• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

"Hello Again" Apple holding mac-centric media event October 27th 10am PST

Status
Not open for further replies.
Concerns over energy consumption are much less of a concern on iMacs that use desktop processors already.

Thats always been my line of thinking. I'm just gonna sit here and hope that Apple also see the sense in that for their next iMacs. I have a 2008 Mac Pro that has served me admirably all these years, but needs to be replaced.
 

Dabanton

Member
I have the worst luck with buying Apple devices.

Bought the 3rd gen iPad. Processor sucked and wasn't powerful enough to run the retina display and thus was replaced by the newer model in less than a year.

This one still stings. Didn't even give us a year, it was a few months later the bastards haha.

I usually jump in at about 4th generation and above. That's when I find their products are usually at their best.

My 4th gen iPod touch is still going strong, but I recently replaced it with the 6th gen one as most apps were no longer really supported on the older products.
 

borghe

Loves the Greater Toronto Area
if you are programming anything that relies on opengl or direct x mac is pretty crap if not unusable.

fuck. sorry, I don't do game development (not does anyone I know)

touche :p

meant outside of game development. 100% my bad.

Ok I need to try the photos app again then.

But the whole setup is still bad. Like my two choices to upload photos from my iPhone right now are use Image Capture or use the Photos app to transfer photos. It would be a lot simpler if I used Finder and drag and drop. I feel like Apple want too much control over the photos transferring process. If I want to transfer photos from my computer to the iPhone they need to be in the Photos app, and then use iTunes. That's just convoluted.

yes it defaults (aka doesn't present an option) to your system drive. Go to preferences, create a new library on an external drive, and make that your primary library.

as for getting photos on there.. two things. First, use iCloud Photo Library... for me this has been a nearly transcendent experience. I never worry about photo storage and availability EVER anymore. When they added RAW I just about died. Worst case scenario is you drop $3/month ($36 per year) for the 200GB iCloud option. To have your photos EVERYFRIGGINWHERE.

If you are bringing them in from a camera.. Photos honestly does a good enough job for that. It brings them in, leaves them alone, and automatically sends them up to iCPL making them instantly available on all other devices.

Yes this all requires you to invest 100% into Apple's photo solution... but with Photos in OS X 11, iCloud Photo Library and now the facial and scene recognition in iOS 10 and macOS 12, IMHO apple's photo solution is FINALLY comparable to Google's with virtually no downsides (aside from not easily accessible from Android devices)
 

xk0sm0sx

Member
I have a question.

Who is Apple's intended audience for this Macbook Pro? Because it seems like everything was designed to be frustrating for a professional, and intended for casual use. It looks like a toy.

If I'm buying it to do professional work, I wouldn't care about the machine being super thin, I would want the power and tools on hand to do my job efficiently. Yet this seems completely the opposite.

Are there even any professionals considering to adopt this machine?
 

borghe

Loves the Greater Toronto Area
I have a question.

Who is Apple's intended audience for this Macbook Pro? Because it seems like everything was designed to be frustrating for a professional, and intended for casual use. It looks like a toy.

If I'm buying it to do professional work, I wouldn't care about the machine being super thin, I would want the power and tools on hand to do my job efficiently. Yet this seems completely the opposite.

Are there even any professionals considering to adopt this machine?

this has been a really miscommunicated point.

the only thing "casual" about these MBPs is the toolbar, which most professionals' reactions to have been "huh?". The actual specs and build quality of the devices are absolutely in line with a top end professional notebook.

basically this is the same profession level notebook the MBP has always been, with the toolbar thrown in to justify(?) the price hike (which isn't so much a hike as a realignment to the current professional tier of notebooks)
 

xk0sm0sx

Member
this has been a really miscommunicated point.

the only thing "casual" about these MBPs is the toolbar, which most professionals' reactions to have been "huh?". The actual specs and build quality of the devices are absolutely in line with a top end professional notebook.

basically this is the same profession level notebook the MBP has always been, with the toolbar thrown in to justify(?) the price hike (which isn't so much a hike as a realignment to the current professional tier of notebooks)

Actually I'm more referring to the discarding of function keys, and the lack of USB ports, and display port.
SD Card slot, I'll give it since they usually break after a few years.

A professional would certainly not mind a thicker macbook if it has the ports he needs.

(And I wouldn't be surprised if the headphone jack will be gone in a later iteration, which means good luck for musicians as well lol)
 

Macam

Banned
I have a question.

Who is Apple's intended audience for this Macbook Pro? Because it seems like everything was designed to be frustrating for a professional, and intended for casual use. It looks like a toy.

If I'm buying it to do professional work, I wouldn't care about the machine being super thin, I would want the power and tools on hand to do my job efficiently. Yet this seems completely the opposite.

Are there even any professionals considering to adopt this machine?

Already ordered, although I could see myself flipping it in 2-3 years, given its limitations (16GB RAM limit, un-upgradable SSD).

It'll be a vast improvement over my current workhorse, but probably without the longevity I want.
 

jstevenson

Sailor Stevenson
Actually I'm more referring to the discarding of function keys, and the lack of USB ports, and display port.
SD Card slot, I'll give it since they usually break after a few years.

A professional would certainly not mind a thicker macbook if it has the ports he needs.

(And I wouldn't be surprised if the headphone jack will be gone in a later iteration, which means good luck for musicians as well lol)

a professional doesn't care about adding a couple dongles to their workstation set-up, or having them in their travel bag. It's a minor minor cost. The 210 dollar image floating around here is to make fun of Apple, but either a corporation pays it and doesn't care, or you go buy cheaper third party stuff from a reputable source like Belkin or Amazon Basics.

Hell, I traveled with 2-3 different dongles for my macbook air for years.

It's not a big deal.
 
Just got a shipping confirmation email for the order with the Macbook Pro 13" Space Grey with the Touch Bar and AppleCare Plus but looking at the email I notice it seems to be specifying AppleCare Plus rather than the Macbook Pro. Is it normal to receive a shipping confirmation an email for the AC+ agreement for a Macbook, or is there actually a possibility I might get the laptop next week?

I got AC+ with an Apple Watch and didn't get a separate email for it so I'm not too sure what's going on here, because with an estimated deliver of 18th November it seems too good to be true.
 
a professional doesn't care about adding a couple dongles to their workstation set-up, or having them in their travel bag. It's a minor minor cost. The 210 dollar image floating around here is to make fun of Apple, but either a corporation pays it and doesn't care, or you go buy cheaper third party stuff from a reputable source like Belkin or Amazon Basics.

Hell, I traveled with 2-3 different dongles for my macbook air for years.

It's not a big deal.

It's like Late 2008 and 2012 again. Whenever Apple introduce a revision on their MacBooks, they always increase its cost over the previous generation.

The year after that, Apple releases another iteration with improved specs at lower cost.

It sucks being an early adopter, but I love using MacBooks.
 

xk0sm0sx

Member
Oh well, I just see it as counter-intuitive. Your laptop already has everything you need to do your work properly, but now Apple is adding hurdles to it.
 

digdug2k

Member
a professional doesn't care about adding a couple dongles to their workstation set-up, or having them in their travel bag. It's a minor minor cost. The 210 dollar image floating around here is to make fun of Apple, but either a corporation pays it and doesn't care, or you go buy cheaper third party stuff from a reputable source like Belkin or Amazon Basics.

Hell, I traveled with 2-3 different dongles for my macbook air for years.

It's not a big deal.
I fucking hate carrying around adapters and dongles for work. On trips I always wind up with lots extra because you've got no guarantee about what's going to be there when you get on-site for something (and I still someone didn't have the right one) For a long time every where I worked had magsafe's in every conference room which was great because I hate carrying around a magsafe too.

I did it. Life went on. I forgot the right one sometimes. Had a few mad rushes to BestBuy/Fry's to buy some. Its not the end of the world, but it is shitty. Don't act like its not.
 

icespide

Banned
USB-C was designed to be fairly future proof (at least the connector shape) yeah? is it fair to say it will be around for a while, maybe longer than USB-A?
 

Toki767

Member
USB-C was designed to be fairly future proof (at least the connector shape) yeah? is it fair to say it will be around for a while, maybe longer than USB-A?

It'll really take hold when Apple uses USB-C for the iPhone in 2 years.

Because they gotta give people a reason to upgrade from the one coming out next year I guess.
 

3N16MA

Banned
Looking at Canadian prices, the base 13 inch MBP with tool bar is pretty comparable to the Surface Book and Surface Pro 4 in terms of pricing. You're basically shelling out at least $1800 before tax.
 

Zaph

Member
USB-C was designed to be fairly future proof (at least the connector shape) yeah? is it fair to say it will be around for a while, maybe longer than USB-A?

No technology is ever really future proof, but yes, kinda. It has a feature called Alternate Mode which allows the device and host to sidestep the USB protocol and do their own thing over some of the wires (which is why USB-C can carry HDMI/Thunderbolt/DP etc). Of course, both the device and host has to support whichever Alternate Mode you want to use.

It really is a fantastic spec - can't wait for it to be more widely adopted.
 

icespide

Banned
It'll really take hold when Apple uses USB-C for the iPhone in 2 years.

Because they gotta give people a reason to upgrade from the one coming out next year I guess.

honestly I don't think they ever will switch to USB-C for iPhones. I think they'll go full wireless charging and remove the charging port alltogether
 

Interfectum

Member
I expect Apple would design it in a way that isn't awkward

ca7fcda8e367a3325721854a2e1f2d9c.jpg


Um4Ndum.png


I'm not so sure anymore.
 

entremet

Member
I do think this is all overblown, every hands on impression I've seen has said that the laptops feel and look fantastic

I think price and using last gen processors is the biggest issue here.

Have one of these and it would make more sense.

At the prices, they should have the current gen processors or be cheaper.
 

Randy5554

Member
I ended up going with a 2015 refurb. Seemed to be the best mix of price, performance, and portability for me. This will be my first Mac.

tQoUNzj.jpg
 
those design decisions have been discussed to death and I understand why people make fun of them, but practically they are non-issues, because the stuff charges fast enough

nothing is fast enough that warrants those design choices. what if i need to use my mouse, and its dead. i will be screwed until it charges
 

jstevenson

Sailor Stevenson
I fucking hate carrying around adapters and dongles for work. On trips I always wind up with lots extra because you've got no guarantee about what's going to be there when you get on-site for something (and I still someone didn't have the right one) For a long time every where I worked had magsafe's in every conference room which was great because I hate carrying around a magsafe too.

I did it. Life went on. I forgot the right one sometimes. Had a few mad rushes to BestBuy/Fry's to buy some. Its not the end of the world, but it is shitty. Don't act like its not.

I mean, my work bag has a zip pocket that had the three dongles I needed in air. I always carried power.

In my own office I never need to worry because the conference rooms are standardized and I'd put stuff on the network and not run it off my laptop.

I mean, I guess yes, it'd be nice not to carry dongles, but if you're in the business of needing to show things from your computer, you carry the necessary equipment. That was the price I paid for a thin / light laptop. Much prefer that over weight / bulk. To each their own though!
 

icespide

Banned
I mean, my work bag has a zip pocket that had the three dongles I needed in air. I always carried power.

In my own office I never need to worry because the conference rooms are standardized and I'd put stuff on the network and not run it off my laptop.

I mean, I guess yes, it'd be nice not to carry dongles, but if you're in the business of needing to show things from your computer, you carry the necessary equipment. That was the price I paid for a thin / light laptop. Much prefer that over weight / bulk. To each their own though!

I'll also add, video out has always been a cluster fuck on most laptops regardless of apple. throughout my career conference rooms would randomly have combos of VGA, DVI, HDMI, etc. Most laptops even non apple ones would need adapters for video stuff, unless it was some shitty laptop with a VGA port, and really who the fuck wants a VGA port?

for all other ports I will admit though, going Apple invites the possibility of dongle-city much more than other laptops
 

mrkgoo

Member
I'll also add, video out has always been a cluster fuck on most laptops regardless of apple. throughout my career conference rooms would randomly have combos of VGA, DVI, HDMI, etc. Most laptops even non apple ones would need adapters for video stuff, unless it was some shitty laptop with a VGA port, and really who the fuck wants a VGA port?

for all other ports I will admit though, going Apple invites the possibility of dongle-city much more than other laptops
my very first mac, a 12" PowerBook had a mini dvi. My next, a 15" mbp had a dvi, but largely I used to use a dvi to vga adaptor.

Now I have a 21" iMac and I have to use a thunderbolt to dvi adaptor fir my second screen.

At least to me, dongles for screens have always been present.
 

Guess Who

Banned
I think price and using last gen processors is the biggest issue here.

Have one of these and it would make more sense.

At the prices, they should have the current gen processors or be cheaper.

They are using current gen processors, except for the non Touch Bar 13" model. 28W/45W Kaby Lake isn't out yet, last I heard.
 

hateradio

The Most Dangerous Yes Man
It'll really take hold when Apple uses USB-C for the iPhone in 2 years.

Because they gotta give people a reason to upgrade from the one coming out next year I guess.
Ironically, I really like the Lightning plug because USB-C is a bit awkward to insert because of its round design.

It's easier to plug this in.

uoUb32x.jpg


Than this.

WBs7X58.png

Did the old models get a price cut?
No.
 
nothing is fast enough that warrants those design choices. what if i need to use my mouse, and its dead. i will be screwed until it charges

Regarding the pencil, it takes a minute or two to charge. And it comes with a dongle if you prefer to plug it in. It is a non-issue elevated to meme-like status.
 

mrklaw

MrArseFace
Regarding the pencil, it takes a minute or two to charge. And it comes with a dongle if you prefer to plug it in. It is a non-issue elevated to meme-like status.

Mouse is pretty annoying though. Charges fairly slowly for me and is unusable during that time. Don't have to do it very often but still annoying. Would much rather have the cable coming out of the front so I could use while charging.
 

The Real Abed

Perma-Junior
nothing is fast enough that warrants those design choices. what if i need to use my mouse, and its dead. i will be screwed until it charges
To be fair you'd be screwed for 15 seconds which would give you hours of usage, or a minute which would give you more, or 2 hours if you need to leave the house which would give you a month of usage. It's really a non-issue. Your mouse will never get that low because you'll know way ahead of time that it's going to die and can remedy it by leaving it plugged in over night or when you go out somewhere.

Not that I'm defending it of course. It looks really stupid that way and could have been remedied by putting the port in the back and is more function over form, but it's not as big a deal as people make it.

The pencil thing is more silly, but is also a non-issue since it charges the same way. But again yes, it looks silly. Could have been remedied by making it magnetic on the side and having it stick to those charging circles on the edge instead. Why no one at Apple thought of that is beyond me. But what can you do.
 

Gaaraz

Member
Here In the UK, they actually went UP in price.
This is the most obscene part. I get that the pound is weak, but we're talking old technology here.

We actually bought a second hand Retina MacBook earlier:

£650 - 2.4Ghz i5, 256GB SSD, 8GB RAM

vs

£1,449 - 2.0Ghz i5, 256 SSD, 8GB RAM

I appreciate there are other factors too such as the newer one having better graphics, it's thinner, has a warranty etc but no way could I justify spending the extra.
 
This is the most obscene part. I get that the pound is weak, but we're talking old technology here.

We actually bought a second hand Retina MacBook earlier:

£650 - 2.4Ghz i5, 256GB SSD, 8GB RAM

vs

£1,449 - 2.0Ghz i5, 256 SSD, 8GB RAM

I appreciate there are other factors too such as the newer one having better graphics, it's thinner, has a warranty etc but no way could I justify spending the extra.

What was the model of your 2nd hand MacBook?
 

crustikid

Member
FYI Best Buy received their shipment of non-touch bar MacBook Pros already. Used "reserve for pick up" and picked one up in the LA area.

Calculated the difference on a 13" touch bar base model after taxes and the difference is ~$320 after taxes. That's 300 more for 2 more ports, faster CPU, and touchbar...I'm not sure if that's worth it at the moment for me since the model I bought is already $200 over budget. Figure I can sell this once the price drops on new models in 18 months and purchase gen 2 touch bar at a modest loss.
 

Futureman

Member
I just noticed on Apple's MBP page, under the "Performance" section you can compare the Iris 550 in the 13" to the Radeon Pro in the 15" and apparently video editing comparison is faster on the Iris?

not sure what to make of this. I guess the 13" versions come w/ either the 540 or 550 Iris chip while the 15" MBP have a dGPU but also an 530 Iris.
 

Futureman

Member
also, not sure if it's been brought up in here, but Apple says no 32 GB RAM option with the MBP because of battery life concerns.

Schiller's answer: Thank you for the email. It is a good question. To put more than 16GB of fast RAM into a notebook design at this time would require a memory system that consumes much more power and wouldn't be efficient enough for a notebook.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom