• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

|OT| French Presidential Elect 2017 - La France est toujours insoumise; Le Pen loses

GAF Decides


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Oriel

Member
Unfortunately all the people who voted for a fascist aren't going away

We still have problems that lead to people running into the arms of fascism and I'm not sure Macron will help change that, although I hope for the best

There's been fascists in the developed world for decades, that doesn't mean we're going to see them take over any time soon. Ever since Brexit and Trump's win the media narrative has been one of ultra-right wing nationalists leading a populist backlash against the liberal world order and globalism. That belief has now been comprehensively destroyed.

There'll always be fascist cunts who want to roll back to their ideal of a world of closed borders, trade barriers and isolationism. That dream of theirs is just that, a dream. Globalism, liberalism and free trade is here to stay and Macron's win so perfectly proves this.
 

HarryKS

Member
Pretty much.

Can't be a true leftist if you think the fascist candidate is the same as a centrist.


How are they fascist? Just throwing that term around does not mean it becomes a filler which you can use to cover a lack of vocabulary.
 

grumpy

Member
C6_SUx7XAAASNt4.jpg


Loosers club :D

Why do those far-right shitstains worldwide all look like they came out of the "Village of the Damned"?
 

Korigama

Member
Glad to see France made the right call. Fun times reading the Fox comments lol. It appears politics for most people has entirely ceased being about what's best for the majority of the country, and is now about as trivial as picking a sports team to root for.
Though not the only factor for that, cable news networks treating election years like sporting events (such as the garbage that CNN had been known to engage in all throughout last year with ads for their political coverage) certainly doesn't help.
Well shit.
A direct admission of Trump's illegitimacy. Lovely.
 

Mael

Member
For the 1st round, 37% who went Macron like his project over 34 for MLP

No really he's was French Ministry for the Economy and Finance In office
26 August 2014 – 30 August 2016

Which is nothing politically.
He had no position in the party
 
Thanks for the salt, I'm cooking now.
If you were for Melenchon you're a big fucking hypocrite, the guy is one of the least new guy we had this round.

When did i said i want a "new guy"?
Making assumption much ? oh wait, i'm on neogaf, i forgot XD

And look at the results, most people vote for him to counter Le Pen.

Vote for the less worst one.
Just like the last election.
And the one before.
And the one before...

But hey, enjoy your victory.
Just don't come here crying when what remains the public service is gonna be destroyed.
 

Xando

Member
How are they fascist? Just throwing that term around does not mean it becomes a filler which you can use to cover a lack of vocabulary.

Are you arguing Le Pen isn't a fascist?

Her policies are textbook fascist. Maybe you should look up the definition of fascist.
 

Stumpokapow

listen to the mad man
No as I showed you he had less support for his platform than the three other candidates (I showed it on this thread last week).
During the second round only 16% voted for his platform (30% for Le Pen's platform)

This doesn't imply what you think it implies. France doesn't have approval voting, you can't infer very much from the results about what it says about Macron's platform, except that a sizable majority of French voters prefer Macron's platform to Le Pen's. It is impossible to say whether those who voted for Macron for reasons other than his platform independently also support his platform or not. I think the #1 reason to vote for Macron is because we must resist fascism, but that doesn't imply anything about what I think of Macron beyond that. Independent, he also seems to me to be fine on policy. As a social democrat I would typically prefer the Socialist Party candidate to win in France and Hamon seemed like a good guy who ran at the wrong time -- but Macron also seems generally suitable and the French left mischaracterizing him as a neoliberal extremist is weird given that the alternative would have been Fillion vs. Le Pen.

But the question is moot anyway because of course French presidents do not have """platforms""" in the abstract, it all depends if they have a legislative majority or are in a cohabitation situation. One presumes LR voters will support him if he moves right because there's an LR legislative majority, while SP voters will support him if he moves left because there's an SP legislative majority (lolololol). If EM+SP get a majority together presumably he will move somewhat left.
 

Coffinhal

Member
For a first round, it's considered a significant margin. 2 Million people.
No sorry, I don't' respect whiners who can't be arsed to go put a white ballot.

Actually he had 1 million more people than Le Pen and 1,5/6 million more than Fillon/Mélenchon

A significant margin is Mitterrand vs Chirac in 1988 (34%/20%) or Mitterrand vs Giscard in 1974 (44/33)

Ah, the perennial idiocy of confusing freedom of speech and the freedom not to be mocked. I wonder who else is confused about this all the time.
I am not for jailing these people. And the discussion is obviously not about it's a form of political expression.

I understood that you like to mock, wait, insult, people that abstain or put a white ballot with great contempt. That's arrogant and irrespectful, so have fun doing it, you're the one looking silly here.

Too bad you didn't say answer about the numbers that show that Macron wasn't elected on his platform but mostly because of a vote utile.
 

Mimosa97

Member
Mélenchon " Ce soir s'achève la présidence la plus lamentable de la cinquième République " LMFAO

Even Macron barely acknowledged Hollande. He just thanked him for running the country for 5 years and that's about it. That's just insanely COLD. Damn.
 

