Well, I'm not talking about how the list is created. That doesnt actually matter much. Like I said, Im talking about how to best view and interpret their list. If you just use it to see how units within a class compare with one another, I cant find a lot to disagree with. If you want to compare units across function (e.g., compare how Ike is an S+ and Rein is a S), it doesnt really work, and no tier list could possibly work in this regard, because units can and do serve completely different needs and have different roles. Like, if you need a mage, Effies S+ rating isnt going to mean that you include Effie over a Julia. But you would use an Effie over a Donnel.
Also not sure what you disagree with w/r/t Rein. I didnt say he doesnt perform well; I just said that, to get maximum benefit out of him, you need to use a specific team composition and that limits his flexibility when it comes to team comp (assuming you want to maximize his effectiveness). Unless you disagree that he needs a specific team comp in order to reach peak performance ? I think we can all agree that, while Rein is very strong on his own, he is even stronger on a horse team. And Nino is strongest on a buff team. Etc etc. Units like Nowi dont need much of anything w/r/t teammates in order to dominate, and I think that has value.
