The athlete that committed to me is unlike any I've seen in this game ever:
94 speed
92 agility
95 accel
86 INJ
84 stamina
75 break tackle
88 juke
91 elusive
88 spin
87 man coverage
79 zone coverage
78 press
90 throw power
78 throw accuracy
Late, but that is one great Athlete. You're gonna have a tough time deciding where to use him. He could be another Denard Robinson (with an even worse arm, that's a pretty meh accuracy rating, but then it "should" get better) Not sure on his size, but could be a great RB with those ball carrier ratings. Don't see Catch Ratings, but could probably be a great WR.
Problem comes into if you want him on Defense. Could fit into most of the DB roles, depending on tackling.
If this ATH is "Gibson" and a 4 star ATH, wow, his scouting must have been astronomical. 72 OVR at first glance, but those rankings would put him at or above 80.
Comparing to Bailey, my QB who won me the game against CB. Him having 84 accuracy (just enough) made me choose QB over DB. 77 QB, but I want to say was 79-80 at the CB positions. 77-78 at the Safety positions (the tackle and hit power were a little lower, but the press made up for it) It was a tough decision, but having a running threat at QB was something I didn't have, while I have alot of quality (except against CB, FMT...and Bob) CB's on the bench.
Bailey-SuperAthlete
90-94 speed
90-92 agility
92-95 accel
80-86 INJ
80-84 stamina
74-75 break tackle
90-88 juke
88-91 elusive
84-88 spin
81-87 man coverage
84-79 zone coverage
86-78 press
80-90 throw power
84-78 throw accuracy
69 catching
67 tackle
80 pursuit
81 play recognition
Hoping that in a year or 2, his THP will perhaps climb to 83-85, but THA (which always grows more than THP) will get into the upper 80's. A respectable arm + speed. But Running QB's are Fumble Factories. Hell, all QB's are fumble factories, if you take off with them and get hit instead of slide.