Stumpokapow

listen to the mad man
How are they fascist? Just throwing that term around does not mean it becomes a filler which you can use to cover a lack of vocabulary.

They support government seizing authority over the social and cultural life of the country in order to protect the ethnic national identity from outsiders. This is a primary ingredient of fascism historically. They do so with the support of autocrats worldwide, including other autocrats who are ethnic nationalists. They aim to delegitimize institutional checks and balances in the national system, also a tendency of fascists because it is a precursor for authoritarian control of a country.

It also happens that she is a Holocaust-questioning daughter of a white supremacist Holocaust denier, so if someone wanted to say "neo-nazi" instead of fascist I think they'd have a pretty credible claim.

But also, setting aside that it does seem to be an accurate word, how thin skinned do you need to be to worry about Marine Le Pen getting called a mean name? Call her what you want to call her, as long as you don't call her President.
 

AYF 001

Member
I'd love to see how much these right wing heels actually believe this crap when their candidate wins the popular vote but loses the election.
I mean, if Donald could win by negative 3 million votes, why can't Putin's My Little Pawny?
 

Korigama

Member
That has to be trolling, right? Right?!
Pretty sure people like the person in that screencap are quite happy for the Electoral College remaining the only thing able to still deliver wins for incompetent Republican presidential candidates (and for the second time in less than 20 years at that).
 

Shito

Member
but Macron also seems generally suitable and the French left mischaracterizing him as a neoliberal extremist is weird given that the alternative would have been Fillion vs. Le Pen.
Thank you, it seems like everybody is forgetting that we were aiming straight for Fillion as our president...

I'm so sick of Mélenchon and his fucking sect
I can't wait for them to shut up a bit... I don't express myself much on the political subject, but the vocal supporters of Melenchon have been SOOOO annoying these past two weeks, acting like they were the only alternative against Le Pen, and forgetting that they only arrived fourth during the first ballot.
 

Oriel

Member
I don't know about that, Macron is as populist a vote as Le Pen. The French people have rejected all the established political parties for basically an unknown.

I mentioned it before in this thread but now you just to hope he doesn't blow it for the next person because people could just as easily turn to someone like Le Pen if they feel like the other options aren't working.

Macron is as moderate and progressive as they come. Just because he doesn't belong to one of the traditional parties doesn't mean he's a rejection of liberal globalisation. His win is an endorsement by voters of continued free trade and openness between countries.
 

Stumpokapow

listen to the mad man
Too bad you didn't say answer about the numbers that show that Macron wasn't elected on his platform but mostly because of a vote utile.

Sure, but I did. The fact that voters found it more urgent to reject Le Pen than to elect Macron does not tell us very much about how much they support Macron.

It's a little strange that you're very mad and very defensive at a guy for reading too much into your choice not to stand against a fascist hatemonger trying to undermine your country's way of life, but you're extremely ready to read too much into a survey about peoples' #1 reason for voting for a candidate. Is it possible you're just projecting because you don't want people to like Macron and you're extremely insecure about your choice to abstain? If you want emotional validation, you're not going to find it here.
 

RM8

Member
It's honestly pretty reassuring to know the supposed far right wave is not really a thing. Countries that aren't a train wreck will remain not being a train wreck :)

Not that it's considered to be important, lol, but next year I also see a very, very low chance for the right wing party to win in Mexico. And honestly, right wing Mexico is still socialist left by many countries' standards anyway.
 

EmiPrime

Member
They support government seizing authority over the social and cultural life of the country in order to protect the ethnic national identity from outsiders. This is a primary ingredient of fascism historically. They do so with the support of autocrats worldwide, including other autocrats who are ethnic nationalists. They aim to delegitimize institutional checks and balances in the national system, also a tendency of fascists because it is a precursor for authoritarian control of a country.

It also happens that she is a Holocaust-questioning daughter of a white supremacist Holocaust denier, so if someone wanted to say "neo-nazi" instead of fascist I think they'd have a pretty credible claim.

But also, setting aside that it does seem to be an accurate word, how thin skinned do you need to be to worry about Marine Le Pen getting called a mean name? Call her what you want to call her, as long as you don't call her President.

Ooooooooooooo!
 
THEY WOULD RATHER LET THE WORLD BURN !!!



No, they have every right to complain, it's their freedom of speech and you have to understand that abstaining is a form of political expression. You may not like it but sociology shows that it is how it works in the reality (see the work of Anne Muxel).

He doesn't have a strong support.

No as I showed you he had less support for his platform than the three other candidates (I showed it on this thread last week).
During the second round only 16% voted for his platform (30% for Le Pen's platform)

Thank you.

I understood that you like to mock, wait, insult, people that abstain or put a white ballot with great contempt. That's arrogant and irrespectful, so have fun doing it, you're the one looking silly here.

Too bad you didn't say answer about the numbers that show that Macron wasn't elected on his platform but mostly because of a vote utile.

And thank you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom