Well, he said he transcribed this information, right? I would need to see if Gilly is reading the new copy or the old rotten copy, if it's the latter than Gilly discovered it and if it's the former, it was Sam.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Game of Thrones *NO BOOK DISCUSSION* |OT2| Season 7 - [Read the OP]
- Thread starter Cornballer
- Start date
Well, he said he transcribed this information, right? I would need to see if Gilly is reading the new copy or the old rotten copy, if it's the latter than Gilly discovered it and if it's the former, it was Sam.
broncobuster
Banned
I blame Robert for everything.
Gendry better take after his mother or uncles. Well, maybe not Stannis.
Gendry better take after his mother or uncles. Well, maybe not Stannis.
Everyone needs to be the Hound. Look what it did for Arya.
Dreadnought
Member
The hell mate pay attention?
He's gonna take a good portion of the Lannister army, kinda like when Yara and Theon defied their king.
ComputerBlue
Member
I kind of do, and intentionally putting her hand on her belly when she was talking to Tyrion seemed like she wanted him to think that, and not the oops, you caught me reaction she had afterwards...
TFW they don't trust the best damn team on the show and you show them what's what:
TFW when you aren't just going to sit there and take some truly garbage-ass writing. Because that's what Winterfell has been the entire season.
I'm not suggesting we ban anyone for spoiler thought crimes or even attempt to enforce shit like that. But an idea for next season might be to have an active leak discussion thread so folks can mostly get it out of their system instead of posting their "theories" in the no book thread.
https://asha47110.deviantart.com/art/Of-Kings-and-Queens-GoT-701148013
D&D is so lucky that their chemistry is so good together, this whole thing could have been less convincing if their love didn't feel real.
D&D is so lucky that their chemistry is so good together, this whole thing could have been less convincing if their love didn't feel real.
Dusktildawn48
Member
Yeah that's why I asked but in a statement sort of way. Was just double checking.
A better approach would have been not to embark on that story in the first place.
Their approach is insanely unimaginative.
RustyNails
Member
Only thing I did not like about Littlefinger's death was the Knights of the Vale person just...abandoning him? Just the word of Starks is enough to kill somebody? The Knights went into battle because LF is their...king/ruler/whatever. That was somewhat dumb. Littlefinger deserved a trial.
Darryl M R
Member
How are people viewing Ned's honor?
His friend started a war over a lie and when Ned learned the truth he did nothing to restore balance to the realm. Robert sat on a throne of lies while Ned hid away in the North with the true king of Westeros being treated poorly by his wife.
His friend started a war over a lie and when Ned learned the truth he did nothing to restore balance to the realm. Robert sat on a throne of lies while Ned hid away in the North with the true king of Westeros being treated poorly by his wife.
They had a couple weeks in the wagon together before reaching Winterfell, not surprised it came up again in that time.
https://asha47110.deviantart.com/art/Of-Kings-and-Queens-GoT-701148013
D&D is so lucky that their chemistry is so good together, this whole thing could have been less convincing if their love didn't feel real.
Yeah they got great chemistry.
ComputerBlue
Member
The only reason LF hadn't been killed yet is because Sansa testifying on his behalf. He also outright threatened the Vale dude last season.
Winterblink
Member
Just another day in Westeros, really
Conkerkid11
Member
Oh shit, everybody thought Kingslayer meant Jaime was gonna kill Cersei. What if it means he's gonna kill the Night King?
darkwing-buck
Member
Jon FUCKS.
Eh, I'm still not completely sold on it but oh well.
SurrenderDorothy
Banned
Littlefinger deserved to die like the weasel he was.
Good riddance.
He made a promise to his sister to keep him secret and that's what he did.
His honour's intact.
Good riddance.
He made a promise to his sister to keep him secret and that's what he did.
His honour's intact.
The Vale has been pro stark going back to the rebellion days with the jon arryn, robert, and ned alliance. They wanted to kill littlefinger before Sansa cried on his behalf. I don't think they give a shit about littlefinger and are happy he is gone
They gave him his courtesy scene, he's done.
Jaime should swap his golden hand for a dragon glass blade, just go around chopping with valeryian steel in one hand and dragon glass in the other.
Presumably they were informed of the depth of his betrayal, that he killed Lysa and tried to poison her son (where is he?).
OG_Original Gamer
Member
I think it's his love for Dany and his jealousy, that will grow towards the heir, that will see him betray Dany.
SenjutsuSage
Banned
Tallshortman
Member
The littlefinger scene was fantastic. Probably the highlight of the episode for me.
SolidChamp
Banned
I'm not reading shit here. Someone just tell me:
Good episode?
Good episode?
Ned learned the truth after the war was pretty much over. Rhaegar was dead and nothing, not even Ned was going to convince Robert that he hadn't kidnapped and raped her. If he had spoke up, Jon would be as dead as the Martell children.
He didn't like LIttlefinger, he knew LF was manipulating Robin into doing whatever he wanted.
What was Ned supposed to do?
He admitted to the murders of the two that came before him. Kind of. I figure they let it happen at that point.
Netherscourge
Banned
Total cringe-worthy hypothetical here:
--Jon is Daenerys' Nephew.
--Jon is Sansa's Cousin.
What's higher-rated on the Incest Scale? Marrying your cousin or marrying your aunt?
And for giggles, which one do you marry and which one do you kill - taking into consideration political alliances.
--Jon is Daenerys' Nephew.
--Jon is Sansa's Cousin.
What's higher-rated on the Incest Scale? Marrying your cousin or marrying your aunt?
And for giggles, which one do you marry and which one do you kill - taking into consideration political alliances.
The war started when Aerys killed Ned's brother and father. Lyanna was kinda like Catelyn taking Tyrion. It's an event that happened up to the start of the war with Ned being executed being what caused the war.
We are on the Internet, we have access to the entire knowledge of humanity. It doesn't prevent us to assume stuff we were told as children or stuff that we incorrectly deduced through flawed logic. And we're posting these assumptions and deductions on a forum and debating them because we know we're right, without fact-checking.
Bran grew up with the kidnapping and rape story. He went to see wtf happened at that tower, I think because he wanted to see the big fight he was told about. It made him find out about Jon, but Jon being who he is doesn't invalidate the kidnapping and rape story in any way, just that not everybody died then.
darkwing-buck
Member
It's pretty good. My expectations were pretty low from episode 6 but this was fine.
Harrison Bergeron
Member
It was a scumbag move, but Rhaegar and Lyanna's circumstances were caused by an established order. I took it as Rhaegar and Lyanna defying that order, and maybe Rhaegar was planning to usurp his own father (who everyone hated and was tearing the Kingdom apart). They were in love and naively wanted to change things.
It's also kind of like what Dany is doing now in "breaking the wheel."
broncobuster
Banned
Robert would've killed Aegon-Jon. Ned learned the truth after the trident. There was too much momentum for Ned to do much else besides protect his nephew.
His execution served to highlight the fact that Littlefinger had zero actual friends. He was never loved, only tolerated out of necessity.
ComputerBlue
Member
Actually, that's a good point you bring up.
Shouldn't Sansa be held accountable for conspiring with LF after he killed her?
OG_Original Gamer
Member
Totally agree, they had no love for LF.
As with seemingly every episode this season, it literally depends on the person you ask. Some loved it, some were okay or lukewarm, and others hated it.
DangerMouse
Member
Haha!
Aunt is a generation closer. Also with the Targaryan incest past, they are closer to siblings genetically.