-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Suicide Squad Review Thread: As Fresh As Green Lantern!
- Thread starter Future Foundation
- Start date
- Status
Doctoglethorpe
Member
That's the Internet.
I really liked it. But I'm salty as all Hell apparently.
Killer Queen
Banned
No one is forcing you to go see it you know. If you don't think it's worth it then just don't go. I consider it to be a 6 elevated to a 7 due to some performances and the style of the movie and I don't feel like I wasted my time, of someone else decides that it's not for them and doesn't wanna go see it that's fine too. Not every opinion is an endorsement, just an opinion stating their thoughts.
orthodoxy1095
Banned
I wonder if you'd be whining about the "hivemind" if it was a consensus good flick.
🤔
Killer Queen
Banned
Arguably someone would.
heliosRAzi
Banned
You can go ahead and like a movie with a shoddy story, thin characters, unearned moments, and shit dialogue, I won't stop you.
orthodoxy1095
Banned
Sure, and to that person we could ask "would you be complaining if this was a consensus bad/divisive flick?"
BronsonLee
Member
Galactic Specter
Member
Is the finale of this movie really a CGI shitstorm?
Killer Queen
Banned
Is this what elitism looks like? Dude let it go you're just being silly at this point. You didn't like it, great, but why shit on those who did like it by going "NO IM RIGHT, ITS BAD BAD BAD AND NO ONE CAN SAY OR FEEL OTHERWISE". Like seriously.
Yes.
Just seems like a roundabout argument.
hemo memo
You can't die before your death
Not really. Actually who watched it with me didn't agree when I said the story was bad. The 3 of them. So opinions.
it's almost the most generic version of that you can imagine.
Plenty of people liked The Avengers.
Broken Joystick
At least you can talk. Who are you?
heliosRAzi
Banned
Exactly! Still, it's more competent than Suicide Squad.
Diablo saying that the squad is his family is really unearned. He just met those people a few hours prior and didn't do much.
True, and definitely skewed higher than the RT average of 4.7/10. I'll admit that I haven't seen it yet, and I will, but man how does someone give it a 2/10. Can it possibly be that bad? I'm just shocked impressions are going back and forth between "it's pretty good" and "it's a f'ing shitshow". And you know, I don't think people are bandwagoning. I believe these are honest to goodness opinions.
MrPhiliasfrog
Member
orthodoxy1095
Banned
Not really. It's just pointing out the hypocrisy of whoever is making that stupid comment.
bob_arctor
Tough_Smooth
Deadshot
earned the right to see his daughter, I will tell you that much. The epilogue scene was really well done. Hell, Harley finally getting back with Joker in the break out as well for that matter.
@Playstation
Pre-order Suicide Squad at PS Store for a free rental of Batman: Assault on Arkham & a theme https://t.co/93hvTZy8JA https://t.co/qbtfXIQaQK
Pre-order Suicide Squad at PS Store for a free rental of Batman: Assault on Arkham & a theme https://t.co/93hvTZy8JA https://t.co/qbtfXIQaQK
……forgetit
Member
I liked it, not so bad, not very good either, but not as bad as I expected. I feel bad for Jared Leto and I think it's funny that Killer Crocs only character is that he's a black guy.
I mean when Waller asks what they want for saving the day he says
for God's sake.
I mean when Waller asks what they want for saving the day he says
BET
ShutterMunster
Junior Member
The hell are you talking about? Pulp Fiction's narrative approach was groundbreaking. Don't confuse plot simplicity with poor execution.
Also Walter Chaw's review is LIFE: http://www.filmfreakcentral.net/ffc/2016/08/suicide-squad.html
The later won't forgive SS's major technical (from a filmmaking pov) sins, just because the cosplay and few line deliveries were done well, or "bah, it's a superhero movie!"
The former can, and finds the skin level context to be enough to have fun with what the film does deliver.
It's completely reasonable, both sides, and had these been superheroes/villains with better pedigree (Joker was barely in it) I probably would have been slightly easier on it myself. But fucking rope guy and boomerang man, lawl.
Killer Queen
Banned
"Worst movie ever" is definitely hyperbolic. But I can see why some people didnt like it and I can see why some people really didn't like it. Some people's negatives are my positives, it's just a highly subjective film. I liked the subjective things and they were strong enough to allow me to look past the objective stuff. But for those that don't i can see why they'd consider it a shit show. It's really something you need to see for yourself.
I didn't say that it was poorly executed. It just wasn't front and center or that deep which is my point, it's not what carries the film, it's style and characters do. Stop over reacting.
bob_arctor
Tough_Smooth
Now we badmouthing Digger Harkness!?? Oh helllll naw!!!
heliosRAzi
Banned
I wouldn't put Joker breaking out Harley in that, but Deadshot getting family time with his daughter definitely counts. That was earned.
hemo memo
You can't die before your death
Yeah to be honest that was weird to me too.
Boombloxer
Member
The hyperbole can stop. It's not the worst movie ever...but might be the worst you see this year.
Except shit like Apocalypse and Gods of Egypt also came out this year.
dancingphlower
Member
Gordon Shumway
Banned
But I skipped both of those!
Theatrical, I agree.And Batman v Superman
Caffeine
Gold Member
you saved yourself haha
George Oscar Bluth II
Banned
Hahaha, damn. That was a great read.
ZackieChan
Member
ayyyy lmao. Pulp Fiction has god-tier story. Nothing "weak" about it.
Killer Queen
Banned
So if you wanna go back to the last page then come back.
I'm glad Harley played a big part, but if they bring her and deadshot back for another movie, they should play the Harley character straighter to her source material. Harley is best when she's on her own, in the scenes where Joker is around, she becomes a nobody who is overshadowed by him.
And when the relationship is not played as abusive, its worse because then she is without her main motivating factor.
She's not defined by being Joker's love interest but as a person continuing a cycle of self destruction who needs to inevitably break her habit to become better.
Also, Dead shot was cool, it was Will being Will as usual. I wanted to see more from Flame guy as he was the only decent dude in the movie. And Amanda was great too as a Kiritsugu type.
I thought the movie was a decent 7 out of 10. Def not the worst movie ever. It was much better than BvS in any case
And when the relationship is not played as abusive, its worse because then she is without her main motivating factor.
She's not defined by being Joker's love interest but as a person continuing a cycle of self destruction who needs to inevitably break her habit to become better.
Also, Dead shot was cool, it was Will being Will as usual. I wanted to see more from Flame guy as he was the only decent dude in the movie. And Amanda was great too as a Kiritsugu type.
I thought the movie was a decent 7 out of 10. Def not the worst movie ever. It was much better than BvS in any case
Maybe the worst you have to see and make up your own opinion on. j/k
Now I love the DC TV shows but the film universe is turning into a trainwreck. It'll no doubt be profitable for DC and WB but fans will rapidly lose interest and wonder what the point of spending $200 million on films with Will Smith and Ben Affleck and Margot Robbie and all those special effects when the end result is a messy script, poorly developed characters and bad editing.
Can you imagine the entire film series never having a genuinely good movie? It'll be like the Underworld or Resident Evil movies. Or like hoping that the next video game film adaptation won't suck. You'd just keep hoping and then after repeatedly being disappointed you'd just give up altogether.
Can you imagine the entire film series never having a genuinely good movie? It'll be like the Underworld or Resident Evil movies. Or like hoping that the next video game film adaptation won't suck. You'd just keep hoping and then after repeatedly being disappointed you'd just give up altogether.
Myspcr_Shadow
Member
Orchestrated is indeed what I meant. The more reasons to see the movie asap for me. I was under the impression it was licensed music through out the whole thing and that it was mostly forced and awkward.
ZackieChan
Member
No, I read your other post. Still wrong.
Killer Queen
Banned
Whatever man. Pulp Fiction isn't carried by its story, it's fairly thin and I doubt most of the people that enjoy the film care for it either. It's not bad but it's definitely not the greatest thing ever and that films strengths aren't its story. But we can agree to disagree.
Messofanego
Banned
This was a great read XD
There are people that think the plot and writing is not bad in this? I don't understand how these criminals became allies or how Deadshot becomes the leader of the group. Things in the movie just happen with no development.
I think they needed two movies. One that is mainly about the squad starting to trust each other and built around a smaller scope and a second one that would have enchantress betraying the squad with one or 2 members jumping ship with her. And in the second movie you could have had Batman and Wonder Woman show up.
The biggest problem with DC is that they so badly want to catch up to marvel and have that heroes vs the ultimate villain movie that they are killing themselves.
I think they needed two movies. One that is mainly about the squad starting to trust each other and built around a smaller scope and a second one that would have enchantress betraying the squad with one or 2 members jumping ship with her. And in the second movie you could have had Batman and Wonder Woman show up.
The biggest problem with DC is that they so badly want to catch up to marvel and have that heroes vs the ultimate villain movie that they are killing themselves.
Boombloxer
Member
"You see" is the operative part of the sentence. Didn't see Gods, and Apocalypse is better than this, though not by much.
That review is brutal.
BannedEpisode
Member
Well the cgi, pacing, character development, and editing were all bad too.
So there's that.
Bearjewpiter
Neo Member
I'm going to preface this by saying I like ass, and I like actors playing crazy people.
But can we get Robbie's ass off the screen for more than a moment or two? Or if it's going to be there can she say anything interesting that isn't either a one liner to make her seem "damaged" or reacting to people looking at her ass? No? That's goes for the whole movie. Nice.
Also Leto was a disgrace. How dare you
There was character development?
But can we get Robbie's ass off the screen for more than a moment or two? Or if it's going to be there can she say anything interesting that isn't either a one liner to make her seem "damaged" or reacting to people looking at her ass? No? That's goes for the whole movie. Nice.
Also Leto was a disgrace. How dare you
There was character development?
/s but still. it was awful
- Status