Pokemon sequel is under development for DS

Dogenzaka said:
If it's revealed that Gen 5 is a DS game with the Platinum/HGSS engine (or heck, just boring sprites with hardly any animations as usual) I will be soooooo sad.
Actually, I highly doubt they will reuse the old engine.

Even with Pokemon R/B/Y to G/S/C on practically the same system, there were some pretty big changes. I never saw G/S in black and white, but in color, they're quite different from one another, and G/S/C truly feels like an evolution.
 
Well each unit got...
Game Boy
  • Red
  • Blue/Green
  • Yellow

Game Boy Color
  • Gold
  • Silver
  • Crystal

Game Boy Advance
  • Ruby
  • Sapphire
  • Emerald
  • FiredRed (remake)
  • LeafGreen (remake)

Nintendo DS
  • Pearl
  • Diamond
  • Platinum
  • HeartGold (remake)
  • SoulSilver (remake)

So..on trend alone, the new game should be on a new unit (the 3DS)...but who knows...
 
I am expecting the same old Pokemon sprites and all on the DS engine nothing really changed besides the graphics through all gens.

Also next gen we will get Ruby Sapphire Remake ;)
 
At this point, it's looking to be for the DSi or 3DS. But which one???
It could be for the DSi, in which case it would be another GSC situation (GBC game compatible with Game Boy).
Or a 3DS launch title, in which case Nintendo and the Pokemon Company can host a party around the pool of money they'll make.

CryptiK said:
Also next gen we will get Ruby Sapphire Remake ;)
YES
 
fernoca said:
Well each unit got...
Game Boy
  • Red
  • Blue/Green
  • Yellow

Game Boy Color
  • Gold
  • Silver
  • Crystal

Game Boy Advance
  • Ruby
  • Sapphire
  • Emerald
  • FiredRed (remake)
  • LeafGreen (remake)

Nintendo DS
  • Pearl
  • Diamond
  • Platinum
  • HeartGold (remake)
  • SoulSilver (remake)

So..on trend alone, the new game should be on a new unit (the 3DS)...but who knows...

But Gold and Silver were playable in the original Gameboy as well.
 
ColtraineGF said:
At this point, it's looking to be for the DSi or 3DS. But which one???
It could be for the DSi, in which case it would be another GSC situation (GBC game compatible with Game Boy).
Or a 3DS launch title, in which case Nintendo and the Pokemon Company can host a party around the pool of money they'll make.


YES
it wouldnt be for DSi it would hurt sales too much it would be either a DS or 3DS title or maybe both who knows.
 
Corrected list

Game Boy with Super Game Boy enhancements
  • Red
  • Blue/Green

Game Boy / Game Boy Color Dual Mode with Super Game Boy enhancements
  • Yellow
  • Gold
  • Silver

Game Boy Color Only
  • Crystal

Game Boy Advance
  • Ruby
  • Sapphire
  • Emerald
  • FiredRed (remake)
  • LeafGreen (remake)

Nintendo DS
  • Pearl
  • Diamond
  • Platinum
  • HeartGold (remake)
  • SoulSilver (remake)
 
If they put it on DS - all DS,dSi and 3DS owners will be able to play it and they will make most money. But as 3ds eds exklusive they would have a uber system seller at launch, but they never released out a main pokemon game at launch...
 
cw_sasuke said:
If they put it on DS - all DS,dSi and 3DS owners will be able to play it and they will make most money. But as 3ds eds exklusive they would have a uber system seller at launch, but they never released out a main pokemon game at launch...

I bet they can pull a Twilight Princess and have a 3D version ready for the 3DS launch so people can choose.
 
seady said:
I bet they can pull a Twilight Princess and have a 3D version ready for the 3DS launch so people can choose.
I don't know about that. It would be 4 versions of one game. Unless they do a Mystery Dungeon Red Team/Blue Team thing, where one version if for the DS and the other for the 3DS.
 
