• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Manga Discussion/News |OT7| This thread gets an F-; I quit; see you next week.

Status
Not open for further replies.

flawfuls

Member
Bright World Project 1-9

Starts off as just your average shitty rom com, but then unexpectedly evolves into some sort of smut version of Lair Game. Intersting!

dR91X9U.png

It kind of feels like something the Future Dairy author would write.
 
One Piece

I guess the liquid type guy in Doflamingo's crew may be some kind of Snot/Mucus based DF. Some people have pointed out that he appears to have a runny nose, Baby 5 is repulsed by him, and his sound effects in the chapter usually go along with snot.

Doflamingo's crew really seems to have some interesting(odd) DF's.
 

Mr. Fix

Member
One Piece

I guess the liquid type guy in Doflamingo's crew may be some kind of Snot/Mucus based DF. Some people have pointed out that he appears to have a runny nose, Baby 5 is repulsed by him, and his sound effects in the chapter usually go along with snot.

Doflamingo's crew really seems to have some interesting(odd) DF's.

qPgzL0n.png


The members of Baroque Works were pretty odd too. Though Doflamingo's crew is like the next level shit.
 
Shokugeki no Soma 13
tumblr_mj55ifh2EZ1qbxqfpo1_500.png


Soma has to be one of the happiest characters in awhile. Outcome was definitely expected really but the tastes testers, the dudes especially made the food just seem like it tasted oh so good. I wish I could taste. For the future, thank goodness he didnt join the Don RS, was afraid that might happen but if he can explore even more clubs and help them out that'd be good too, though maybe he will start his own.

I wonder if this will get big enough to get its own festival making many of the dishes in the series. 23 pgs next chapter will be wonderful, no color page?
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Food Smut

Obviously he wasn't going to lose.

You would think this school would be really popular given that you're constantly being given orgasms by the food.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Yeah, but apparently the classes are super hard. You can't get the orgasms if you don't study.

Unless you're one of those taster people.

I like how despite the whole Food Battle element, its breaking down into a generic harem featuring Food Tsundere as the probable victor.

Also, isn't there some kind of really shitty aesop in this whole, "defeat me and I'll love you" trope?

Silver Spoon

Suffering by proxy
 

aohige

Neo Member
food smut
anybody actually tried cooking following their recipes?
looks soo good...

Unlike most shounen cooking manga, food in Soma are actually rather conservative and normal. Chaliapin steak is a commonly known and etablished recipe in Japan, and the nifty "tricks" he used were all pretty conventional stuff, just unexpected to be used in a don.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Unlike most shounen cooking manga, food in Soma are actually rather conservative and normal. Chaliapin steak is a commonly known and etablished recipe in Japan, and the nifty "tricks" he used were all pretty conventional stuff, just unexpected to be used in a don.

...what's a don

Claymore

That made no sense.

These two lines follow each other really well.
 

aohige

Neo Member
...what's a don

Any dish served with rice in a donburi (large bowl).
Just like a sandwich, it's a single combined dish and not considered separate entree, so the balance between the toppings, the sauce, and rice is crucial to a good don.

Just like the hamburgers in America, most don in Japan are considered fast food for the masses.
 

aohige

Neo Member
No thanks to Food Smut for not telling me
LLShC.gif

Well um

The manga is written by and for Japanese audience, who know what a don is.

Explaining a don is like an American comic book explainng what a hamburger is lol.
Imagine Tony Stark stopping in his tract to explain what a cheeseburger is upon returning home! lol

EDIT: Oh, and a little trivia. Weekly Shounen Jump is more than a little responsible for associating with the popularity of beef don. Kinnikuman back in the 80s popularized the gyu-don (beef donburi) in TV ads and its show, and it became a national success, propelling Yoshinoya (a giant don restaurant chain) to massive food chain giant and cement itself as one of the cornerstone of fastfood in Japan.
 
Food Smut 13

Another girl blows her load after eating Soma's food. Kind of fun to see how food battles work in this series hopefully we'll see some more crazy scenarios show up.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Well um

The manga is written by and for Japanese audience, who know what a don is.

Explaining a don is like an American comic book explainng what a hamburger is lol.
Imagine Tony Stark stopping in his tract to explain what a cheeseburger is upon returning home! lol

EDIT: Oh, and a little trivia. Weekly Shounen Jump is more than a little responsible for associating with the popularity of beef don. Kinnikuman back in the 80s popularized the gyu-don (beef donburi) in TV ads and its show, and it became a national success, propelling Yoshinoya (a giant don restaurant chain) to massive food chain giant and cement itself as one of the cornerstone of fastfood in Japan.

I'm more referring to the translators. Usually if something is super foreign they will put in a note explaining what it is.
 

BatDan

Bane? Get them on board, I'll call it in.
Weekly Shonen Jump US TOC for March 4th 2013

Rurouni Kenshin Restoration
Naruto
One Piece
World Trigger
Nisekoi
Toriko
Bleach
One-Punch Man
Dragon Ball
Cross Manage
Blue Exorcist

Preview for next week: Toriko and World Trigger
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Weekly Shonen Jump US TOC for March 4th 2013

Rurouni Kenshin Restoration
Naruto
One Piece
World Trigger
Nisekoi
Toriko
Bleach
One-Punch Man
Dragon Ball
Cross Manage
Blue Exorcist

Preview for next week: Toriko and World Trigger

I don't think the US version's TOC has any relevance to the popularity of the series. I think that's just the order they print it in.
 

upandaway

Member
Shokugeki no Soma

Hahaha look at her. She just exploded. The appropriate reaction to the food whose smell made her leak out a little.

One more to the harem then, but Tadokoro will always be the original
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Shokugeki no Soma

Hahaha look at her. She just exploded. The appropriate reaction to the food whose smell made her leak out a little.

One more to the harem then, but Tadokoro will always be the original

Food Tsundere already has this locked up
 
Yuusha ni Narenakatta Ore wa Shibushibu Shuushoku o Ketsuishimashita 01

Z7ZopQrl.png


I like this. Pretty good humor even though this will probably turn into a harem it still seems fun. Hopefully they'll use more RPG humor in this and I'll be sold.
 

Kave_Man

come in my shame circle
Food smut

So good. I know it'll be a ways off but I wonder when they'll start bringing in opponents that actually stand a chance against him.

Also bring back naked apron guy.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Food smut

So good. I know it'll be a ways off but I wonder when they'll start bringing in opponents that actually stand a chance against him.

Also bring back naked apron guy.

I don't like the fact that his first Food Battle had him quitting the school as the challenge. He obviously wasn't going to lose at that point. Its not like it was implausible he could get owned otherwise since he's just some new punk.

Tadokoro wins by virtue of being approximately a million times better

BUT SURE

Tadokoro is just a moeblob butt monkey that doesn't do anything
 
Soul Cartel 60

Interesting back story for them, though the different layers on the world was most compelling. If they can go to 9th somehow, instead of just to 1st through 4th.

vs LQ-84i
tumblr_mj5fceuNPy1qbxqfpo1_500.png


Raiden vs it, interesting mission premise and what not, though go LQ-84i liked one its lines midway, someday I should actually try the franchise out I guess.
 

aohige

Neo Member
Yuusha ni Narenakatta Ore wa Shibushibu Shuushoku o Ketsuishimashita 01

Z7ZopQrl.png


I like this. Pretty good humor even though this will probably turn into a harem it still seems fun. Hopefully they'll use more RPG humor in this and I'll be sold.

It would be funnier if it wasn't for the fact it's just a variation of age-old copypasta in 2ch...
The man who claims he can use Dragon Quest spells at the application interview.
 

Kave_Man

come in my shame circle
I don't like the fact that his first Food Battle had him quitting the school as the challenge. He obviously wasn't going to lose at that point. Its not like it was implausible he could get owned otherwise since he's just some new punk.

Hey you're right about that. I hope going forward he doesn't get those as his challenge anymore.

It would at least allow him the possibility to lose other then those terrible "lose to the antagonist in a non-direct way just before the real fight" stuff that these series love to do.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Hey you're right about that. I hope going forward he doesn't get those as his challenge anymore.

