• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Spring 2011 Anime Thread of ZAWA ZAWA, Money, emo Cyclops, and fun^10xint^40=Ir2

Status
Not open for further replies.

Geneijin

Member
Izayoi said:
I thought it was a given that Iroha was not a perverted show on the whole, though. You'd have to be crazy to think so.

Am I going to need to spell everything out from now on?
It is a given, but your statement as I bolded could be read as such a statement saying HanaIro was one, which is why I wanted to highlight why you got the reactions you did over your statement.
 

Erigu

Member
Izayoi said:
Are you being facetious here or are your implying this is what I think?
No, just something I often see when it comes to stuff like this...
(not sure what's "Engrish" about "Holo" though... or "Horo" for that matter)


cosmicblizzard said:
I thought it was never revealed who Ohba really was.
Not officially (i.e. by the Shûeisha), but considering the evidence, there's no reason to doubt anymore... Ôba/Gamô doesn't even try to hide it.
 

Geneijin

Member
Izayoi said:
Pfft. Claiming that I would post it once in every new anime season thread? If that's work I want a job in that.
Oh, you meant work as in working? Of course not. I simply meant work as you exerted effort to get that tag.

Don't know what other reason gave you that tag, but it seems like that was the reason.
 

Izayoi

Banned
Geneijin said:
It is a given, but your statement as I bolded could be read as such a statement saying HanaIro was one, which is why I wanted to highlight why you got the reactions you did over your statement.
Fair enough, but I wish people would at least take the time to ask what I really meant if there was any confusion instead of immediately grabbing the torches and pitchforks.

Erigu said:
No, just something I often see when it comes to stuff like this...
(not sure what's "Engrish" about "Holo" though... or "Horo" for that matter)
Anywhere that interchangeable "r" or "l" shows up Engrish comes into play, especially with names that are not supposed to be Japanese. Horo sounds more natural and "Japanese" to me than Holo does, which comes across as forced and awkward. It's a matter of preference more than anything. I get that they want the name to sound foreign, but that doesn't mean they have to make it sound stupid.

Geneijin said:
Oh, you meant work as in working? Of course not. I simply meant work as you exerted effort to get that tag.

Don't know what other reason gave you that tag, but it seems like that was the reason.
That's what I'm saying. I exerted zero effort in obtaining my tag. My merely having an opinion and stating that I would repeat my opinion at some point down the line I acquired a tag. I've seen elaborate joke threads and all kinds of crazy stuff in efforts to get tags, whereas I did virtually nothing in comparison.
 

Articalys

Member
And finally, I shall link the whole discussion back to the current season of anime (even though it kind of already was, but whatever) like so:

mxeRV.jpg


Ami Koshimizu ftw

now to go and actually watch Spice and Wolf
 

Geneijin

Member
Izayoi said:
Fair enough, but I wish people would at least take the time to ask what I really meant if there was any confusion instead of immediately grabbing the torches and pitchforks.
True, but, to be fairer (just wanted to say that), how often will people do that? People will seldom ask that initially unless something prompts someone to ask "joke post?" or the alike.

That's what I'm saying. I exerted zero effort in obtaining my tag. My merely having an opinion and stating that I would repeat my opinion at some point down the line I acquired a tag. I've seen elaborate joke threads and all kinds of crazy stuff in efforts to get tags, whereas I did virtually nothing in comparison.
Then you must have missed the other efforts where people did almost nothing to gain their tags e.g. tag fishing threads. There's someone who got his tag for never posting in the related thread (I forget who).

Besides, you're working to maintain your tag right now by holding onto your opinion. I hope it isn't a horrific defeat or a hollow victory
Yeah, it's bad! Leave me be.
 

Solune

Member
Izayoi said:
Fair enough, but I wish people would at least take the time to ask what I really meant if there was any confusion instead of immediately grabbing the torches and pitchforks.
To be fair though when the episode with "fanservice" first showed up alot of posters already expressed their distaste, you're just lttp and there are more defenders of the show around now.

Me, I just laugh since it had no effect on me.
 
Geneijin said:
True, but, to be fairer (just wanted to say that), how often will people do that? People will seldom ask that initially unless something prompts someone to ask "joke post?" or the alike.


Then you must have missed the other efforts where people did almost nothing to gain their tags e.g. tag fishing threads. There's someone who got his tag for never posting in the related thread (I forget who).

Besides, you're working to maintain your tag right now by holding onto your opinion. I hope it isn't a horrific defeat or a hollow victory
Yeah, it's bad! Leave me be.

hurr hurr.


At least it wasn't anything shipping related....
 

Joule

Member
Dog Days 5: Not bad but I was hoping for some more full length fights considering how they set 3 separate battles in the last episode. Insert song~ At least Horie can sing pretty good. Nothing I really wanted to gif this episode either. : (

Hidan no Aria 3: I wonder how many more Speed bomb situations they'll go through before the season is over. Jeez.
 

DrForester

Kills Photobucket
Holo would be the greatest troll ever if not for the fact that Lawrence is actually smart enough to troll her a few times too (never nearly as well though)
 
DrForester said:
Holo would be the greatest troll ever if not for the fact that Lawrence is actually smart enough to troll her a few times too (never nearly as well though)

At least he's improving.


Because of the shame?

Maybe :p

Its just i don't remember the fans of Rei on here saying anything else about it but hey.
 

hellclerk

Everything is tsundere to me
Infinite Justice said:
Maybe :p

Its just i don't remember the fans of Rei on here saying anything else about it but hey.
I don't even watch it for Rie. I watch it because it's fucking hilarious, awesome, and badass. I was expecting bad tsunderes and gun porn going in, and by God I got it! What I didn't expect was what a deliciously brilliant camp the plot turned out to be. It's one of those So-Bad-It's-Good blood pumping action shows. Not quite as good with the style as stuff like Shoot 'Em Up, but this is a serial television show. I think they're doing a great job with their material and format.
 
doomed1 said:
I don't even watch it for Rie. I watch it because it's fucking hilarious, awesome, and badass. I was expecting bad tsunderes and gun porn going in, and by God I got it! What I didn't expect was what a deliciously brilliant camp the plot turned out to be. It's one of those So-Bad-It's-Good blood pumping action shows. Not quite as good with the style as stuff like Shoot 'Em Up, but this is a serial television show. I think they're doing a great job with their material and format.

Well i did already single you out as watching it (since you posted that you dug it) so you don't have to defend yourself. :)

Its just the other's zeroshiki implied that i'm wondering about.


I'll possibly check it out eventually.
 

zeroshiki

Member
DrForester said:
He is one of the smartest male leads in Anime like Spice and Wolf. He holds his ground, and isn't the bubbling fanboy most male's in anime become.

He also isn't useless and celibate and takes as much as Holo gives.

Infinite Justice said:
Well i did already single you out as watching it (since you posted that you dug it) so you don't have to defend yourself. :)
Its just the other's zeroshiki implied that i'm wondering about.

Geneijin has some kind of death pact with crappy anime this season.

Geneijin said:
I'm up to Episode 3.

See.
 
DrForester said:
He is one of the smartest male leads in Anime like Spice and Wolf. He holds his ground, and isn't the bubbling fanboy most male's in anime become.


zeroshiki said:
He also isn't useless and celibate and takes as much as Holo gives.

True but he can be really "one-track minded" at times due to his trade but at least he realizes that fault also.

Season 3 plz since the novels are done now :( :(


Geneijin said:
That, and not enough people to talk to about it.

Infinite Stratos was so special.


I'm up to Episode 3.


Lol but i could see that as a reason since IS had Dresden, ABF, macodin, etc chatting.
 

hellclerk

Everything is tsundere to me
zeroshiki said:
Its a terrible show with crappy production values and a non-sensical story.
Actually no, it's production values are pretty damned good, hilari-bad CG aside (and even that adds to the charm). I mean, I don't disagree that it's a terrible show, but that's sort of why I like it: It's so bad, it's AWESOME. I just enjoy it for what it is.
 

Izayoi

Banned
Well, if it says something, Shana is
my waifu
and I could not stomach watching HnA. I'll give it one more episode, but the production values are some of the worst this season, and with stuff like Ore-tachi, that's saying something. JCStaff is a blight upon this world. Just like how they started Merry awesome but then flew straight into the fucking ground for the last half.

I'm hoping JCStaff loses the license to Shana and Ufotable announces that they're doing S3 with all of the old voice cast or something.

Actually, I'll take anyone but JCStaff. Please, someone, anyone. ;_;
 

hellclerk

Everything is tsundere to me
Izayoi said:
Well, if it says something, Shana is
my waifu
and I could not stomach watching HnA. I'll give it one more episode, but the production values are some of the worst this season, and with stuff like Ore-tachi, that's saying something. JCStaff is a blight upon this world. Just like how they started Merry awesome but then flew straight into the fucking ground for the last half.

I'm hoping JCStaff loses the license to Shana and Ufotable announces that they're doing S3 with all of the old voice cast or something.

Actually, I'll take anyone but JCStaff. Please, someone, anyone. ;_;
Except that Shakagana no Shana is NOTHING like Hidan no Aria. The former is a relatively sane (if kind of inane) Tsundere magical girl meets MacGuffin boy. While Hidan no Aria is pretty much the same in terms of plot basis, it's totally insane. It does such over-the-top things with a stupid grin on its face with no apologies while back-flipping over explosions shooting two high caliber handguns with pinpoint accuracy. It is in no way realistic, smart, sane, inane, or good. But fuck me sideways if it isn't totally AWESOME. SnS by its tone, pacing, more muted character writing, and predominance of character drama told me to take it seriously. Aria has none of what SnS had. Aria has Hollywood Action Movie pacing, the tone of a show staring Jon Claud Van Damm, Wesley Snipes, Vin Diesel, AND Steven Seagal, extremes of character, and enough explosions to make Michael Bay blush.

Hidan no Aria is just plain dumb fun.
 

Geneijin

Member
zeroshiki said:
Geneijin has some kind of death pact with crappy anime this season.
It's anything but a death pact. I don't believe I've admitted to any of the sort!

Infinite Justice said:
Lol but i could see that as a reason since IS had Dresden, ABF, macodin, etc chatting.
Don't forget the anime thread is a long look through and this is GAF where OTs like TWGOK, Gosick, Legend of Legendary Heroes, etc - died.

Doesn't explain OreImo though :lol

doomed1 said:
Hidan no Aria is just plain dumb fun.
I don't know about plain dumb fun, but I do agree the lack of a serious tone (mostly) makes it easier to accept things happening and follow without as much of a discriminating eye if one finds joy in those sort of animes.

zeroshiki said:
I will laugh maniacally if what Izayoi asks actually happens and its DEEN.

Hey, they did FSN, right?
Yep, and UBW, which needs to disappear. I've been scarred by that face.
 

zeroshiki

Member
DEEN basically had a license to print money and (I assume) a huge budget for FSN and UBW and they still fucked it up. That's not easy to do.
 

Jex

Member
Geneijin said:
I'm not in either Holo or Horo faction.
So you start one war, but now you're in team neutral?
Izayoi said:
On the contrary, "Holo" comes across as horrendously Engrish to me. Say it out loud. It's awkward and does not roll off the tongue very well. "Horo" is much more natural.
I see this issue isn't very important, at all!
 

Jex

Member
Izayoi said:
Iroha is nothing like Aria. It's a slice of life starring three young girls, that's the only similarity. Iroha is perverted and has real conflict, things which are not present in Aria.
Hey now. It's a classy show!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom