Support NeoGAF

[Raptor]

IS kinda ok but the S is crap, they should have gone with a MoS one, you know the best S ever made.

 

[Bobby Roberts]

IS kinda ok but the S is crap, they should have gone with a MoS one, you know the best S ever made.

No lies detected.

 

[Sibersk Esto]

IS kinda ok but the S is crap, they should have gone with a MoS one, you know the best S ever made.

lol nah

 

[Oregano]

Its not just that it's TV. This show appears to be doing its own thing with the IP and the characters, not following canon as closely as Arrow and Flash. It's fine, I just don't think fanboys are part of the target audience for this one.

Flash is somewhat faithful but Arrow plays very fast and loose with the canon. Changes to Merlyn and Black Canary being two obvious, important ones.

 

[Bobby Roberts]

lol nah

post the best then.

 

[Discotheque]

It's just an off looking promo pic

The first picture they released of man of steel made him look like a jersey boy and yet in the film he looked so much better

Benoist looks good in all the other pics posted in here

 

[Sibersk Esto]

post the best then.

.

 

[Bobby Roberts]

BASIC

 

[munchie64]

.

Nice S.

 

[LaNaranja]

After Flash and Arrow I was really looking forward to this. The costume and the lack of confirmation that this will be in Arrowverse have me super apprehensive. I will give it a chance like I did Gotham but I have a bad feeling.

 

[SoilBreak]

Its not just that it's TV. This show appears to be doing its own thing with the IP and the characters, not following canon as closely as Arrow and Flash. It's fine, I just don't think fanboys are part of the target audience for this one.

But Arrow is loosely following's GA's canon/lore.

 

[flaxknuckles]

For the record I always thought Grant looks stupid as fuck as The Flash (fuckin nerdy pre-spider bite Peter Parker lookin' ass) and his costume looks like low budget trash no matter how many episodes I see. And Melissa just doesn't look like Supergirl to me, it has nothing to do with her attractiveness. Gal Gadot looks beautiful as a mothafucka but she still doesn't look like Wonder Woman to me. Maybe Melissa will look better in the full show (that I won't be watching because superhero tv shows are low budget trash).

 

[Sibersk Esto]

BASIC

I'm old fashioned

 

[More_Badass]

Not sure how you can say that with The Flash currently on the air and going all out up to and including Time Travel.

Pretty much

We got Flash outrunning a nuclear explosion and live-action Reverse Flash, Firestorm, and Grodd all in the same episode.

 

[dan2026]

Why is it so dark and drab looking?

 

[TOM f'N CRUISE]

Meh, they should have gone with her instead

ughhhhhhh good god such beauty

 

[Kilvin]

I like the understated look of it. Approved.

 

[Apt101]

A bit dark. Maybe that works better once it's on a bright film set.

 

[Rooster12]

This is CBS. Nobody should be excited about this.

At worst it's another Smallville.

At best it could have Dragonball Z level action

 

[Hours Left]

Looks good, I like the red leggings.

Now show us what Mehcad Brooks will be wearing.

 

[Raptor]

.

That is old as hell and doesnt even look a character an alien race made, while the MoS S while still keeping the S shape it does indeed look like a something an alien race came up with and I love that.

Sure nostalgia plays a part why that could be considered a classic but not to me, looks yeah very basic.

 

[Konka]

This thread is a bunch of comic nerds judging a woman outfit and the response are just how I would expect.

 

[KDash31987]

ughhhhhhh good god such beauty

https://www.facebook.com/EnjiCosplay

 

[Sibersk Esto]

That is old as hell and doesnt even look a character an alien race made, while the MoS S while still keeping the S shape it does indeed look like a something an alien race came up with and I love that.

Sure nostalgia plays a part why that could be considered a classic but not to me, looks yeah very basic.

Fair enough. I disagree but fair enough

This thread is a bunch of comic nerds judging a woman outfit and the response are just how I would expect.

congratulations

 

[More_Badass]

At worst it's another Smallville.

At best it could have Dragonball Z level action

On a TV budget, live action? Never going to happen

But considering the quality of Flash's effects, the portrayal of powers will definitely be better than Smallville

 

[Kinyou]

I really like this fan costume. Varying shades of blue could add a lot

(^though there also is a lot of Photoshop going on, so maybe it would look less good in live action)

 

[Can Crusher]

while the MoS S while still keeping the S shape it does indeed look like a something an alien race came up with and I love that.

It really doesn't lol

 

[NotTheGuyYouKill]

Not bad. Better than mini-skirt/vagina shield.

 

[OdysseusVA]

This thread is a bunch of comic nerds judging a woman outfit and the response are just how I would expect.

2edgy4me

 

[Hexa]

Not a fan. I wanted something brighter.

Meh, they should have gone with her instead

This without the midriff or less of it would be perfect

 

[Hexa]

Crap double post.

 

[Bobby Roberts]

I really like this fan costume. Varying shades of blue could add a lot

I agree on the varying shades of blue part. They actually use that for the Supersuit in the Smallville comics, and it looks great there.

 

[Raptor]

It really doesn't lol

Ok.

 

[beyond_death]

its.. meh. I dont like the leggings but everything else is just alright. But atleast there is a costume.

 

[Hoya Destroyer]

No exposed leg or midriff is disappointing, but I didnt expect them to go for the sexier look.

Meh, they should have gone with her instead

Like that. Much nicer.

 

[arevin01]

They went with the conservative look. Would have liked to see some more skin.

 

[Shining Sunshine]

The emblem looks like a cheap heat printing.

Also, nylons and the knee high boots look terrible.

 

[Last Hearth]

Costume doesn't bother me so much, but the actress loves nothing like how I envision Supergirl. I am not saying she's unattractive, she might make a decent Barbara Gordon, she's just not Supergirl, and her in the Supergirl cosume just looks off in every way.

 

[Future Foundation]

.

That one's good, this one's so much better. Atwood really should've just added a shield. That's my only real problem with the costume - that or some yellow to the space behind the glyph.

 

[The Shogun]

another.. not by me.

This is some cosplay level crap.

Like I still, hours later, cannot get over how awful that costume looks.

Everything from the waistline down just looks like it was bought from like Goodwill or some thrift shop and thrown together. There is nothing that stands out or catches the eye.

I feel like a full suit / pants look would have gone so much better than the skirt and boots. Or at the very least add some design detail to them.

 

[bryanee]

I think its the best TV superhero costume so far. It looks better than the Flash costume did promo images.

 

[Femmeworth]

Bleh. I'm not a fan of the Man of Steel costume either, though.

 

[Volimar]

I really like this fan costume. Varying shades of blue could add a lot



(^though there also is a lot of Photoshop going on, so maybe it would look less good in live action)

I really like that one as well though it always looks weird to me when girls wear long sleeves with a skirt.

 

[Caboose]

Eh, looks like a cosplayer.

 

[Lashley]

Awful.

Looks so cheap, like a Halloween costume.

 

[Trickster]

Not liking it one bit, the design just looks like a mess, and the actress doesn't look like super girl at all.

 

[sprsk]

Looks like a 1920s cheerleader.

 

[Karsha]

Tbh the photo itself is pretty shitty so can't judge it from that, looks like taken with some phone with all wrong saturation etc.

 

[Ahasverus]

I'm old

I know

It's the belt, the belt looks super cheap.

 

[charsace]

I wish they would have went with something that looks more kryptonian. I never understood why super girl has to wear super man's colors.