A Black Falcon said:
Corrected list
*list*
That is true, but playing Yellow, it was very clearly built for the GB. Each town is only one color hue with different shades, and so are all of the Pokemon. It was to the point that the box art didn't even say "Game Boy Color" on it like other GB/C games.

Edit: It was also apparently a feature for only outside of Japan, too.
 
seady said:
I bet they can pull a Twilight Princess and have a 3D version ready for the 3DS launch so people can choose.

Nah.

I think with as chummy as Iwata with is Isahara (and GF is with Nintendo) it should be a 3DS launch title as a system seller, which would make the most money for Nintendo in the long run. I think Nintendo believes that DS owners won't by a third Pokemon game like before (first being DPPt, second being HGSS.)
 
seady said:
I bet they can pull a Twilight Princess and have a 3D version ready for the 3DS launch so people can choose.

Could be, but the difference between the DS and 3DS is probably way bigger than between Cube and Wii back then, they wont do ist if the game will have to look completly different...

imo they should bringt it on 3ds - just because of the wpa2 support...
 
My bet is that its going to be a DS game which is 3D enhanced when played on the 3DS.

Just as the GBA enhanced some GBC games.
 
A Black Falcon said:
Corrected list

Game Boy with Super Game Boy enhancements
  • Red
  • Blue/Green

Game Boy / Game Boy Color Dual Mode with Super Game Boy enhancements
  • Yellow
  • Gold
  • Silver

Game Boy Color Only
  • Crystal

Game Boy Advance
  • Ruby
  • Sapphire
  • Emerald
  • FiredRed (remake)
  • LeafGreen (remake)

Nintendo DS
  • Pearl
  • Diamond
  • Platinum
  • HeartGold (remake)
  • SoulSilver (remake)

So 3DS it is, and also on the 3DS near the end remakes of Ruby and Sapphire under names like Blood Ruby.
 
trinest said:
So 3DS it is, and also on the 3DS near the end remakes of Ruby and Sapphire under names like Blood Ruby.

I may probably end up being wrong.. But I honestly can't see them remaking Ruby and Sapphire.

They're practically the same games as Diamond and Pearl, almost.
 
Dabookerman said:
I may probably end up being wrong.. But I honestly can't see them remaking Ruby and Sapphire.

They're practically the same games as Diamond and Pearl, almost.

They will remake Ruby/Sappire.

$$$
 
Dabookerman said:
I may probably end up being wrong.. But I honestly can't see them remaking Ruby and Sapphire.

They're practically the same games as Diamond and Pearl, almost.
Don't forget that the RS remakes will be based on gen 5, not gen 4.
 
cw_sasuke said:

Well, yeah, precisely. I'm just saying that outside of the obvious, there isn't an obvious demand for it like there was for RBY/GSC remakes.

I'd personally be surprised if they announce it (And buy it nonetheless).
 
Well, we'll see of Gen 5 will be different.

Mind you, Gen 3 actually made a complete overhaul on the HUD and gameplay, so 1 and 2 were begging to be remade.
 
Dabookerman said:
Well, yeah, precisely. I'm just saying that outside of the obvious, there isn't an obvious demand for it like there was for RBY/GSC remakes.

I'd personally be surprised if they announce it (And buy it nonetheless).
I'd buy it in a heartbeat because I really want a "fixed" RSE. I honestly didn't like the main quest, definitely not on par with the other 3 generations.

If they go the route of changing things here and there and making it better, then I would love it, and I don't think I will be alone there. Add to that whatever huge twist they have in store for gen 5, too, and there's gonna be enough demand, especially if it comes out 5-6 years from now.
 
Dabookerman said:
Well, yeah, precisely. I'm just saying that outside of the obvious, there isn't an obvious demand for it like there was for RBY/GSC remakes.

I'd personally be surprised if they announce it (And buy it nonetheless).
Yeah, whereas everyone loves RBY/GSC and wanted them remade, a hell of a lot of people don't like RSE and think it's the worst of the series.
Another reason is that RSE are still compatible with the current generation. RBY/GSC needed to be remade because there was noway to get Pokemon from them to current generation games, whereas you can Pokemon from RSE just fine.
Not to mention that every Pokemon from RSE is available in the 4th gen games anyway, to the point where you can basically get all RSE legendaries in HGSS so they can't exactly market it by saying "Get all these Pokemon you couldn't before!"
 
