Support NeoGAF

[AJUMP23]

Everyone is getting a C this year. Nothing mind blowing but overall passing.

 

[YCoCg]

SOP: B
SGF: D
XBO: C

But a pretty meh year overall so far.

 

[Labadal]

Sony - B
Microsoft - B
Summer Game Fest - I forgot
PC Gaming Show - E

 

[Heisenberg007]

1. SGF = 8/10
2. SoP = 7.5/10
3. Xbox = 5/10

• I enjoyed SGF the most - especially the first half. Wishlisted several games that were shown then. 8/10
• State of Play was also quite good. I think it excelled because it had something for everyone: first-party, third-party exclusives, VR, indie, etc. 7.5/10.
• Xbox's was the weakest, in my opinion. It was a very good Game Pass ad, but the selection of games was mediocre. Their marquee title (Outer Worlds 2) was absolutely awful, an $80 mediocre title. Super Meat Boy 3D and Mudong were the highlights for me. Not enough gameplay for other games (COD, Plague Tale, etc.)

 

[SenkiDala]

I like how people rate Sony SOP a F, and the XGS a A or B, blaming Sony for having too little exclusives, while during the XGS we had... 0 exclusives.

All the games that you've seen on the XGS are also coming on PS5. 99% of them on day one. So how the XGS can be better ? If we're speaking about games (and I think that's the case), the PS5 will get all the games of the XGS, all.

We've no news of Perfect Dark, Everwild, Fable, Forza, State of Decay, and on and on, but "oh well that's ok" ?

Anyway, seeing that now 99% of games are multiplatforms (the 1% that are not, are PS games), I rate those presentations by "how the games I've seen are exciting to me".
In the Xbox Showcase I liked :
- Keeper
- Gears of War Reloaded

Both are coming on PS5.

In the SOP I liked :
- Ghost of Yotei
- Silent Hill f
- Lumines Arise
- Pragmata
- Final Fantasy Tactics remake
- MGS Delta
and some others.

 

[Alan Wake]

SGF: 6/10
SoP: 6/10
XGS: 7/10

Xbox won it again. Except, this time most of the announced games will launch on PS5 as well. So Sony is the winner in any case. If you own a PS5 you'll have a lot to look forward to.

 

[Team Andromeda]

SOP - 3
summer - 6
Showcase - 7

 

[Sephiran]

As a Switch 2 owner, 0 games were announced for Switch 2 during these 3 shows, meaning its an F for me.

 

[Ribi]

SOP 5/10
SGF 8/10
XBAWKS 5/10

if you think the sony show was good you have lower standards than Nintendo fans

 

[kunonabi]

SGF was terrible but at the same time they announced Alex for SF6 and the next RE is building off of Outbreak so I gotta give it some props. I am not a bearded english lit major or little girl so the xbox showing was not for me. The playstation event was excellent and i normally cant stand Sony's showings.

 

[Rocinante618]

So much pessimism here, I loved most of them!

SoP:

1. 007 First Light
2. Nioh 3
3. Silient Hill f
4. Bloodstained 2

SGF:

1. End of Abyss
2. Mouse PI
3. Game of Thrones, War for Westeros
4. Atomic Heart 2
5. Felt that Boxing
6. Lego Voyagers/Out of Words
7. Mina the Hollower
8. Dying Light The Beast
9. ILL
10. Stranger than Heaven
11. RE9

XBOX:

1. Outer Worlds 2
2. High on Life 2
3. Plague's Tale, Spin-off
4. Blood of Dawnwalker
5. Ninja Gaiden 4
6. Beasts of Reincarnation
7. Indiana Jones DLC
8. Cronos, New Dawn
9. Grounded 2
10. Clockwork Revolution
11. No Ghosts at the Grand
12. Mudang Two Hearts (where Steam??)
13. At Fate's End
14. (maybe, lol, I just play campaigns) CoD BO7

So I rate it Xbox >~ SGD >> SoP (which is kinda expected as SoP is a smaller one compared the the other two major events)