-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Starfield has 'Mixed' reviews on Steam (Up: 'Recent' reviews are Mostly Negative)
IFireflyl
Gold Member
TransTrender
Gold Member
Wow
Not even top 25 on SteamCharts while BG3 is #5
Not even top 25 on SteamCharts while BG3 is #5
Clintizzle
Lord of Edge.
Let's hope with the release of Spiderman 2 the crazies in this forum can enjoy gaming and get over their obsessive pile on for Starfield or even Forza 
Drizzlehell
Banned
GHG
Gold Member
Let's hope with the release of Spiderman 2 the crazies in this forum can enjoy gaming and get over their obsessive pile on for Starfield or even Forza
Spiderman 2 likely isn't releasing on Steam for another 18 months at least.
This still has legs.
Darkness_Arises
Member
So.................do a lot of you sit around and watch other forum members sit around and watch numbers or do you acutally play?
newtypepilot
Member
now 64% LOL
DonkeyPunchJr
World’s Biggest Weeb
I enjoyed the game but reflecting back on my experience, I agree with most of the criticism. It very much feels like a Bethesda RPG, with space combat and planet exploration taking the place of the open-world traversal.
I think it’s still worth playing if that sounds like your thing.
I think it’s still worth playing if that sounds like your thing.
alucard0712_rus
Banned
Wait, people played Baldur's Gate 3 for more hours than GTAV? Or it's relatively new on Steam?Wow
Not even top 25 on SteamCharts while BG3 is #5
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
In the last 30 days, yes.
Last edited:
Daneel Elijah
Member
This is only for the more recent ones. Since launch we are still around 68%.
RGB'D
Member
The discussion now has more bias in it than ever before. Anecdotally I am enjoying Starfield more than Skyrim or FO4. Play it for yourself and form your own opinion. The SONY bias is pervasive though and SF is getting way more criticism than it would have as a multiplat so the noise is less reliable. It would probably be just as hyped alongside SM2 and people would be bragging that the PS5 version was less buggy.
Zuzu
Member
I know this is an older conversation now so sorry to dig this back up but I think you’re right the more I think about. I’ll retract my previous opinion that it’s “casual”. It does allow a good amount of customisation and a variety of builds.
Last edited:
vaibhavpisal
Member
I must say, I am playing it like a casual now. Lol.
Putting points in everything from weapon damage to scanning to crafting to ship/outpost building.
Have spent 100 hrs and at some point said screw it, and now working towards making a character that will do everything.
JackMcGunns
Member
120 hours in. The more you play, the more you realize how little you know. The game is absolutely massive!
Watch this video, in fact follow this channel, there's so much good advice here for beginners
Die Namek Ability
Member
Such strange game design that you have to play for so long to being to have fun or for the game to get good. The team clearly has it in them to make it a fun game so why not do that from the get go and hook the player right away? Would have been better received imo, first impressions as they say
Last edited:
JackMcGunns
Member
Funny take, I didn't have to play all that to like it, that's where I am now because I'm hooked, I've played 120 hours because I love exploration and enjoying these amazing quests, for example and without giving anything away, there's a cyberpunk style quest where you help a pharmaceutical company succeed over its competition, and while you're at it, you can let them experiment on you with implants that can give you permanent powers. Some mission can be stealthy, or gun blazing, others dog fighting in space. The level of customization of your ship which you can build and design from scratch is mind boggling, you can become an unstoppable space pirate if you choose to, or you can decide to build outposts on different planets harvesting resources for incredible amounts of loot and xp, btw none of that is required to beat the main story, but man this sandbox has more to offer than any game I've ever played.
Question, if I had told you that I sunk more hours over time in GTA5, would you have questioned why I needed that many hours to like it?
After enjoying Starfield so much, and despite its many flaws that can be fixed with future patches, like improving loading and allowing you to skip some cutscenes, but despite that, I am convinced without a single doubt that most of the hate towards the game, and I don't mean the dislikes, but the flat out hate and review bombs are tied to its exclusivity.
Die Namek Ability
Member
Your response was to a user that had said they didnt start enjoying it until after a while and that has been a common opinion that i have seen regarding this game. Some folks even recommend rushing the story playthrough so it will be fun on the newgame plus.
It seemed like you were trying to convince the other user more of the same, if that not the case my apologies. If it is the case my response to you is appropriate.
To respond to your GTAV question, i wouldnt think based on your gameplay time that it was a bad game or not fun because thw consensus is that its good from the jump, something im confident starfield could have been but because of a strange game design choice/s is not from the start and you need to invest heavily into it for it to START being enjoying.
DJ12
Member
Beats just sitting there waiting for a patch to actually fix the issues people are complaining about.
2 patches since release, none adding any performance or dlss.
Wouldn't expect any better from Bethesda though.
Torrent of Pork
Banned
I don't think the intro is bad per-se, but if you're shoehorning your expectations of prior BGS gameplay into Starfield it's not going to click. My first few hours were brutal until I stopped treating it like Fallout 4 in space, and just let the game speak for itself.
I restarted my character for different traits, and the first few hours were just as good as everything else.
I restarted my character for different traits, and the first few hours were just as good as everything else.
Topher
Identifies as young
skit_data
Member
I don't think Starfield will ever see that ever green community around it in the way Elder Scrolls and Fallout has. The number of reviews made by content creators deeming it more or less a disappointment is almost bizarre IMO.
Still falling.
Modders have a lot of work to do to change the trajectory of the reviews for this game.
mckmas8808
Mckmaster uses MasterCard to buy Slave drives
I'm curious to see if these customer reviews will hurt the 2nd month sales of the game.
GHG
Gold Member
I really don't understand them launching their games (this and FM) in the state that they have. It's like the only thing they learnt from the Redfall situation was how to manipulate the "professional" review process. The problem with that though is that the truth always comes out.
For example, Forza Motorsport is now the 37th worst game of all time on steam based on user reviews.
Flutta
Banned
Their goal was always to increase GP subs as much and as fast as possible. And for that to happen
Quality will always take a hit. Also it’s MS we’re talking about, if they are willing to sacrifice Halo their biggest franchise no game will matter to them, just throw them out there one after the other and hope for the sub numbers to go up.
Last edited:
vaibhavpisal
Member
Also it’s MS we’re talking about, if they are willing to sacrifice Halo their biggest franchise no game will matter to them, just throw them out there one after the other and hope for the sub numbers to go up.
Masterclass strategy on display here from Xbox.
Pelta88
Member
They're spending hundreds of millions in development cost for a 15 minute PR win. All that to tout meaningless GP numbers that don't amount to growth, revenue, or more importantly profit.
Announcing how many people tried a ip for "free" at launch and how many people are still engaged 30 days post launch paint to vastly different pictures. Redfall, Starfield, Forza, and Halo Infinite are overtly bad games. But if you ask an XBOX guy for an explanation of why these games release in such a shit state they'll tell you... And this is verbatim quote... "But Microsoft are still making money." Sidestepping the question entirely.
Announcing how many people tried a ip for "free" at launch and how many people are still engaged 30 days post launch paint to vastly different pictures. Redfall, Starfield, Forza, and Halo Infinite are overtly bad games. But if you ask an XBOX guy for an explanation of why these games release in such a shit state they'll tell you... And this is verbatim quote... "But Microsoft are still making money." Sidestepping the question entirely.
Last edited:
As much as I love this game there is just one single thing that ruins it for me and it's the limited POI'S when landing on different planets.
I mentioned this last night in another thread and was called out for it but I do genuinely love this game, it's just that the trailer made me think that the discovery element for the 1000 planets would make me want to go out and see what was out there but what's the point when every POI on and planet is exactly the same as the last even down to the different items.
Surely they should have realised this would happen!
It kills the discovery element and my advice to anyone is just stick to the storyline and nothing else.
I mentioned this last night in another thread and was called out for it but I do genuinely love this game, it's just that the trailer made me think that the discovery element for the 1000 planets would make me want to go out and see what was out there but what's the point when every POI on and planet is exactly the same as the last even down to the different items.
Surely they should have realised this would happen!
It kills the discovery element and my advice to anyone is just stick to the storyline and nothing else.
JackMcGunns
Member
I think you're just projecting. "OMG he really likes Starfield, must be fake or an Ad"
If you follow that channel, you'll see that he has a wide variety of games from different platforms that he has played exptensively and covered very nicely. He put in more than 100 hours in Starfield and feels the same way as most people who have invested in the game. Starfield has its quirks, but it's incredibly massive and rewarding, completely underrated from where the Steam score stands.
Last edited:
vaibhavpisal
Member
Just different POI's would be so disappointing. I want different stories added to some planet surfaces.
Whenever you enter a solar system, you see three dots (...) Marking some planets/moons. When you visit those, you will see they have some facility/settlements. But they tend to be some variant of POIs that planet randomly assigns when you land.
My guess is they were going to add quests on planet surface but couldn't due to feature creep/ time limitations.
I would like these to be added. Some variety of quests that tells some story specific to that planet. IMO it will completely change dynamic of exploration in this game and raise it to the status of all time greats. It's obviously made for that.
GHG
Gold Member
I think you're just projecting. "OMG he really likes Starfield, must be fake or an Ad"
*looks at his latest videos*
Not really:
Topher
Identifies as young
*looks at his latest videos*
Not really:
Yeah, I'm seeing primarily Starfield and Skyrim going back the last couple of years. Nothing wrong with that but it is definitely a Bethesda focused channel. I wouldn't call it an "advertisement" though, which is what the comment
JackMcGunns
was responding to was saying. Channel has quite the following focusing on these few games so that is the crowd they are catering to.
JackMcGunns
Member
JackMcGunns
Member
Yeah, I'm seeing primarily Starfield and Skyrim going back the last couple of years. Nothing wrong with that but it is definitely a Bethesda focused channel. I wouldn't call it an "advertisement" though, which is what the comment
Exactly, the guy was implying it was a Microsoft shill or something, as if anyone interested in Starfield or Bethesda games is automatically one or something. I'm really hooked on Stafield, 207 hours now, it's pretty awesome.
GHG
Gold Member
You claimed the following:
Which is factually untrue.
This is the channel description:
Additionally:
- The last time he covered a game that isn't Starfield was 3 months ago (other games have come out since then)
- The last time he covered a game that isn't a Bethesda one was over 2 years ago (even then it was fleeting).
Yeah, I'm seeing primarily Starfield and Skyrim going back the last couple of years. Nothing wrong with that but it is definitely a Bethesda focused channel. I wouldn't call it an "advertisement" though, which is what the comment
These types of channels get preferential treatment and exclusive/early access for the type of work that they do (heap praise on a particular studio/franchise). If you're looking for anything impartial then those aren't the types of places to go looking. It is what it is.
Last edited:
JackMcGunns
Member
You claimed the following:
Which is factually untrue.
This is the channel description:
Additionally:
They are pretty much an extension of the Bethesda press office (much like Vaatividya is for From Software). So I don't know who you're attempting to kid here.
- The last time he covered a game that isn't Starfield was 3 months ago (other games have come out since then)
- The last time he covered a game that isn't a Bethesda one was over 2 years ago (even then it was fleeting).
These types of channels get preferential treatment and exclusive/early access for the type of work that they do (heap praise on a particular studio/franchise). If you're looking for anything impartial then those aren't the types of places to go looking. It is what it is.
Are you following? The guy implied it was a MS shill trying to advertise Stafield, that's disengenous. Are they Bethesda fans? Yes. Are Bethesda games worthy of a following? Yes. Are they MS shills? NO. Was the video an Ad? NO
Ok, then.
GHG
Gold Member
Looking at their content they are very much acting marketing officers for all things Bethesda. There's nothing wrong with it since that's how they've built their following and I'm sure they are a valuable resource for fans of Bethesda's games, but let's call a spade a spade.
This would be like attempting to argue Vaati is impartial when it comes to souls games when the fact is that From Software use him for 3rd party marketing endeavours. All the video's on the channel you linked are of similar nature.
Topher
Identifies as young
I don't disagree with any of that. As you showed, they admit right out of the gate that they are Bethesda aligned. But I watch channels like these all the time for games I'm playing because they give out good information. That's the advantage these sites have focusing on so few games. Now if the video above was a Starfield review then I could understand anyone scoffing at what would undoubtedly be a 10/10 rating. That video was more informative than promotional to me. These "10 things I wish I knew" videos are very common on youtube.
GHG
Gold Member
There's nothing wrong with the nature of the video, however attempting to claim that the channel covers a variety of games and that they can be seen to be impartial is laughable:
The above just isn't accurate in any way shape or form. Why even attempt to make it seem like the person/people running it are your average gamer?
The channel itself makes it clear they are compromised for goodness sake.
Last edited:
JackMcGunns
Member
So any game that has a following just means the followers are tribal and are trying to advertise it? Nintendo fans praising BOTW or TOTK should basically be ignored and we must presume it's just a mid game if you're not a Nintendo fan? because that's basically what you're implying.
The reason I posted the video to begin with was to help someone playing Starfield for the first time, there were many useful things I wish I knew before playing the game. I'm having a hard time understand what the problem is here.
GHG
Gold Member
I've made it clear that the issue is with your framing of the nature of their channel rather than the content itself.
JackMcGunns
Member
And I made it clear that I was replying to someone that was playing the game and I was being helpful by giving him tips on the 10 basic things he should know about the game. It's a good guide for beginners of Stafield, not a Stafield review. Some looney then was like "OH MY... what is this advertisement" and here we are
Last edited:
Similar threads
- Locked