• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Manga News/Discussion |OTL| Not a lick of constructive conversation here

Status
Not open for further replies.

Stulaw

Member
Sora no Otoshimono 70

Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo :(

Yeah, I know, :(
Sora no Otoshimono 71 ( bad translation)
Well, I'm sure
Tomoki will survive, but what will happen to Sugata now? I mean the little nun only wanted to be a good girl, and from what I can gather, she wanted Tomoki to love her, so she changed into an adult, but she 'killed' him and has now kidnapped Sugata. I have a feeling her end is near, unless Tomoki seperates her personalities somehow with Hiyori's memories
 
Man... Tenjou Tenge and Air Gear started out so well... and then turned into incomprehensible bullshit during the last couple arcs. So annoying that he went off the deep end just to one-up some incredibly impossible arcs. But his character design is pretty solid.

Indeed and it was pretty jarring to see it happen twice.

I honestly thought Tenjou took a sharper turn than AG
 
Nisekoi: False Love 73

If this were animated, would be definitely one of the scenarios I hope were given the anime treatment. Hilarious two or so chapters. Writing should be a bit more adventurous and actiony in regards to the cast would definitely make the series far more enjoyable. Of the girls Onodera gave the best moments.
 
To this day I have no idea what happened in Tenjou Tenge near the end or what Nagi's power even was in comparison to the others. The final villain was a mess too.

Didn't even bother with Air Gear.

First time I read so much smut in a manga though. First smut manga actually with action now that I thought about it. Might have to go back and reread it.
 
World Trigger 13
tumblr_mmqznlMvJY1qbxqfpo1_500.png


I guess Ill say that it was the first chapter with content that I thought, at this pace, made it rather boring. Not that I don't care for Chika and her side effect, its just that it was a really boring backstory that I didn't care about. Thankfully that final page saved the chapter. (and the trion measurement part too)

Harvesting of Trion organ from folks was the most compelling aspect, really want to know whats going on the other side.
 

B-Dubs

No Scrubs
Aunt Tits

So Minamoto wants to pussy out, but it looks like she won't let him. Dude's at least getting a handy.

Why do I still read this?
 
Shokugeki no Soma 22

Really hoping Hinako becomes a reccuring character.

Her antics in the previous challenge and in this chapter, have really made me like her.
 
A other weird one in my list. I suppose someone recommended it, when I asked for a horror manga.
As always, I jumped right in, without knowing what this is about.

Variante 1-2

LY2hdyP.jpg


A high school girl and her parents get killed at home and the girl comes back to life at the morgue. It's discovered that she got some sort of mutated arm that is similar to the chimera monsters that are running around in this world. The general public doesn't know about them and they're fought by some special unit. When she's in danger or gets threatened, her arm awakens, she loses control of it and hilarity ensues.

The first two chapters are about 100 pages long and I'm still not sure what to think of it. It doesn't feel atmospheric, I don't feel any suspense and the characters don't interest me either. I really don't know where this is going, but I feel like she's going to use her power to fight the monsters, yay!

The art is nothing special at all. Not even the chimera monster was good or creative and far from scary. "It does the job" is probably the best thing I could say about it.
 
Tenjou Tenge

To this day I have no idea what happened in Tenjou Tenge near the end or what Nagi's power even was in comparison to the others. The final villain was a mess too.

At first his power was the ability to steal the powers of the other families and use it as his own but then it got really weird when his father appeared doing weird shit.

Shokugeki no Soma 22

Really hoping Hinako becomes a reccuring character.

Her antics in the previous challenge and in this chapter, have really made me like her.

Her weird obsession with Tadokoro (Dojima had to rule her out of the judging) makes her interesting also lol
 
One-Punch Man 16
tumblr_mmrr7bjhvg1qbxqfpo1_400.png


Concern for master, if only it went both ways. Anyway whole chapter felt like one of those filler type anime stories of sorts, would definitely have wanted to see this in an anime form as it seemed funny. Genos ftw.

The color page seemed kind of odd to be the final moment, odd use of one.
 
Variante 3-4, end of vol 1

"Sure, you have a mutated monster arm you can't control and you killed my dog, that sucks big time. But you're my best friend after all and I care about you!"

Best friends forever.

The scene that followed afterwards was hilarious as well. I don't buy it one bit that the public doesn't know about these monsters, when attacks like that happen everywhere, even in brought daylight.
 
Aunts tits 78

I feel like the 10 page format of these chapters really is flawed in these more dialogue heavy ones, it keeps us away from the good stuff too long
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
I should've been working on something but instead I read ES21 from Poseiden -> Teikoku.

Goddam.
 
A other weird one in my list. I suppose someone recommended it, when I asked for a horror manga.
As always, I jumped right in, without knowing what this is about.

Variante 1-2

Just so you know, don't expect the most clear resolution. I don't know if this was cancelled, rushed, or the author always planned it to be that way, but it definitely feels like one of the first two.
 

Articalys

Member
So this is just in terms of licensing stuff in the USA? I hope they get on it because I'm starting to learn French and Japanese to read unreleased stuff here.
I don't think it really means much of anything for now, just that they might be open to the idea in the future. I'd keep up the language studies if I were you.
 
Variante 5-7

As expected, mutant arm girl is going to use her power to fight those evil monsters. Her first real fight against a chimera was sort of underwhelming and cliche. New, power, can't control it, it gets dangerous, she goes berserk, end. Bleh. I just hope that there are going to be more interesting enemies down the line. And with her being part of the unit I guess it's normal that she causes some uncertainties amnesty the other members.
 

Akito

Member
1/11 c1-6


I stumbled on this by pure chance but decided to give it a go anyway and that was not a bad decision at all. It may looks like a ordinary sports/football manga but a better description would be a short story collection with football as an overarching theme.
Each short story put the spotlight on one certain character, their life and relation with Andou, our MC. In the first chapter Andou, almost a high school student is faced with the life changing decision whether to continue playing football or to concentrate on studying in order to get into a good university. The love and enthusiasm he once had for football seems almost gone as well so the outcome seems quite obvious until a encounter with a weird girl occurs.
The others MCs are all pretty different but what they all have in common is that they are somehow related to Andou, there's Nina, the female manager of the high school football club where Andou is the captain or Masaomi, the reserved goalkeeper in Andou's first professional club. Some may love football just like Andou but some may not even have any relation to it, though they are all affected by him and his straightforward love for it, which help them moving forward and overcoming their own obstacles.
If you're looking for a sports manga which puts emphasis on drama, romance and slice-of-life rather than sports itself in the vein of, dare I say it, most of Adachi's manga, this could be a good match, do not expect it to be nearly as subtle though.

P.S. I like how the covers also have an overarching theme, the colors are also pretty nice.
 

upandaway

Member
May I ask why you dropped Foot Smut? The reactions this week seemed rather positive.
He's been wrestling with the invincible MC trope for like 75% of his comments on the manga so far, it seems like a camel broke his straw so to say, since the chapter itself wasn't particularly explosive. Feel free to correct me angry-man.
 
He's been wrestling with the invincible MC trope for like 75% of his comments on the manga so far, it seems like a camel broke his straw so to say, since the chapter itself wasn't particularly explosive. Feel free to correct me angry-man.

Oh, I see. How smutty is Food Smut for people who don't (want to) read smut? Would that be like "watching porn for the story"?
 

Antiwhippy

the holder of the trombone
Yeah. Pretty much. The cooking aspects are fun too.

Needs a lot more development though.

Just to be clear there is fanservice, but it is pretty tame compared to what most people consider smut over here.

Equal opportunity fanservice too, which I fully support.
 

upandaway

Member
Oh, I see. How smutty is Food Smut for people who don't (want to) read smut? Would that be like "watching porn for the story"?
It's.. hard to say. I mean, the smut is definitely there, and they are most definitely physically orgasming by interacting with food, but.. and I hate myself for relying on this comparison again, but it's so easy I have to: it's done similarly to Yakitate Japan and it's hilarious in the same vein. If you liked that manga, then it should be fine even if you don't like smut, I think.

Not much point in figuring it out though since the first chapter is enough for anyone to make up his mind... that's the important part of the whole thing I think.

Equal opportunity fanservice too, which I fully support.
We definitely need more Inui reactions.
 

Kurita

Member
Food Smut isn't really smut. The reactions in the mangas are just over-the-top and really fun.
And there are naked dudes and girls.

Assassination Classroom 42
dhJA8qR.png

*dead*
 
Variante 8-9, end of vol 2

This sort of feels like this not-inFamous multi platform game that came out a while ago (I forgot the name). Anyway, it's been standard procedure from here on. Akio kills monsters, Sudou begins to discover secret things within the organization, those things are probably linked to his past, jadda jadda jadda. At least the flashback explains his stupid bandana.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom