• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Has the PS5 already cemented itself as the worst Playstation generation in history?

What's Sony's worst generation?

  • Playstation

    Votes: 13 1.6%
  • Playstation 2

    Votes: 8 1.0%
  • Playstation 3

    Votes: 210 25.6%
  • Playstation 4

    Votes: 23 2.8%
  • Playstation 5

    Votes: 565 69.0%

  • Total voters
    819

Three

Member
pn9vevo3tmm61.png


John Candy Reaction GIF


*This is a list of Sony Published games ( exclusives at the time ) for PS3, not all games are first party studios.
You try and list every yearly MLB game today, a million Singstars or remakes in the same way and you'd be told those don't count. This was beyond the entire gen too, the sports titles that were releasing when the next gen PS4 was already out are listed up to 2015. You're going to have a big list like this when the PS5 has a decade too of published games.
 

Danny Dudekisser

I paid good money for this Dynex!
How? It’s just a better ps5

$700 for a marginally stronger piece of hardware, instantly torpedoed by PSSR. Software solutions to weak hardware problems like this are becoming an absolute blight, and that's assuming they actually work right (which PSSR frequently doesn't). Plus the fan noise is terrible if you lose the fan lottery, and the build quality is worse than the original.
 
Last edited:

James Sawyer Ford

Gold Member
$700 for a marginally stronger piece of hardware, instantly torpedoed by PSSR. Software solutions to weak hardware problems like this are becoming an absolute blight, and that's assuming they actually work right (which PSSR frequently doesn't).

PSSR looks great in most games, all games look better on PS5 Pro, some are transformational and it’s still early days

being $250 more expensive than the base unit doesn’t make it bad hardware
 

Danny Dudekisser

I paid good money for this Dynex!
PSSR looks great in most games, all games look better on PS5 Pro, some are transformational and it’s still early days

being $250 more expensive than the base unit doesn’t make it bad hardware

It does when the tech often doesn't work properly and what you're paying for is more of a software solution than a hardware one. If I'm shelling out that kind of extra money, I need to be getting steak, not steak sauce. "Early days" cannot be an excuse for it. Games are getting patched to remove that core feature of the system in some cases. That's absurd.
 
Last edited:
The only real options are PS3 and PS5 and I'd say maybe so far yes PS5 is the worst but I don't think it will end up that way. I think it'll be PS3 then PS5. It'll depend on what comes out over the next couple years or however long this generation is going to be. I'm honestly hoping PS5 gets Fable and if that happens I don't think I'd end up calling it the worst along with everything yet to release.

PS3 I think had Uncharted, Infamous, Journey, Demon's Souls...PS5 hasn't had anything on that level yet imo. Astro Bot is better than LittleBigPlanet though.
 
Last edited:

James Sawyer Ford

Gold Member
It does when the tech often doesn't work properly and what you're paying for is more of a software solution than a hardware one. "Early days" cannot be an excuse for it. Games are getting patched to remove that core feature of the system in some cases. That's absurd.

The tech works properly, and if it doesn’t, that’s a third party issue with individual teams
 

Lokaum D+

Member
PSSR looks great in most games, all games look better on PS5 Pro, some are transformational and it’s still early days

being $250 more expensive than the base unit doesn’t make it bad hardware
it looks so great that they rolled back to TSR in SH2 Remake, but what i m saying, no one has more than one console and PSSR is better than DLSS.

 
Last edited:

Danny Dudekisser

I paid good money for this Dynex!
That’s a developer issue, not quality checking their own product and using the latest PSSR versions

The point is that if it's a better system, I should be getting better performance across the board. I'm not, even if some games perform very well. But what I never thought I'd see from an *upgrade* is worse performance in some games, but that's what happens when you rely on software gimmickry instead of actual raw horsepower. Which is why I have such an issue with the laughable price tag.
 

James Sawyer Ford

Gold Member
The point is that if it's a better system, I should be getting better performance across the board. I'm not, even if some games perform very well. But what I never thought I'd see from an *upgrade* is worse performance in some games, but that's what happens when you rely on software gimmickry instead of actual raw horsepower. Which is why I have such an issue with the laughable price tag.

You are. SH2 performs better then it does on PS5
 

EruditeHobo

Member
imo ppl who buy Playstation are primary interested on exclusives...

This is wrong... the focus on "exclusivity" here remains way, way overblown. It's a relic of the past, it's far less relevant than it's ever been to console gaming.

Ecosystem is the new exclusive. That's why so many people (perhaps not rabid hobbyists, like on this board) are buying and happy with their PS5s. And it's why PS3 is getting the votes it does on this poll. PS5 ecosystem is very impressive, and offers pretty good value.
 

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
Why would I care how many units the PS3 sold vs the PS5?

I care about how much enjoyment and value the generation has brought me, not how much money a massive corporation made off of it.
You like Playstation games. They like Playstation Sales Figures.

Remember Bo_Hazam? He literally didnt care about the games. He said he only cared about the Sony brand. That's what you are seeing here.

The PS3 era is where Sony first party truly came alive. Before the PS3 era, they had just Jak and Daxter, Ratchet, Twisted Metal, a couple of Team Ico games and GOW. The rest were all third party moneyhats that went away as soon as Playstation stumbled. It was then when Sony started investing in studios cultivating them with new IPs like Motorstorm, Warhawk, Uncharted, Infamous, Resistance, TLOU, and yes, KZ2. A game that got a sequel even though the first one bombed, both commercially and critically. But they stuck with it and it literally saved the PS3 from all the bad press E3 2005 and the Cell had generated. It showed people that the cell was indeed a beast and Sony wasn't going to go down without a fight.

But it sold only 250k units in the first month while Halo and Gears were selling 3 and 2 million respectively. So sales fans dismissed games like Infamous and KZ2.
 

Zacfoldor

Member
It does when the tech often doesn't work properly and what you're paying for is more of a software solution than a hardware one. If I'm shelling out that kind of extra money, I need to be getting steak, not steak sauce. "Early days" cannot be an excuse for it. Games are getting patched to remove that core feature of the system in some cases. That's absurd.

Im Not Maya Rudolph GIF by Saturday Night Live


Honestly if you don't consider the money it's a big upgrade. You would take it for free. Guaranteed.

Would you not take it for free? Wanna argue that?

If you would take it for free, all we are arguing about is the price.

The relatively minor price difference of a couple hundred dollars is completely irrelevant on a device you will play for years and years unless money is a huge factor. For those that 200 dollars makes a big difference, how are they buying vanilla PS5 and the 70 dollar games? I do feel for anyone who is not able to afford. But for the grace of God go I. However, it doesn't make sense that everyone complaining about is due to lack of money, but rather hatred of Sony for a myriad of reasons or just a general hatred of everything good. Because the PS5 Pro is good, my brother. It's very good, and in this case I will keep believing my lying eyes.
 
Last edited:

Danny Dudekisser

I paid good money for this Dynex!
Im Not Maya Rudolph GIF by Saturday Night Live


Honestly if you don't consider the money it's a big upgrade. You would take it for free. Guaranteed.

Would you not take it for free? Wanna argue that?

If you would take it for free, all we are arguing about is the price.

The relatively minor price difference of a couple hundred dollars is completely irrelevant on a device you will play for years and years unless money is a huge factor. For those that 200 dollars makes a big difference, how are they buying vanilla PS5 and the 70 dollar games? I do feel for anyone who is not able to afford. But for the grace of God go I. However, it doesn't make sense that everyone complaining about is due to lack of money, but rather hatred of Sony for a myriad of reasons or just a general hatred of everything good. Because the PS5 Pro is good, my brother. It's very good, and in this case I will keep believing my lying eyes.

I genuinely would not for many games.

I don't actually care about the money, it's the principle.
 
Last edited:

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
For me personally PS5 is their worst gen by far for first party games that really interest me

Opinions, but I enjoyed Sony first party a heck of a lot more with PS3 than PS5. Not even close really. For me, that's the defining aspect of a PlayStation console as it is the primary reason I ever buy a PlayStation.

The elder statesmen of GAF have spoken.

star-wars-bail-organa.gif
 
You like Playstation games. They like Playstation Sales Figures.

Remember Bo_Hazam? He literally didnt care about the games. He said he only cared about the Sony brand. That's what you are seeing here.

The PS3 era is where Sony first party truly came alive. Before the PS3 era, they had just Jak and Daxter, Ratchet, Twisted Metal, a couple of Team Ico games and GOW. The rest were all third party moneyhats that went away as soon as Playstation stumbled. It was then when Sony started investing in studios cultivating them with new IPs like Motorstorm, Warhawk, Uncharted, Infamous, Resistance, TLOU, and yes, KZ2. A game that got a sequel even though the first one bombed, both commercially and critically. But they stuck with it and it literally saved the PS3 from all the bad press E3 2005 and the Cell had generated. It showed people that the cell was indeed a beast and Sony wasn't going to go down without a fight.

But it sold only 250k units in the first month while Halo and Gears were selling 3 and 2 million respectively. So sales fans dismissed games like Infamous and KZ2.
They had some good and decent stuff coming from Europe as well. Ghosthunter, Getaway games, Primal... the titles you mentioned might've had the most spotlight and media attention, but don't neglect the other regions' output as well. Sony's release stream had a lot of variety back then. The Sony of today is almost unrecognizable on that part.

Btw, the factoid that the original Killzone wasn't a super hit makes it the more ironic how Hulst gets to call the shots on what gets a sequel and what doesn't.
 
Last edited:

Three

Member
Not sure what you're laughing at Bojji Bojji

hannibal-buress.gif

Look below
Yep, that was PS3. So much new IP and great games. Opposite of the PS5.

Yep. This is why the PS3 is getting votes. Ignore the amazing library and wealth of new IP, it almost got outsold by Xbox! It’s trash!

Meanwhile him 3-4 years after PS3 release, read the bolded:

If its a multiplatform game I will almost always buy the 360 version simply because they are usually better plus all my online/real life friends game on the 360. And Live.
So that really only leaves exclusives for PS3 and I am in the minority I guess of not being too impressed with what PS3 has to offer in that regard.
But yes "amazing library and wealth of new IP" that he completely ignored at the time.
 
Last edited:

Kokoro2020

Member
The people who say Ps3 are insane. We had The Last of Us, Demons Souls, God of War 3, Metal Gear Solid 4, Resistance Fall of Man, Uncharted 3 and 2, Heavy Rain, Infamous 1/2, Sly 4, Little Big Planet 1/2, a few a Ratchet and Clanks just to name a few.

Ps5 has Returnal and Astro. Spidey 2, Horizon 2, Ragnorok...

Id love an age test for those whos prefer psv over ps3.
The PS3 was a really good console. But when you compare it to the rest, it just falls slightly short, IMO. Just because people say it's the "worst" doesn't necessarily mean they are saying it's bad.

As for the Vita, I've never played it. I do have a PSP though, which was also an underrated console.
 

HeisenbergFX4

Gold Member
We could also measure it by how many old boomers are yelling at clouds instead
Who is yelling at anything?

I thought this thread was an opinion piece on which generation we thought was the worst and it delved into "but yeah the PS5 earned so much more money thus it has to be better"

Maybe the old boomers are just straight up smarter and have made it this long on Earth for a reason :)
 

PeteBull

Member
Only redeeming quality of this gen's playstation is- 0 competition, nintendo is literally 5 years late to the party and even then their hardware is roughly on the lvl of 12yo ps4, microsoft trying their best to cosplay as undertaker to take their console business to the grave, prices for mid and high lvls of pc gpus skyrocketed to hell and back.
If u put ps5/ps5pr0 vs any previous gens playstations, including ps3, with its line up and amount high quality true exclusive games, it would flop hard :p
 
Last edited:

StreetsofBeige

Gold Member
You like Playstation games. They like Playstation Sales Figures.

Remember Bo_Hazam? He literally didnt care about the games. He said he only cared about the Sony brand. That's what you are seeing here.

The PS3 era is where Sony first party truly came alive. Before the PS3 era, they had just Jak and Daxter, Ratchet, Twisted Metal, a couple of Team Ico games and GOW. The rest were all third party moneyhats that went away as soon as Playstation stumbled. It was then when Sony started investing in studios cultivating them with new IPs like Motorstorm, Warhawk, Uncharted, Infamous, Resistance, TLOU, and yes, KZ2. A game that got a sequel even though the first one bombed, both commercially and critically. But they stuck with it and it literally saved the PS3 from all the bad press E3 2005 and the Cell had generated. It showed people that the cell was indeed a beast and Sony wasn't going to go down without a fight.

But it sold only 250k units in the first month while Halo and Gears were selling 3 and 2 million respectively. So sales fans dismissed games like Infamous and KZ2.
Oh ya. Bo was the biggest Sony pimp on this board. I remember him pasting pics telling everyone his Sony TV and AV equipment. If Sony makes electric can openers and doorbells, he’d probably have those too. Lol
 
Last edited:
But yes "amazing library and wealth of new IP" that he completely ignored at the time.

Cracking Up Lol GIF by HULU


You’re trying for some gotcha but you didn’t bother to check the context of the thread you’re quoting, it’s specifically about multiplayer shooters. You might not know this, but some of the best PS3 exclusives were in fact NOT multiplayer shooters. Motorstorm, Last of Us (amazing SP, even better MP), Uncharted, infamous, GoW3, Twisted Metal, etc).

Adorable.
 

rofif

Can’t Git Gud
Well no way in fucking hell ever ps3 is worse than ps5.
Ps3 is legendary. I would take it over ps1 and ps3. Especially the nice fat ps3.
Funny because I never had one but I remember that generation very fondly with my 360
 

Three

Member
You might not know this, but some of the best PS3 exclusives were in fact NOT multiplayer shooters. Motorstorm, Last of Us (amazing SP, even better MP), Uncharted, infamous, GoW3, Twisted Metal, etc).

Adorable.
Good try, I would have believed you if you weren't constantly shitting on said games at the time.
I played through DI because the combat was awesome and the game was generally fun to play.

I suffered through GoW3's dull, repetitive combat and terrible story just to QTE my way through the next awesome boss fight.
Both games bored me to tears. Infamous a lot quicker than Prototype.

Crackdown 2 can't come soon enough.
I agree with this.
 
Last edited:

Mibu no ookami

Demoted Member® Pro™
Not sure what you're laughing at Bojji Bojji

hannibal-buress.gif

Look below




Meanwhile him 3-4 years after PS3 release, read the bolded:


But yes "amazing library and wealth of new IP" that he completely ignored at the time.

Cold-blooded...

But this is reality of revisionist history. No time will ever be worse than now except for the future, which will always be worse as it relates to making an argument against something you don't like

Good try, I would have believed you if you weren't constantly shitting on said games at the time.

Dude, you're actually on fire right now...

Meme Reaction GIF by MOODMAN
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom