• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Suicide Squad Review Thread: As Fresh As Green Lantern!

Status
Not open for further replies.
K

KingBroly

Banned
I thought it was alright. I think the lack of a consistent tone hurts it most for me. It really drags in the middle, and the tone there is where it drags. I think the casting was pretty great overall. Writing was...okay, except for the tone dragging it in a certain direction.

There was one line in the entire movie that made go 'really? That seems very out of character' near the end. It just sticks out at you and makes you shake your head.

Leto's Joker, honestly, while pretty good, the character felt out of place for me in this movie.

So...I'd say this is a 6.5/10 movie. Good to Okay, not great. Enjoyable, maybe not memorable.
 
B

Blader

Member
BronsonLee said:
I tend to view critic reviews as one part of whether I'll like a movie; most of them don't share my tastes, so I'll mostly just use them as a barometer for what kind of a movie I should expect. Personally, it feels like they're taking Squad to task for flaws that they let slip by on earlier comic-book films; endless army, unnecessary save the world plot, that kind of thing.
Click to expand...

I haven't really seen many reviews single these out the primary problems of the movie. A lot of the biggest criticisms I've seen are aimed at the editing, pacing, tone, character balance, superfluous Joker, etc.

Even still, I wouldn't say cannon fodder enemies or a big bad threat from the sky or destruction porn were problems that slipped by anyone in earlier movies. The first couple times you see that shit in a superhero movie, it's cool; by the 10th and 11th times, it's pretty tired. Granted Marvel has done that in more movies than Fox or WB/DC have, but at least they're starting to change things up. So maybe SS is only WB's third movie in this series, and maybe Apocalypse is the first time X-Men did the mass destruction thing, but these movies don't exist in a vacuum. If you were getting tired of that shit in Marvel's movies, you're gonna be really tired of it now in other studios' movies.
 
S

skelekey

Member
So Jahns, Angry Joe, and The black nerd seem pretty positive on the movie and the rotten tomatoes audience score is pretty high. the metacritic isn't too bad and the user score is good there as well. I think I'm going to go see it.
 
A

AlfredX1990

Banned
As fresh as Green Lantern, but were there standing ovations?

skelekey said:
So Jahns, Angry Joe, and The black nerd seem pretty positive on the movie and the rotten tomatoes audience score is pretty high. the metacritic isn't too bad and the user score is good there as well. I think I'm going to go see it.
Click to expand...

You think the audience score is high? BvS began at 95% audience score, SS began at 75%, audience score means nothing the first month
 
S

Spine_Ripper

Member
KingBroly said:
There is one line in the entire movie that made go 'really? That seems very out of character' near the end. It just sticks out at you and makes you shake your head.
Click to expand...

Was it
YOU ARE EVIL!!!]
?

Because that literally made me lol. I get what they were going for, but man that execution was bad.
 
J

Jarmel

Banned
Blader said:
Even still, I wouldn't say cannon fodder enemies or a big bad threat from the sky or destruction porn were problems that slipped by anyone in earlier movies. The first couple times you see that shit in a superhero movie, it's cool; by the 10th and 11th times, it's pretty tired. Granted Marvel has done that in more movies than Fox or WB/DC have, but at least they're starting to change things up. So maybe SS is only WB's third movie in this series, and maybe Apocalypse is the first time X-Men did the mass destruction thing, but these movies don't exist in a vacuum. If you were getting tired of that shit in Marvel's movies, you're gonna be really tired of it now in other studios' movies.
Click to expand...

Someone correct me if I'm wrong but the last Marvel movie to go ham on the destruction porn was really Avengers 2 and it got taken to task for that. Recent Marvel movies don't follow that trend going off Ant Man, Civil War, Iron Man 3, Winter Soldier, and GotG to some extent. The weaker Marvel movies do the cannon fodder stuff and they usually get dinged pretty harshly as a result.
 
K

kurahador

Member
Jarmel said:
Someone correct me if I'm wrong but the last Marvel movie to go ham on the destruction porn was really Avengers 2 and it got taken to task for that. Recent Marvel movies don't follow that trend going off Ant Man, Civil War, Iron Man 3, Winter Soldier, and GotG to some extent. The weaker Marvel movies do the cannon fodder stuff and they usually get dinged pretty harshly as a result.
Click to expand...

MCU only change things up when it comes to final battle starting with Ant-Man.

And it looks like Doctor Strange will follow by doing its own thing.
 
O

Operations

Member
Watched it last night. Everything was terrible, but what really irked me was just how off was the soundtrack in general, didn't match the atmosphere or the scenes at all. An army, march-like theme for a stealth scene? What?
 
Q

quiksilver1209

Neo Member
Saw the movie last night. I had the same feeling about this movie as when I left the theater from BvS. There is a great movie in there somewhere, but for me at least the pacing was all over the place and felt that some characters weren't really used at all and almost not really important(Katana). Harley and Deadshot were the main attractions for me and I enjoyed it for the most part. Leto's Joker wasn't around long enough for me to give an honest opinion about it but I thought he was cool. I really liked Captain boomarang and Croc for what scenes they did have.

I kind of wish they went with an Assault on Arkham type story instead of this plot. Also some of the music that was used in some scenes seemed out of place and some of the jokes seemed forced. I really hope we get to see an ultimate cut, but I doubt it.
 
S

Schlorgan

Member
skelekey said:
So Jahns, Angry Joe, and The black nerd seem pretty positive on the movie and the rotten tomatoes audience score is pretty high. the metacritic isn't too bad and the user score is good there as well. I think I'm going to go see it.
Click to expand...
The Metacritic is 41%...
 
J

jorgejjvr

Member
BronsonLee said:
Ok, let's strap in.

I'm pretty easy to please when it comes to films. I live 5 minutes away from a nice movie theater; I'll watch anything from He Named Me Malala to Furious 7, and usually come away pretty satisfied. It's hard for me to not like a film. Even stuff like Transformers 3, which was a stupid ass movie, has something that appeals to me, like the absolute carnage that happens in Chicago.

For Suicide Squad, it's pretty easy to recognize the flaws in it, but to me, it was a ton of fun to watch. And it was never boring; something that basically every movie this summer totally fanned on.

It's a loud movie. All the character intros are extremely colorful, full of bombast, and do a pretty decent job on filling us in on the backstory (though I still would've vastly preferred these characters to show up in previous movies, but alas). They felt well thought out, and for the most part, all had hooks to them.

The action is OK. I generally prefer WB's way of shooting films over most studios, so they're still quite on point there, but it could've been better on the action front itself. The movie shines the most to me when they're focusing on the core concepts of either the Squad (bad guys forced into doing good), or the characters themselves. My favorite scene wasn't even a big setpiece or large scale battle (two things that I'm unsure as to why the movie needed them), but a small bar scene. Banter between extraordinary people is still intriguing to me.

I don't really think there were any misfires, casting wise. Will seems back in leading man mode, though I probably would've preferred more of a focus on him, to be honest. Margot is excellent, pretty good emotional anchor. El Diablo's subplot is solid. Boomerang and Croc seem like they're there to troll, which is fine. Katana didn't do too much, and neither did Joker, which makes all the heat about the latter seem kinda dumb. Your highlights are probably Harley/Deadshot/Waller, in that order.

I tend to view critic reviews as one part of whether I'll like a movie; most of them don't share my tastes, so I'll mostly just use them as a barometer for what kind of a movie I should expect. Personally, it feels like they're taking Squad to task for flaws that they let slip by on earlier comic-book films; endless army, unnecessary save the world plot, that kind of thing.

I'd say Squad starts off well, stumbles a bit in the middle, but gets to the finish line in a solid way (probably due to the reshoots). It's a fun ass movie. Perfect for a matinee if you're bored. It feels like more the product of people's hype being deflated versus the actual quality of the film itself, which is no more egregious than most summer films.

Me? I'll go watch it again tomorrow. I'm a sucker like that.
Click to expand...

Glad to hear!

Watching it tonight, excited
 
A

Ahiru77

Member
Went to the film before the reviews. Had an awesome time.

LOVED: the Suicide Squad (Everyone rocked!!! Especially the main hitters Will Smith, Margot Robbie and Viola Davis!!!)
DISLIKED: The Joker (too slimy and childish), the major mission/the main villain (too simple and cartoony for what could have been an more psychologically challenging movie.)



But reading the reviews.....oh my word....
n0J2wKA.gif


It's like a personal vendetta or something. I feel so bad.
 
H

Hubbl3

Unconfirmed Member
Killer Queen said:
I think I'll go see this on Saturday but I ain't got no friends. How awkward is it seeing a movie alone?
Click to expand...

I don't find it awkward in the least bit and I actually prefer going to the movies alone. I'll usually watch a movie I really want to see by myself and then I'll go see it a 2nd time with the lady friend or with some buddies.
 
B

BronsonLee

Member
Civil War & Deadpool came out too early to count in that, IMO

If we include them it's Civil War, if not then it's Suicide Squad because Jason Bourne fucking shit the bed while traveling back in time to 2002 for the same plot
 
P

Phediuk

Member
So, just got back from this and yep, it's probably the worst movie I've seen this year.

Congrats, BvS. You're finally better than something.
 
Y

Yeezus H. Christ

Banned
pestul said:
On SchmoesKnow live show last night, JTE said that he knows an insider that actually viewed the original Ayer cut earlier this year. This was around the time people were leaking that it was a complete mess. Apparently the Ayer original had a lot more violence with Croc and a much darker tone. It didn't have the popular music at all. The BvS reception did influence the final theatrical version. JTE is very trustworthy.
Click to expand...

is he trustworthy enough that if he says his friend told him an early Dr. Strange screening was 'breathtaking', that we should believe him?
 
K

Killer Queen

Banned
broncobuster said:
Matinee showing?
Click to expand...
Nah, I changed my mind and think I'll go tonight, I've literally done nothing but play TLOU all week so I think I should get out a bit. But you guys are right there's really no difference compared to going with someone and usually when I go with someone they talk or are on their phone.
 
P

PBY

Banned
Phediuk said:
So, just got back from this and yep, it's probably the worst movie I've seen this year.

Congrats, BvS. You're finally better than something.
Click to expand...
Agreed. Just flat out incompetent.

Can't remember a film I've disliked this much in a while.
 
B

BLACKLAC

Member
pestul said:
On SchmoesKnow live show last night, JTE said that he knows an insider that actually viewed the original Ayer cut earlier this year. This was around the time people were leaking that it was a complete mess. Apparently the Ayer original had a lot more violence with Croc and a much darker tone. It didn't have the popular music at all. The BvS reception did influence the final theatrical version. JTE is very trustworthy.
Click to expand...

Link?
 
D

Dead

well not really...yet
pestul said:
On SchmoesKnow live show last night, JTE said that he knows an insider that actually viewed the original Ayer cut earlier this year. This was around the time people were leaking that it was a complete mess. Apparently the Ayer original had a lot more violence with Croc and a much darker tone. It didn't have the popular music at all. The BvS reception did influence the final theatrical version. JTE is very trustworthy.
Click to expand...
jesus, that's so fucking disappointing
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Rocksteady hit by layoffs after Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League underperforms
2 3
131
6K
Drew1440 replied
Suicide Squad: Kill The Justice League Gets First Big Discount
2
67
5K
Quasicat replied
‘Arkham Knight’ Now Has More Players Than ‘Suicide Squad: Kill The Justice League’ On Steam
Drama Community
34
3K
Shin-Ra replied
Suicide : Squad; Kill The Justice League | Review Thread
Analysis Review 4 5 6 7 8
355
31K
Certinty replied
Suicide Squad: Kill The Justice League |OT| Sent to Die
18 19 20 21 22
1K
65K
T-0800 replied
Top Bottom