Support NeoGAF

[Tiago Rodrigues]

No game is perfect, even all time classics like Ocarina of time, Baldur's Gate or Final Fantasy VII - all had some problems (like 15fps on Zelda, hahaha). Elden Ring has major technical issues, yet it got many 10/10 scores. Claire Obscur runs MUCH better than that, it mostly has some graphical issues like you said.

I think no game in the last ten years deserve 10/10 but E33 and TW3 are very close.

Off topic but i don't know how we played all that back then, we were much happier and had more fun. Can we go back?

Sometimes i don't know if Digital Foundry ruined me or not.

 

[Lokaum D+]

No game is perfect, even all time classics like Ocarina of time, Baldur's Gate or Final Fantasy VII - all had some problems (like 15fps on Zelda, hahaha). Elden Ring has major technical issues, yet it got many 10/10 scores. Claire Obscur runs MUCH better than that, it mostly has some graphical issues like you said.

I think no game in the last ten years deserve 10/10 but E33 and TW3 are very close.

i dont think 10/10 games means perfect of flawless games, imo a 10/10 game just means that it must be played, that said, i dont think GoY is a 10/10 game for the simple reason that has no Jin on it.

 

[Markio128]

Off topic but i don't know how we played all that back then, we were much happier and had more fun. Can we go back?

Sometimes i don't know if Digital Foundry ruined me or not.

I don't get hung up too much about review scores. However, I do think having an aggregate score based on different components of a game would make things much easier to understand. Most magazines back in the day used to average the score after considering visuals, sound, music, gameplay, value for money, etc.,

If I was to give a game a 9+, it would simply come down to whether I'd play the game again after finishing it. Games like The Witcher 3, Cyberpunk, are recent examples, even if they have their flaws.

I'd have to give GOT a 9 because I completed it twice and platinumed the game. I only have 11 platinums in total. Hence why I'm excited for GOY.

BOTW is an easy 10 for me.
Elden Ring is another.
GT7 as well.

I don't think I'd play Expedition 33 again, so for me, that'd be an 8. It's a top-tier one and done for me.

 

[GymWolf]

Only a japanese male can achieve true perfection. That is why Senzo Tanaka did not want to train Frank Dux at first.

Tanaka's son was getting bullied by average teens, dude cried with one eye when he died

 

[Danny22]

And you and others have some weird attachment to downplay this game?

Reviews come out and majority are positive if not glowing about the game, but..... no, no, no, you cant trust reviewers
Game looks like last gen....... gets praise from DF and others, but...... no, no, no, here's some cherry picked screenshots to try and prove otherwise
I could go on with the goalpost moving, but whats the point

Are you even interested in buying it? genuinely curious

I mean I like it but its just another more content dlc-ish type sequel that Sony has been making, It's strange people keep glossing over that

 

[Tiago Rodrigues]

I mean I like it but its just another more content dlc-ish type sequel that Sony has been making, It's strange people keep glossing over that

The DLC:

 

[Lokaum D+]

Since i m banned from the OT for being an annoying anti woke bastard i ll let my initial impressions here.

Amazing presentation and the opening act its just chef kiss, the lethal difficult is so good that it make the combat tense as a real sword fight should be, If you make a mistake you are cooked.

Japanese dub is great but its seens to have the same lip sync problem from Tsushima.

Graphics are great and what Sony did on this game marketing should be considered a crime and for the ppl saying that this is Tsushima DLC its not, its way more beautiful and i m eating crow right now ( again i blame Sony )

Also, Atsu Kaasan is beautiful af.

Atm this game feels Kill Bill on every corner and Atsu is better than i imagined , waaaaaay better ( i blame Sony again )

And just one more time, what Sony did on the marketing of this game should be considered a crime.

 

[Sacred]

I played several hours of this game now, this game is nowhere near an 87. The combat is very overrated, alot of button spamming, the mini games are awful, world feels empty, and the dialogue is absolutely terrible. It is a beautiful game, but very shallow and not well polished.