
Um, yes. The only people who still want an AH are the people who quit during launch month and haven't played since. Nobody who has actually been playing the game wants an AH.
Uh, speak for yourself, please.
I still play (casually) and while I loved to sell most of my loot in FF XI on the AH, knowing exactly what's worth selling and for how much by just checking the history, I just can't be bothered to sell anything regularly in FF XIV at all. As a casual player, it's just no fun at all, while I really enjoyed it in FF XI.
Eight reasons (first five are (in)directly the cause of having no AH):
- Selling history of every item available.
- Ease of use (both buying and selling) still isn't the same and I don't see any advantages as to why.
- Having one retainer while as a seller of all kinds of loot (not a crafter), I would kinda have to have one for each ward to optimally sell my goods (lower tax)
- Crashing wards (yes, may have been fixed now, but took long enough). Especially for a casual player, I just want to sell my loot every couple of days and coming back seeing nothing sold because the wards crashed AGAIN is frustrating. Putting the items up again, coming back and the wards crashed AGAIN? Nice...
- Now and then enjoying the small surprise that an Item that I put up on the AH for like 10000 sold for like double that, because some guy doesn't care about the price, expected it to be more expensive, was in a hurry, or whatever. I just like that part of auctions.
Other reasons why I sell less in FF XIV than I did in FF XI:
- Items have to be 100 % repaired to sell again... Never understood that and as a casual player that won't level each and every craft, without being able to go to an NPC to repair it 100 %, I just sell most old gear at NPCs...
- Still there are so many +1 / +2 / +3 items, WTF, weren't they going to phase those out? I sell most +1 / +2 / +3 items at an NPC, because they're hardly worth more and I always got way more regular ones.
- Being able to equip everything makes lower gear worth less.
Edit: oh, and you know what actually is the worst part of this all? Implementing these retainers from scratch and going through all of the changes that they've put in since launch must have cost much, much more time and effort than a simple AH, which is just a simple interface with lists of items on sale. Man, if you think of the time and resources they could have saved by just improving on the FF XI AH and call it a day... They could have used those resources elsewhere.