Via FT Alphaville, Cullen Roche likes what I said in todays column except that its too political, and then asks why I dont call for a temporary cut in payroll taxes, which Republicans, who love tax cuts, would support.
Um, this kind of thing is why you have to be political to have any grasp of reality.
I mean, theres good reason on economic grounds to be skeptical about the effectiveness of temporary tax cuts as stimulus; Milton Friedmans permanent income hypothesis tells us that much of such cuts will be saved, not spent. But leave that on one side, and consider a point Mr. Roche doesnt seem aware of: Republicans have already rejected a payroll tax cut.
Remember, the Obama administration extracted such a cut as the price for its surrender on the Bush tax cuts and it has been trying to get that cut extended, as the only economic stimulus it considers politically possible. And the GOP has turned it down flat.
How can that be, when Republicans love tax cuts? The answer is, they dont. They love tax cuts for the rich. Tax cuts for ordinary workers, many of whom will be those hated lucky duckies whose incomes are too low to pay income tax, are if anything something Republicans dislike.
Also, the GOP is against any idea that (a) comes from Obama (b) might help the economy before the 2012 election.
Again, this is why you have to pay attention to politics. Straight economics is necessary, but wont get you to the full reality.