If it is 3DS, this blowout on Pokemon Sunday and in CoroCoro will be the first unveiling of the system. Do you think that would happen?
 
ivysaur12 said:
If it is 3DS, this blowout on Pokemon Sunday and in CoroCoro will be the first unveiling of the system. Do you think that would happen?
No. I'm almost certin that they already annouced this is for the DS.
 
I'm gonna be super-cynical and say we aren't going to see any media of the game for ages. What we will see is probably going to be a load of new Pokemon, and a few pieces of info.
 
I'm going to be super anti-cynical and say there's no reason why this wouldn't be 3DS and that we are going to get a complete rethinking of the overworld formula, if not of the battle system.
 
Green Scar said:
I'm gonna be super-cynical and say we aren't going to see any media of the game for ages. What we will see is probably going to be a load of new Pokemon, and a few pieces of info.

That's not so much cynical as par for the course if you believe the game will be 3DS-exclusive...
 
I think we are probably just gonna get artwork for the region, the region's name, plus some characters. I really doubt they will show a single screenshot of the game yet.
 
ivysaur12 said:
If it is 3DS, this blowout on Pokemon Sunday and in CoroCoro will be the first unveiling of the system. Do you think that would happen?

absolutely not. nintendo would not allow the unveiling of a game for a system they have not formally revealed yet. it's going to be a DS game.
 
Regulus Tera said:
I'm going to be super anti-cynical and say there's no reason why this wouldn't be 3DS and that we are going to get a complete rethinking of the overworld formula, if not of the battle system.

I hope so. I really do. They've got the definitive Pokemon games with HG/SS.
Try something new, even if it's not as good (maybe) change is good. I would welcome it.
 
Mr.Wuggles said:
absolutely not. nintendo would not allow the unveiling of a game for a system they have not formally revealed yet. it's going to be a DS game.

It's been formally announced, press release and everything. The system itself hasn't been shown, but it is formally and officially announced.
 
Why would you do that? said:
That is true, but playing Yellow, it was very clearly built for the GB. Each town is only one color hue with different shades, and so are all of the Pokemon. It was to the point that the box art didn't even say "Game Boy Color" on it like other GB/C games.

Edit: It was also apparently a feature for only outside of Japan, too.

That's true, Yellow isn't the same kind of GBC game as most GBC games are. That "one color hue" thing sounds like they might have taken the Super Game Boy colors and just put them in as GBC colors, perhaps?

Still, I can't imagine any way that they did it other than having it be a dual-mode game. Perhaps it should have a note saying that it's a much less comprehensive effort than the later ones, colors-wise, but it's got to be a dual-mode game, outside of Japan at least.

I don't know why they didn't put "GBC" on it. They wanted to keep the box looking the same as Red and Blue, perhaps? On a similar note Nintendo left off the Super Game Boy logos from Red, Blue, Yellow, Gold, and Silver in the US, despite all of them having SGB support. In Japan the boxes have the SGB logos, but not in the US. Now I know the SGB was evidently more popular there (perhaps because the SNES lasted longer there, and the SGB only came out in 1994), but other games that supported it mostly had the logo on them... the Pokemon games are the main exception. It's just a little odd, and I have no idea why they did it. They definitely did not remove the SGB features from the US releases, just the logo showing that it's supported.

trinest said:
So 3DS it is, and also on the 3DS near the end remakes of Ruby and Sapphire under names like Blood Ruby.

It's possible it could be for the standard DS, but yeah, historically 3DS does seem more likely. We'll see though, but it is true that there haven't been more than five Pokemon versions designed for any one system, and the DS has five now.
 
OMG Aero said:
Yeah, whereas everyone loves RBY/GSC and wanted them remade, a hell of a lot of people don't like RSE and think it's the worst of the series.
Another reason is that RSE are still compatible with the current generation. RBY/GSC needed to be remade because there was noway to get Pokemon from them to current generation games, whereas you can Pokemon from RSE just fine.
Not to mention that every Pokemon from RSE is available in the 4th gen games anyway, to the point where you can basically get all RSE legendaries in HGSS so they can't exactly market it by saying "Get all these Pokemon you couldn't before!"
Your second point is a good indicator why R/S will be remade for Gen 5. Unless, of course, you can catch all Pokémon from D/P/Pt/HG/SS that were in Gen 3.

That is, of course, if Gen5 is going to be a 3DS game.

Mr.Wuggles said:
did i say formally announced?

Mr.Wuggles said:
absolutely not. nintendo would not allow the unveiling of a game for a system they have not formally revealed yet. it's going to be a DS game.
And the difference is?
 
Jet Grind Radio! said:
And the difference is?

it was formally announced, yes - nintendo released a tiny press release that was a few sentences long. all it revealed was that it was 3D, backwards compatible, and the "successor to the DS series".

they did not reveal the system. there is still a lot that nintendo hasn't confirmed themselves - does it have graphics on par with the GC like so many rumors suggest? nikkei strongly suggested it would have vibration, a tilt sensor, and a "3D stick", and while those are very likely to come true, nintendo never confirmed it themselves.

suppose this is a 3DS game that they're announcing this week, when all nintendo has revealed about the 3DS are those few details. do you really think nintendo would allow that?

the 3DS was formally announced in march. it's getting formally revealed in june. no 3DS games will be formally announced until june at the very earliest.
 
Mr.Wuggles said:
it was formally announced, yes - nintendo released a tiny press release that was a few sentences long. all it revealed was that it was 3D, backwards compatible, and the "successor to the DS series".

they did not reveal the system. there is still a lot that nintendo hasn't confirmed themselves - does it have graphics on par with the GC like so many rumors suggest? nikkei strongly suggested it would have vibration, a tilt sensor, and a "3D stick", and while those are very likely to come true, nintendo never confirmed it themselves.

suppose this is a 3DS game that they're announcing this week, when all nintendo has revealed about the 3DS are those few details. do you really think nintendo would allow that?

the 3DS was formally announced in march. it's getting formally revealed in june. no 3DS games will be formally announced until june at the very earliest.
Why wouldn't they? I don't know where you are getting these "rules" that things HAVE to be done a certain way. For all we know next week's reveal could just be the starters and the name for Gen 5. They could do all of that and STILL announce it for the 3DS.
 
You know, since this is not a real 5th gen pokemon, I figured I'd show you all because this is a really cool fan-pokemon I found on google yesterday.

What do you think?

257kf8k.jpg


I personally wish those 3 would be real 5th gen pokemon.
 
Ugh, this thread. It's announced for DS, get that through your head and stop trying to second guess an official press release. If you really think it would be odd perhaps you've missed the fact that nearly every hardware iteration is preceeded by a Pokemon game and rarely followed:

Pokemon Red/Green/Blue: Gameboy Pocket releases 5 months later
Pokemon Yellow: Gameboy Color releases 1 month later
Pokemon Crystal: Gameboy Advance releases 3 months later
Pokemon Ruby/Sapphire: Gameboy Advance SP releases 3 months later
Pokemon Emerald: DS releases 3 months later
Pokemon Diamond and Pearl: DS Lite releases 6 months later
Pokemon Platinum: DSi releases 2 months later
Pokemon Heart Gold/Sould silver: DSi XL releases 2 months later.

You guys are really bad at looking at your "evidence." The best you can hope for is DSi/3DS enhanced.
 
Galactic Quail said:
You know, since this is not a real 5th gen pokemon, I figured I'd show you all because this is a really cool fan-pokemon I found on google yesterday.

What do you think?

257kf8k.jpg


I personally wish those 3 would be real 5th gen pokemon.

...What is it? A fox?

Edit: Hmm...a Cerberus might be weird for pokemon, but it could be cool...
 
Top Bottom