It would at least allow him the possibility to lose other then those terrible "lose to the antagonist in a non-direct way just before the real fight" stuff that these series love to do.

I don't really like the fact that so far he's just a super Ace with no real flaws beyond making shitty experiments (which so far appears to just be a sight gag). Granted, I'm probably putting too much analysis into something we're calling Food Smut. (you can't call it Food Porn because that means something else. There is Food Porn in here as well, actually)
 

upandaway

Member
Tadokoro is just a moeblob butt monkey that doesn't do anything
So far she's displayed the most impressive adaptability to Soma's shenanigans. The complete opposite of Erina


Haikyuu 50

Hmm, it really does look like HQ is adopting the "Kuroko system" of having a main duo (the main guy and his best friend) for every team. Not sure how I feel about that.

Because of this chapter I'm also really afraid that (like Kuroko, haha) Hinata will be reduced to coming up with new moves every time his current thing gets countered. Fortunately it doesn't look like we're heading there, since this time they can just come up with a different sign or randomly decide to switch the 2 keywords.
 
So far she's displayed the most impressive adaptability to Soma's shenanigans. The complete opposite of Erina


Haikyuu 50

Hmm, it really does look like HQ is adopting the "Kuroko system" of having a main duo (the main guy and his best friend) for every team. Not sure how I feel about that.

Because of this chapter I'm also really afraid that (like Kuroko, haha) Hinata will be reduced to coming up with new moves every time his current thing gets countered. Fortunately it doesn't look like we're heading there, since this time they can just come up with a different sign or randomly decide to switch the 2 keywords.

They could always just switch setters and etc. The other characters did get practice with each other.
 

FillerB

Member
Hey you're right about that. I hope going forward he doesn't get those as his challenge anymore.

Probably not. As Naked-Apron-Guy said during their challenge, Souma doesn't really have much else to bet with at the moment. I'm sure that if/when he starts his own club stuff for that (budget, members, appliances, clubroom etc.) will be put at stake. That will allow him to lose with having actual "consequences" and allows for Souma to think up some inventive cooking techniques to deal with not having, for example, a good oven.
 
So far she's displayed the most impressive adaptability to Soma's shenanigans. The complete opposite of Erina


Haikyuu 50

Hmm, it really does look like HQ is adopting the "Kuroko system" of having a main duo (the main guy and his best friend) for every team. Not sure how I feel about that.

Because of this chapter I'm also really afraid that (like Kuroko, haha) Hinata will be reduced to coming up with new moves every time his current thing gets countered. Fortunately it doesn't look like we're heading there, since this time they can just come up with a different sign or randomly decide to switch the 2 keywords.

I wouldn't be too afraid of the duo's on teams, at least just yet. So far I like the different strengths of the teams(blocking team, receiving team, Aobajousai with it's spike/setter combo) and I especially liked "The Brain" twist(if it can be considered that) as it went into the idea of a decent team with one piece excelling them to being better than they are.

I also really hope they don't go into Hinata learning something new each time he's countered. Him learning a feint or being able to aim for a tip should be the extent of his progression for the most part. Let the guy at least learn to receive and pass the ball first. :/
 

Kurita

Member
Haikyuu 50

Hmm, it really does look like HQ is adopting the "Kuroko system" of having a main duo (the main guy and his best friend) for every team. Not sure how I feel about that.

Because of this chapter I'm also really afraid that (like Kuroko, haha) Hinata will be reduced to coming up with new moves every time his current thing gets countered. Fortunately it doesn't look like we're heading there, since this time they can just come up with a different sign or randomly decide to switch the 2 keywords.

I sincerely hope that matches will not just rely on the main duo.
 
I sincerely hope that matches will not just rely on the main duo.

It's already set up for the other setter to come in at some point. Plus they've set up for the other 1st year to eventually be a good/special server.

I really can't see it focusing only on Hinata and Kagayama. I think a lot of it will depend on the strength of the other team. With Aobajousai it's serve/setting so it's focusing on Nimaya's recieve(only once so far though) and Kagayama's sets.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom